Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Court Urged to End Rule That Erased Hernandez's Conviction
By admin
Published 6 years ago on
November 9, 2018

Share

BOSTON — A legal principle that erased former New England Patriots player Aaron Hernandez’s murder conviction after he killed himself in prison is outdated, unfair and should not stand, a Massachusetts prosecutor told the state’s highest court Thursday.

“He goes through a full trial, a jury who speaks for the public convicts him and because he dies, in this case commits suicide, the whole thing is wiped out like it never happened? It’s not fair or just and should be changed.” — Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn III

It doesn’t make sense the former New England Patriots tight end is now innocent in the eyes of the law just because he died before his appeal could be heard, Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn III said. Quinn is urging the court to reinstate Hernandez’s conviction and do away with the legal principle for future cases.

“He goes through a full trial, a jury who speaks for the public convicts him and because he dies, in this case commits suicide, the whole thing is wiped out like it never happened? It’s not fair or just and should be changed,” Quinn told reporters after the hearing.

Hernandez was found guilty in 2015 of killing semi-professional football player Odin Lloyd. Two years later, the 27-year-old was found dead in his prison cell days after being acquitted of most charges in a separate double-murder case.

A judge threw out Hernandez’s conviction last year, citing the legal principle that holds that a defendant convicted at trial who dies before an appeal is heard should no longer be considered guilty in the eyes of the law, thereby returning the case to its pretrial status.

Hernandez’s Attorney Says There’s Nothing Wrong With the Doctrine

Legal experts say the doctrine, rooted in centuries of English law, requires a conviction not be considered final until an appeal can determine whether mistakes were made that deprived the defendant of a fair trial.

John Thompson, Hernandez’s appellate attorney, told the Supreme Judicial Court that there’s nothing wrong with the doctrine and that the alternatives floated by Quinn are problematic.

“The jury’s decision is not the end-all be-all,” Thompson said. “It is an opinion arrived at by 12 people followed by a process that is subject to defect.”

The Supreme Judicial Court typically takes several months to issue a decision.

How other states handle cases such as Hernandez’s varies widely. Some states, like Massachusetts, toss the convictions, while others dismiss the defendant’s appeal and the conviction stands. Other states allow appellate courts to consider a dead defendant’s case, prosecutors say.

Quinn wants court to allow a defendant’s estate to pursue an appeal, if they wish, otherwise the verdict would stand.

Others Seemed Puzzled Over What to Do

Several justices appeared interested in an approach crafted by the Alabama Supreme Court, which directed the state simply to note in the court record the conviction was neither affirmed nor reversed because the defendant died while the appeal was pending.

“I’m struggling with this because we don’t have any good options.” — Ralph Gants, chief justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

But others seemed puzzled over what to do.

“I’m struggling with this because we don’t have any good options,” said Ralph Gants, chief justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.

Quinn pointed to other high-profile Massachusetts criminals who had their convictions erased after their death, including John Salvi, who was convicted of killing two abortion clinic workers and wounding five other people during a shooting rampage in Brookline in 1994.

Roman Catholic priest John Geoghan, a key figure in the clergy sex abuse scandal that rocked the Boston archdiocese and spread across the globe, also had his child molestation conviction vacated after he was beaten to death in 2003 in his cell at the same Massachusetts maximum-security prison where Hernandez died.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

High-Speed Rail CEO Won’t Commit to Size of Fresno Station. What’s in the Future for Rail?

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Crew Rescues Man Who Fell Into Ponding Basin Near Coalinga

DON'T MISS

Where Valley Lawmakers Stand on Punishing Seekers of Teens for Sex

DON'T MISS

Arias Criticizes Smittcamp Over Lack of Drug, Homeless Arrests

DON'T MISS

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation, Faces 16 Years in Prison

DON'T MISS

California Democrats Reject Push for Harsher Penalties for Soliciting Sex From Older Teens

DON'T MISS

Trump Turns to US Supreme Court in Bid to Strip Protected Status From Venezuelan Migrants

DON'T MISS

Fresno’s Audra McDonald Earns 11th Tony Nomination, Eyes Record Seventh Win for ‘Gypsy’

DON'T MISS

US Imposes Sanctions on Mexican Fuel Theft Network It Links to CJNG Cartel

DON'T MISS

Last Chevron-Chartered Vessel Starts to Return Oil Cargo in Venezuela, Data and Source Say

UP NEXT

LeBron: ‘I Don’t Have the Answer’ to Questions About His Future After Lakers’ Exit

UP NEXT

UNC’s Belichick Defends Hudson as ‘Doing Her Job’ After Interjecting During CBS Interview

UP NEXT

Teoscar Hernandez, Andy Pages Lead 18-Hit Attack as Dodgers Beat Marlins

UP NEXT

‘Agreeing to Disagree’ Is Hurting Your Relationships – Here’s What to Do Instead

UP NEXT

Americans Are Chasing the Castlecore Dream in Europe, and You Should Too

UP NEXT

49ers Agree to Contract With Free Agent Tackle D.J. Humphries

UP NEXT

George Kittle Agrees to Extension With 49ers, Becomes Highest-Paid Tight End Ever

UP NEXT

Sacramento State Hires Shaquille O’Neal as a Voluntary GM

UP NEXT

Edman Delivers in 10th as Dodgers Weather Myers’ Pinch-Hit Slam for Win Over Marlins

UP NEXT

Shedeur Sanders Was Not the Only Prospect to Receive a Prank Call During the NFL Draft

Arias Criticizes Smittcamp Over Lack of Drug, Homeless Arrests

12 hours ago

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation, Faces 16 Years in Prison

14 hours ago

California Democrats Reject Push for Harsher Penalties for Soliciting Sex From Older Teens

14 hours ago

Trump Turns to US Supreme Court in Bid to Strip Protected Status From Venezuelan Migrants

14 hours ago

Fresno’s Audra McDonald Earns 11th Tony Nomination, Eyes Record Seventh Win for ‘Gypsy’

15 hours ago

US Imposes Sanctions on Mexican Fuel Theft Network It Links to CJNG Cartel

15 hours ago

Last Chevron-Chartered Vessel Starts to Return Oil Cargo in Venezuela, Data and Source Say

15 hours ago

At Least 9 Dead in Drone Strikes After US and Ukraine Sign Minerals Deal

15 hours ago

New CIA Videos Aim to Lure Chinese Officials

16 hours ago

Trump Taps Waltz for US Ambassador to the United Nations

16 hours ago

High-Speed Rail CEO Won’t Commit to Size of Fresno Station. What’s in the Future for Rail?

As part of the California High-Speed Rail Authority’s attempt to rein in a ballooning budget, its new CEO in a townhall last week walk...

11 hours ago

11 hours ago

High-Speed Rail CEO Won’t Commit to Size of Fresno Station. What’s in the Future for Rail?

A man was rescued early Thursday, May 1, 2025, after falling 60 feet into a ponding basin near Coalinga and was taken to a local hospital for evaluation. (CAL FIRE)
11 hours ago

Fresno County Crew Rescues Man Who Fell Into Ponding Basin Near Coalinga

11 hours ago

Where Valley Lawmakers Stand on Punishing Seekers of Teens for Sex

12 hours ago

Arias Criticizes Smittcamp Over Lack of Drug, Homeless Arrests

Justin Mills, 36, of Pixley, was convicted on Tuesday, April 29, 2025, of six felony counts of child molestation and faces up to 16 years in prison. (Tulare County DA)
14 hours ago

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation, Faces 16 Years in Prison

14 hours ago

California Democrats Reject Push for Harsher Penalties for Soliciting Sex From Older Teens

An aerial view shows Diover Millan of Venezuela, top left, and other detainees at the Bluebonnet Detention Facility, the facility where Venezuelans at the center of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling are held, in Anson, Texas, U.S., April 23, 2025. (REUTERS/Daniel Cole/File Photo)
14 hours ago

Trump Turns to US Supreme Court in Bid to Strip Protected Status From Venezuelan Migrants

Fresno’s Audra McDonald, already the most decorated performer in Tony history, is nominated for a record-breaking seventh award for her role in the “Gypsy” revival. (Shutterstock)
15 hours ago

Fresno’s Audra McDonald Earns 11th Tony Nomination, Eyes Record Seventh Win for ‘Gypsy’

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend