Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: What Are the Limits on a 'Gig Economy?'
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
February 28, 2019

Share

The term “gig economy” entered the popular lexicon a few years ago, referring to new industries that rely on technology and non-employee workers, such as the Uber and Lyft rides-on-call services.


Opinion
Dan Walters
CALmatters Commentary

The most contentious, dubbed the “killer B” by employment attorneys, is “that the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business.” Or to turn it around, if the work is the employer’s core business, the worker must be an employee.
In fact, however, hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of Californians work as “independent contractors,” ranging from emergency room physicians and movie actors to exotic dancers and truck drivers.
The line between those legitimately and voluntarily working as contractors and those who are being cheated out of even minimum wages and basic benefits has always been a little fuzzy.
Nearly a year ago, the state Supreme Court tried to draw a clear line, unanimously declaring in a case involving package delivery drivers that classifying someone as a contractor must pass a three-point test, dubbed ABC.
The most contentious, dubbed the “killer B” by employment attorneys, is “that the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business.” Or to turn it around, if the work is the employer’s core business, the worker must be an employee.
Suddenly, the status of countless contract employees was in doubt, and employers worried about position-by-position lawsuits, potential retroactivity, and payment of back wages and payroll taxes.

The Issue Is Being Joined Again

Labor union leaders, meanwhile, celebrated. Union membership has been drifting downward recently and having hundreds of thousands of new payroll employees who could join unions was a welcome gift.
After the ruling came down, employers tried – and failed – to persuade legislators to put it on hold.
The issue is being joined again this year. Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez, a San Diego Democrat, has introduced a bill intended to lock the Supreme Court ruling into law and intense negotiations are underway among the affected stakeholders over what it will contain.
The conflicting positions were aired this week at an Assembly Labor and Employment Committee hearing with the ruling’s backers saying it will protect workers from being exploited by greedy employers, and business lobbyists saying it will force those voluntarily working as contractors to lose flexibility.
“It adds another layer of confusion for employers,” Jennifer Barrera of the California Chamber of Commerce told the committee.
One of the more bizarre aspects is the role of Stormy Daniels, an adult film performer who gained notoriety by claiming to have had an affair with President Donald Trump. Daniels, now a spokeswoman for a string of exotic dance clubs, wrote an article in the Los Angeles Times defending dancers’ independent contractor status.

A Major Chore for the Legislature

“Strippers get naked and dance for our customers,” Daniels wrote. “It’s a sensitive profession. As independent contractors, we can perform when, where, how and for whom we want. If we are classified as employees, club managers would be empowered to dictate those conditions.”

“Strippers get naked and dance for our customers. It’s a sensitive profession. As independent contractors, we can perform when, where, how and for whom we want. If we are classified as employees, club managers would be empowered to dictate those conditions.” – Stormy Daniels
During the hearing, her contention was echoed by representatives of other contract workers, such as emergency room physicians.
However, defenders of the court decision insist that it won’t affect voluntary flexibility.
“It doesn’t interfere with flexibility on wages and hours,” Gonzalez declared. Hastings Law School Professor V.B. Dubal agreed saying, “It just means you have the wage floor,”
Last month, another factor popped up. The Republican-dominated National Labor Relations Board reversed an earlier position and made it easier for workers to be classified as contractors and thus ineligible for union organization.
The conflicting rulings mean that a California worker could be an employee under state law governing wages and hours, but a contractor unable to join a union under federal law.
Sorting it all out will be a major chore for the Legislature this year.
CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

DON'T MISS

Senate Rebukes Trump’s Tariffs as Some Republicans Vote to Halt Taxes on Canadian Imports

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Sides With the FDA in Its Dispute Over Sweet-Flavored Vaping Products

DON'T MISS

Trump Announces Sweeping New Tariffs to Promote US Manufacturing, Risking Inflation and Trade Wars

DON'T MISS

Fresno Firefighters Save Dog From Canal and Now She’s Ready for Adoption

DON'T MISS

Big Brands Spend Just Enough on X to Avoid Musk’s ‘Naughty List’

DON'T MISS

Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams

DON'T MISS

State Center Trustees Render Split Decision on Future of PLAs

DON'T MISS

California’s Schools Chief Has a $200,000 Salary and a Side Gig

DON'T MISS

Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion

DON'T MISS

Trump Proposes Tax Deduction for Auto Loan Interest on US-Made Cars

UP NEXT

State Center Trustees Vote for Special Interest Giveaway Over Students: Opinion

UP NEXT

I Will Force Votes on Blocking Arms Sales to Israel: Sen. Bernie Sanders

UP NEXT

What Trump’s ‘Liberation Day’ Tariffs Could Mean for Americans: Fareed Zakaria

UP NEXT

Why the Nation Would Be Wise to Support a Third Term Amendment for Donald Trump

UP NEXT

If California Bails Out LA’s $1 Billion Budget Deficit, Beware the Slippery Slope

UP NEXT

Trump Has Had Enough. He Is Not Alone.

UP NEXT

The Real Crisis in California Schools Is Low Achievement, Not Cultural Conflicts

UP NEXT

Trump and Musk Are Suffering From Soros Derangement Syndrome

UP NEXT

CA Politicians Have an Irritating Habit of Ignoring the Downsides

UP NEXT

If Pete Hegseth Had Any Honor, He Would Resign

Fresno Firefighters Save Dog From Canal and Now She’s Ready for Adoption

10 hours ago

Big Brands Spend Just Enough on X to Avoid Musk’s ‘Naughty List’

11 hours ago

Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams

11 hours ago

State Center Trustees Render Split Decision on Future of PLAs

11 hours ago

California’s Schools Chief Has a $200,000 Salary and a Side Gig

12 hours ago

Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion

12 hours ago

Trump Proposes Tax Deduction for Auto Loan Interest on US-Made Cars

12 hours ago

Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact

12 hours ago

Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US

12 hours ago

Fresno Man Found Dead, Coroner’s Office Seeks Help Finding Family

13 hours ago

Senate Rebukes Trump’s Tariffs as Some Republicans Vote to Halt Taxes on Canadian Imports

WASHINGTON — The Senate passed a resolution Wednesday night that would thwart President Donald Trump’s ability to impose tariffs on Canada, ...

6 hours ago

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., center, is joined from left by Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., Sen. Peter Welch, D-Vt., and Sen. Angela Alsobrooks, D-Md., as they speak to reporters about President Donald Trump's tariffs on foreign countries, at the Capitol, in Washington, Wednesday, April 2, 2025. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)
6 hours ago

Senate Rebukes Trump’s Tariffs as Some Republicans Vote to Halt Taxes on Canadian Imports

9 hours ago

Supreme Court Sides With the FDA in Its Dispute Over Sweet-Flavored Vaping Products

10 hours ago

Trump Announces Sweeping New Tariffs to Promote US Manufacturing, Risking Inflation and Trade Wars

A young Labrador mix rescued from a Fresno canal on Sunday, March 2, 2025, is thriving in a foster home after overcoming fear and trauma. (Instagram/Fresno Animal Center)
10 hours ago

Fresno Firefighters Save Dog From Canal and Now She’s Ready for Adoption

11 hours ago

Big Brands Spend Just Enough on X to Avoid Musk’s ‘Naughty List’

11 hours ago

Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams

11 hours ago

State Center Trustees Render Split Decision on Future of PLAs

12 hours ago

California’s Schools Chief Has a $200,000 Salary and a Side Gig

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend