Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Justices Seem Ready to OK Asking Citizenship on Census
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 6 years ago on
April 23, 2019

Share

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court’s conservative majority seemed ready Tuesday to uphold the Trump administration’s plan to ask about citizenship on the 2020 census, despite evidence that millions of Hispanics and immigrants could go uncounted.
There appeared to be a clear divide between the court’s liberal and conservative justices in arguments in a case that could affect how many seats states have in the House of Representatives and their share of federal dollars over the next 10 years. States with a large number of immigrants tend to vote Democratic.

Citizenship Question Blocked by Lower Courts

Three lower courts have so far blocked the plan to ask every U.S. resident about citizenship in the census, finding that the question would discourage many immigrants from being counted . Two of the three judges also ruled that asking if people are citizens would violate the provision of the Constitution that calls for a count of the population, regardless of citizenship status, every 10 years. The last time the question was included on the census form sent to every American household was 1950.
But over 80 minutes in a packed courtroom, the conservative justices did not appear to share the concern of the lower court judges.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh, the court’s newest member and an appointee of President Donald Trump, suggested Congress could change the law if it so concerned that the accuracy of the once-a-decade population count will suffer. “Why doesn’t Congress prohibit the asking of the citizenship question?” Kavanaugh asked near the end of the morning session.
Kavanaugh and the other conservatives were mostly silent when Solicitor General Noel Francisco, the administration’s top Supreme Court lawyer, defended Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross’ decision to add the citizenship question. Ross has said the Justice Department wanted the citizenship data, the detailed information it would produce on where eligible voters live, to improve enforcement of the Voting Rights Act.

Liberal Justices Lack Votes to Stop Census Plan

Lower courts found that Ross’ explanation was a pretext for adding the question, noting that he had consulted early in his tenure with Stephen Bannon, Trump’s former top political adviser and immigration hardliner Kris Kobach, the former Kansas secretary of state.
The liberal justices peppered Francisco with questions about the administration plan, but they would lack the votes to stop it without support from at least one conservative justice.
“This is a solution in search of a problem,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the court’s lone Hispanic member, said of Ross’ decision.
Justice Elena Kagan chimed in that “you can’t read this record without sensing that this need was a contrived one.”
Chief Justice John Roberts appeared to have a different view of the information the citizenship question would produce.
“You think it wouldn’t help voting rights enforcement?” Roberts asked New York Solicitor General Barbara Underwood, who was representing states and cities that sued over Ross’ decision.
Underwood said the evidence Ross had before him was “that it would not give better citizenship information.”

Concerns About Accuracy of Count

And, Underwood said, the record is clear that a census that asks people if they are citizens will be less accurate.
Census Bureau experts have concluded that the census would produce a more accurate picture of the U.S. population without a citizenship question because people might be reluctant to say if they or others in their households are not citizens. Federal law requires people to complete the census accurately and fully.
The Supreme Court is hearing the case on a tight timeframe, even though no federal appeals court has yet to weigh in. A decision is expected by late June, in time to print census forms for the April 2020 population count.
The administration argues that the commerce secretary has wide discretion in designing the census questionnaire and that courts should not be second-guessing his action. States, cities and rights groups that sued over the issue don’t even have the right to go into federal court, the administration says. It also says the citizenship question is plainly constitutional because it has been asked on many past censuses and continues to be used on smaller, annual population surveys.

Gorsuch: Other Countries Include Citizenship Question

Justice Neil Gorsuch, also a Trump appointee, also noted that many other countries include citizenship questions on their censuses.
Douglas Letter, a lawyer representing the House of Representatives, said the census is critically important to the House, which apportions its seats among the states based on the results. “Anything that undermines the accuracy of the actual enumeration is immediately a problem,” Letter said, quoting from the provision of the Constitution that mandates a decennial census.
Letter also thanked the court on behalf of Speaker Nancy Pelosi for allowing the House to participate in the arguments.
“Tell her she’s welcome,” Roberts replied.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Operation Assad: The Air Mission to Smuggle the Syrian Despot’s Valuables

DON'T MISS

Mother of Woman Killed by Immigrant Speaks at White House Briefing

DON'T MISS

Lilly Weight-Loss Pill Works as Well as Ozempic, Shares Surge

DON'T MISS

Jung Hoo Lee Stars as the Surging Giants Beat Aaron Nola and the Phillies

DON'T MISS

Moscow Plans to Use Seized US-Owned Company to Feed Russian Army, Document Shows

DON'T MISS

Scientists Find Strongest Evidence yet of Life on an Alien Planet

DON'T MISS

Ohtani Hits 448-Foot Homer in 7-Run 1st Inning, Dodgers Sweep Rockies

DON'T MISS

Ursula Is Beautiful, Athletic, and Seeking Your Companionship

DON'T MISS

EU Announces $1.8 Billion Aid Package for Palestinian Authority

DON'T MISS

How Trump Might Unwittingly Cut Emissions From Online Shopping

UP NEXT

Commercial Salmon Season Is Shut Down Again. Will CA’s Iconic Fish Ever Recover?

UP NEXT

What To Know About California Reparations: Is State’s Apology the Beginning or the End?

UP NEXT

Zoom Down for Thousands of Users, Downdetector Shows

UP NEXT

Puerto Rico Goes Dark After Widespread Power Plant Failure

UP NEXT

Butler, Curry Lead Warriors Past Grizzlies to Secure Seventh Seed in West Playoffs

UP NEXT

Harper and Realmuto Homer to Help Lead the Phillies to a Win Over the Giants

UP NEXT

Will Smith’s 3-Run Homer Sends Dodgers Over Major League-Worst Rockies

UP NEXT

California Is Preparing to Take Trump to Court to Stop His Tariffs

UP NEXT

Retail Sales Rise 1.4% in March as Shoppers Stock Up on Big Ticket Items Ahead of Tariffs

UP NEXT

7 Takeaways: How the DMV Allows Dangerous Drivers to Stay on the Road

Jung Hoo Lee Stars as the Surging Giants Beat Aaron Nola and the Phillies

22 minutes ago

Moscow Plans to Use Seized US-Owned Company to Feed Russian Army, Document Shows

27 minutes ago

Scientists Find Strongest Evidence yet of Life on an Alien Planet

44 minutes ago

Ohtani Hits 448-Foot Homer in 7-Run 1st Inning, Dodgers Sweep Rockies

49 minutes ago

Ursula Is Beautiful, Athletic, and Seeking Your Companionship

53 minutes ago

EU Announces $1.8 Billion Aid Package for Palestinian Authority

1 hour ago

How Trump Might Unwittingly Cut Emissions From Online Shopping

1 hour ago

Trump Slams Fed’s Powell Over Rates, Saying Termination Can’t ‘Come Fast Enough’

1 hour ago

Dollar, US Stocks Find Some Stability as Trade Talks Help the Mood

1 hour ago

Merced’s Own Super Bloom Is Here. How This Grassland Reserve Protects Endangered Species

2 hours ago

Operation Assad: The Air Mission to Smuggle the Syrian Despot’s Valuables

DAMASCUS/LONDON/DUBAI (Reuters) – As his enemies closed in on Damascus, Bashar al-Assad, who ruled over Syria with an iron fist for 24...

4 minutes ago

A satellite image, according to Reuters analysis, shows the C5-SKY jet taxiing to the runway before its flight out of Syria, at Hmeimim air base, Syria December 8, 2024. (2025 Planet Labs PBC/Handout via REUTERS)
4 minutes ago

Operation Assad: The Air Mission to Smuggle the Syrian Despot’s Valuables

Patty Morin, the mother of Rachel Morin who was murdered in 2023, speaks during a briefing for reporters at the White House in Washington, on Wednesday, April 16, 2025. The appearance by Patty Morin came as a federal judge threatened the Trump administration with a contempt-of-court investigation over its deportation flights to El Salvador. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
11 minutes ago

Mother of Woman Killed by Immigrant Speaks at White House Briefing

The logo of Lilly is seen on a wall of the Lilly France company unit, part of the Eli Lilly and Co drugmaker group, in Fegersheim near Strasbourg, France, February 1, 2018. Picture taken February 1, 2018. (REUTERS/Vincent Kessler)
19 minutes ago

Lilly Weight-Loss Pill Works as Well as Ozempic, Shares Surge

22 minutes ago

Jung Hoo Lee Stars as the Surging Giants Beat Aaron Nola and the Phillies

Russian conscripts called up for military service line up during a ceremony before their departure for garrisons, in Bataysk in the Rostov region, Russia, April 10, 2025. (REUTERS File)
27 minutes ago

Moscow Plans to Use Seized US-Owned Company to Feed Russian Army, Document Shows

An illustration shows a hycean world – an exoplanet with a liquid water ocean beneath a hydrogen-rich atmosphere - orbiting a red dwarf star. Based on observations by the James Webb Space Telescope, the exoplanet K2-18 b might fit in this category. This illustration was obtained by Reuters on April 16, 2025. (A. Smith, N. Madhusudhan/University of Cambridge/Handout via REUTERS)
44 minutes ago

Scientists Find Strongest Evidence yet of Life on an Alien Planet

Los Angeles Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani watches his ball go out for a solo home run during the first inning of a baseball game against the Colorado Rockies Wednesday, April 16, 2025, in Los Angeles. (AP/Mark J. Terrill)
49 minutes ago

Ohtani Hits 448-Foot Homer in 7-Run 1st Inning, Dodgers Sweep Rockies

Ursula, GV Wire's Adoptable Pet of the Week, April 17, 2025
53 minutes ago

Ursula Is Beautiful, Athletic, and Seeking Your Companionship

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend