Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Fresno Parks Tax: Dueling Lawsuits But Ultimately One Winner
David Website Replacement
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 6 years ago on
February 6, 2019

Share

Dueling lawsuits in Fresno Superior Court ask the same question: Did Measure P pass with 52% of the vote?
As instructed by the Fresno City Council last week, the city attorney filed suit asking a judge to settle the controversy. Did the measure that would raise the city sales tax 3/8 of a cent for parks need a majority or two-thirds approval of voters to become law?
The city filed its suit Friday, Feb. 1, 63 minutes after Fresno Building Healthy Communities filed its suit.
A court date has yet to be set.
In the city’s filing, it asked the court to consolidate its action with Fresno BHC’s suit. Both sides are asking the judge to award attorney fees.
[tnc-pdf-viewer-iframe file=”http://www.gvwire.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/19CECG00422-City-complaint.pdf” width=”800″ height=”700″ download=”true” print=”true” fullscreen=”true” share=”true” zoom=”true” open=”true” pagenav=”true” logo=”true” find=”true” current_view=”true” rotate=”true” handtool=”true” doc_prop=”true” toggle_menu=”true” language=”en-US” page=”” default_zoom=”auto” pagemode=””]  

Supporters Call Two-Thirds Standard Unfair

The Fresno BHC lawsuit argues that the law requiring two-thirds approval is unfair.


“While the majority of Fresno residents voted to pass the parks measure, an artificial voter threshold required a two-thirds majority for passage. The coalition believes the threshold is not only unfair, but the law is on the side of the people.”— Dr. Tony Iton, California Endowment 

“While the majority of Fresno residents voted to pass the parks measure, an artificial voter threshold required a two-thirds majority for passage. The coalition believes the threshold is not only unfair, but the law is on the side of the people. That’s why Fresno BHC filed a lawsuit against the city of Fresno asking the court rule that a simple majority allow Measure P to be enacted,” Dr. Tony Iton, vice president of the California Endowment, wrote in a blog post.
The California Endowment provides funding for Fresno BHC.
Fresno BHC, part of the coalition of groups supporting Measure P, filed the suit independent of the official campaign.
However, the campaign said it supported the legal action.
“We are supportive of Fresno BHC’s decision to take this next step and await the court’s decision on this critical issue for community groups across California,” campaign spokeswoman Natasha Biasell said.
Central Valley Community Foundation is listed on campaign documents as the official sponsor of the Yes on P campaign
Ashley Swearengin, Fresno’s former mayor and current president/CEO of the CVCF, did not reply to GV Wire’s request for comment.
Measure P supporters say the sales tax would raise $38 million annually for 30 years for parks, trails, and other programs.
[tnc-pdf-viewer-iframe file=”http://www.gvwire.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/19CECG00432-FBHC-complaint.pdf” width=”800″ height=”700″ download=”true” print=”true” fullscreen=”true” share=”true” zoom=”true” open=”true” pagenav=”true” logo=”true” find=”true” current_view=”true” rotate=”true” handtool=”true” doc_prop=”true” toggle_menu=”true” language=”en-US” page=”” default_zoom=”auto” pagemode=””]  

Changing the Rules

Mike Der Manouel Jr., a conservative radio commentator and Measure P opponent, said that the supporters are engaging in sour grapes. He also says that any chance to pass a future tax with cooperation from City Hall is over.
“Tactically speaking, the lawsuit by Yes on P is a disaster,” Der Manouel said. “They’ve effectively shut themselves out of any future discussions with the mayor, and are attempting to retroactively change the rules and outcome of an election already decided.  Many municipalities will join in defense to protect their interests in similar litigation.  It’s a temper tantrum. Nothing more.”
Mayor Lee Brand, in discussing Measure P at a recent speech to the Fresno Area Hispanic Foundation, expressed a desire for another tax measure that would support both parks and public safety.

Basic Legal Question

The law in question stems from Proposition 218, which passed with 57% of the vote in 1996.
That law deals with how taxes may be raised and the standard to pass them in California. Among the many changes it made, Prop. 218 required any tax increase to go to the voters.
As it applies to Measure P, any tax that goes to a specific purpose needs two-thirds to pass. General taxes, which goes to a government’s general fund to be used for any reason, require a majority (50% plus one).
There are two ways a tax can go before the voters — the governing body (in this case, the city council) votes to place it on the ballot, or a petition with enough qualifying signatures compels the council to place the item on the ballot.
Whether Measure P is a specific tax is not in question. Neither is the fact that it reached the ballot after proponents collected sufficient signatures.
In the resolution adopting Measure P in August 2018, the council wrote “measure requires approval by two-thirds (2/3) vote, unless otherwise required by law.” They followed the interpretation of city attorney Douglas Sloan.
However, the controversy is about whether the majority vs. two-thirds argument applies to how the tax was placed on the ballot.

Supreme Court Ruling Creates Confusion

A 2017 Supreme Court case answered one aspect of how Prop. 218 applies in certain circumstances.
In California Cannabis Coalition v. City of Upland, the court ruled that taxes proposed through the initiative process aren’t under the same Prop. 218 rules as a tax placed on the ballot by a government body.
However, Upland only directly answered the specific question for scheduling an election (either as a special election or at the next general election). The court did not answer the question (nor was it asked to by the plaintiffs) about the majority vs. two-thirds standard.
Fresno BHC says that Upland also applies to the standard of votes needed; the city counters that Measure P needs two-thirds.
A similar case in San Francisco is being challenged by the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, which was behind Prop. 218. However, things are reversed in the case. The city attorney in San Francisco interpreted Upland to mean that only a majority was needed to pass.
Two tax proposals in San Francisco received more than a majority but less than two-thirds. The city declared them passed. The Howard Jarvis group disagreed, and the case is now in court.

Yes on P Outspent Foes Nearly 5-to-1

How much did the Measure P campaign spend in its attempt to pass the parks sales tax measure?
In the latest campaign filing covering the period through Dec. 31, 2018, Yes on Measure P spent $2.2 million. That’s nearly five times as much as the No on P campaign spent.
The campaign raised $2.15 million and has more than $56,000 cash on hand. However, it has $131,000 in debt.
The largest single contributor was the late David McDonald, who gave $850,000.
The Central Valley Community Foundation contributed more than $584,000 in labor and other costs.
The Sacramento law firm of Olson Hagel & Fishburn LLP performed legal work for Yes on P. Between Oct. 21 and the end of the year, the campaign paid $44,000 in legal services.



“What this boils down to is, this is going to be a judicial decision. This would end up in court one way or the other.”  — Councilman Nelson Esparza 
Olson is also handling the lawsuit for Fresno BHC.
The No on P campaign raised and spent $454,000 and has no cash left nor debt.
Granville Farms, a related company to Granville Homes, publisher of GV Wire, was a major contributor to the No on P campaign.

Letting the Courts Decide

When councilmembers voted 4-3 in closed session last week to file for declaratory relief, they knew it was headed to the courts anyway.
“What this boils down to is, this is going to be a judicial decision. This would end up in court one way or the other,” Councilman Nelson Esparza said.
Election law attorney Fredric Woocher of Los Angeles-based Stumwasser & Woocher agreed that the courts will decide Measure P’s fate.
“That two-thirds vs. majority vote question is one that is currently at issue in a number of cases and really requires a judicial resolution,” said Woocher, who is not involved with the case.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Paul Atkins Sworn in as US SEC Chair

DON'T MISS

UnitedHealth Spent $1.7 Million on Executive Security in 2024, Filing Shows

DON'T MISS

US Supreme Court Appears Likely to Uphold Obamacare’s Preventive Care Coverage Mandate

DON'T MISS

Woman in Fresno Mansion Fraud Case Sentenced to Prison for Tax Evasion

DON'T MISS

California Prisoner Indicted for Exploiting Child Victim While Incarcerated

DON'T MISS

Kennedy Plans to Phase Out 8 Commonly Used Food Dyes

DON'T MISS

The Superintendent Search Document FUSD Does Not Want You to See

DON'T MISS

Trump Approval Rating Dips. Many Wary of His Wielding of Power, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

DON'T MISS

Fresno Woman, Tied to Fentanyl ‘M30 King,’ Sentenced to Federal Prison

DON'T MISS

Tesla Settles Wrongful Death Lawsuit Claiming Sudden Acceleration in Ohio Crash

UP NEXT

Woman in Fresno Mansion Fraud Case Sentenced to Prison for Tax Evasion

UP NEXT

Trump Is Dismantling the Education Dept. How That Might Harm Special Ed

UP NEXT

Special Interests Pour More Than Half a Billion Into CA Lobbying

UP NEXT

Fresno Barbershop Shooting Leaves Man Dead, Two Others Injured

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Satbir Singh

UP NEXT

Steeply Discounted OD-Reversal Medicine Now Available to Any Californian

UP NEXT

Merced College Breaks Ground on $21 Million Center Geared for Tomorrow’s Ag Jobs

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Arrest 11 for DUI During Weekend Enforcement

UP NEXT

One Man Dead After Kings River Rescue Attempt in Fresno County

UP NEXT

Fresno County Will Sell Naming Rights for Clovis and Reedley Libraries

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Woman in Fresno Mansion Fraud Case Sentenced to Prison for Tax Evasion

5 hours ago

California Prisoner Indicted for Exploiting Child Victim While Incarcerated

5 hours ago

Kennedy Plans to Phase Out 8 Commonly Used Food Dyes

5 hours ago

The Superintendent Search Document FUSD Does Not Want You to See

5 hours ago

Trump Approval Rating Dips. Many Wary of His Wielding of Power, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

5 hours ago

Fresno Woman, Tied to Fentanyl ‘M30 King,’ Sentenced to Federal Prison

6 hours ago

Tesla Settles Wrongful Death Lawsuit Claiming Sudden Acceleration in Ohio Crash

6 hours ago

Trump Is Dismantling the Education Dept. How That Might Harm Special Ed

6 hours ago

Special Interests Pour More Than Half a Billion Into CA Lobbying

7 hours ago

Texas Walmart Shooter Who Killed 23 Avoids Death Penalty by Pleading Guilty

8 hours ago

Paul Atkins Sworn in as US SEC Chair

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Paul Atkins, who previously served as a U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission member from 2002 to 2008 and wa...

3 hours ago

CEO of Patomak Global Partners Paul Atkins takes part in a strategic and policy CEO discussion with U.S. President Donald Trump in the Eisenhower Execution Office Building in Washington, U.S., April 11, 2017. (REUTERS/Joshua Roberts/File Photo)
3 hours ago

Paul Atkins Sworn in as US SEC Chair

The corporate logo of the UnitedHealth Group appears on the side of one of their office buildings in Santa Ana, California, U.S., April 13, 2020. (REUTERS/Mike Blake)
4 hours ago

UnitedHealth Spent $1.7 Million on Executive Security in 2024, Filing Shows

5 hours ago

US Supreme Court Appears Likely to Uphold Obamacare’s Preventive Care Coverage Mandate

Pilar Rose, 51, formerly of Fresno, pleaded guilty to tax evasion and obstructing an IRS audit, agreeing to forfeit her mansion and BMW after falsifying financial records to evade taxes and secure fraudulent loans. (Zillow)
5 hours ago

Woman in Fresno Mansion Fraud Case Sentenced to Prison for Tax Evasion

Nathaniel Ray Diaz, 21, of Greenfield, is a California state prisoner who has been indicted on federal charges on Monday, April 21, 2025, for allegedly directing a minor to send sexually explicit images while serving time for previous offenses against the same child. (Shutterstock)
5 hours ago

California Prisoner Indicted for Exploiting Child Victim While Incarcerated

Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. speaks at a news conference about the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s latest autism survey in Washington, April 16, 2025. In his first attempt to significantly change the nation’s food supply, Kennedy will direct food manufacturers to phase out eight petroleum-based food dyes that are found in hundreds of thousands of grocery-store staples, the department said on Monday, April 21. (Pete Kiehart/The New York Times)
5 hours ago

Kennedy Plans to Phase Out 8 Commonly Used Food Dyes

5 hours ago

The Superintendent Search Document FUSD Does Not Want You to See

President Donald Trump attends the annual White House Easter Egg Roll, on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., April 21, 2025. (REUTERS/Leah Millis)
5 hours ago

Trump Approval Rating Dips. Many Wary of His Wielding of Power, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend