Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
AP Fact Check: Trump’s Hype on Migrants, Illegal Immigration
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 7 years ago on
November 4, 2018

Share

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump is spreading misleading rhetoric about the nature of Central American migrants heading to the U.S. border and grossly inflating the number of immigrants living in the U.S. illegally.

In a speech Thursday, he suggested without evidence that the migrant caravans are full of hardened criminals; in fact, they are mostly poor people with few belongings who are fleeing gang violence.

In stressing that his administration will not allow a “catch and release” policy, Trump also claimed this week that 25 million to 30 million immigrants now live in the country illegally because previous administrations had “released” immigrants in the U.S. after they had been caught crossing the border as they awaited immigration hearings.

He’s wrong. Independent estimates put the number of people in the U.S. illegally at less than half that amount.

A look at his various claims on immigration:

People in the Caravans Are Dangerous, Hardened Criminals

TRUMP: “At this very moment, large well-organized caravans of migrants are marching towards our southern border. Some people call it an invasion. …These are tough people in many cases; a lot of young men, strong men and a lot of men that maybe we don’t want in our country. …This isn’t an innocent group of people. It’s a large number of people that are tough. They have injured, they have attacked.” — immigration speech Thursday.

“This isn’t an innocent group of people. It’s a large number of people that are tough. They have injured, they have attacked.” President Donald Trump

THE FACTS: He suggests without evidence that people in the caravans are, by and large, dangerous, hardened criminals.

The migrants in the caravans are mostly from Honduras, where it started, as well as El Salvador and Guatemala. Overall, they are poor, carrying the belongings that fit into a knapsack and fleeing gang violence or poverty.

It might be true there are some criminals mixed in with the throngs, given the sheer number of migrants. Trump did not substantiate his claim that members of the MS-13 gang, in particular, are among them.

Some migrants in one of the caravans clashed with Mexican police at the Mexico-Guatemala border, hurling stones and other objects as they tried to cross the international bridge. One migrant died; it’s not clear how it happened. Caravan leaders said they had expelled a number of troublemakers from the procession, exhibiting some self-policing. Ultimately, most entered Guatemala — and later, Mexico — by illegally bypassing immigration checkpoints.

The caravan otherwise has been overwhelmingly peaceful, receiving applause and donated food from residents of the towns they pass. Mexican police have not tried again to stop them.

The Department of Homeland Security issued a fact sheet stating that “over 270 individuals along the caravan route have criminal histories, including known gang membership.” But it did not specify how it had arrived at that number.

Children Being Taken Away From Parents

TRUMP: “President Obama separated the children from parents and nobody complained. When we continued the exact same law, the country went crazy.” — immigration speech Thursday.

“President Obama separated the children from parents and nobody complained.” — President Donald Trump

THE FACTS: Actually, President Barack Obama did not do the same thing as a matter of policy.

While it’s true the underlying laws were the same, the Trump administration mandated anyone caught crossing the border illegally was to be criminally prosecuted. That policy meant adults were taken to court for criminal proceedings, and their children were separated and sent into the care of the Health and Human Services Department, which is tasked with caring for unaccompanied migrant children. The so-called zero tolerance policy remains in effect, but Trump signed an executive order June 20 that stopped separations.

Jeh Johnson, Obama’s homeland security secretary, recently told NPR there may have been unusual or emergency circumstances when children were taken from parents, but there was no such policy.

20 Percent of Claimants Are Granted Asylum

TRUMP: “Asylum is not a program for those living in poverty.” — speech Thursday.

THE FACTS: He’s largely right. Poverty may play a role in the complex decision process granting asylum, but the status is reserved for people who have a justifiable fear of persecution in their own country based on factors such as their race, religion or political views. According to the Homeland Security Department, about 20 percent of claimants are granted asylum. Currently, there is a backlog of about 700,000 cases, and it can take years for claims to get resolved.

Amount of People in This Country Illegally

TRUMP: “We’re not doing releases. What’s been happening over years is they would come in, release them, and they would never show up for their trial. And we now have 25 or 30 million people in this country illegally, because of what’s been happening over many years.” — remarks Wednesday to reporters.

THE FACTS: It’s nowhere close to 25 million to 30 million, nor has the number increased much in recent years.

The nonpartisan Pew Research Center estimates there were about 11.3 million immigrants in the U.S. illegally in 2016, the most recent data available. That number is basically unchanged from 2009.

The number of such immigrants had reached a height of 12.2 million in 2007, representing about 4 percent of the U.S. population, before declining due in part to a weakening U.S. economy.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Is the Secret to CA Housing Affordability Buried in the Building Code?

DON'T MISS

Students Are Short-Circuiting Chromebooks for a Social Media Challenge

DON'T MISS

Trump says US and Iran ‘Sort of’ Agree on Terms for a Nuclear Deal

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Arrest Teen, Woman in Triple Shooting

DON'T MISS

Hanford Is Valley Location for Statewide Teachers Protest on Saturday

DON'T MISS

Marte Hits 2 Homers, Suárez Adds 3-Run Blast As D-Backs Outlast Giants

DON'T MISS

Dodgers Call Up Top Prospect Dalton Rushing, Cut Loose Catcher Austin Barnes

DON'T MISS

Timberwolves Beat Warriors to Reach Western Conference Finals for 2nd Straight Year

DON'T MISS

Dodgers Get Homers From Ohtani, Pages, Kim and Muncy and Rally Past the Athletics

DON'T MISS

Palestinians Mark Nakba Day as Fears of Displacement Grow

UP NEXT

The World Is Wooing US Researchers Shunned by Trump

UP NEXT

US Overdose Deaths Fell 27% Last Year, the Largest One-Year Decline Ever Seen

UP NEXT

Pacers Eliminate Top-Seeded Cavaliers, Advance to the Eastern Conference Finals

UP NEXT

Netanyahu Says There Is ‘No Way’ Israel Halts the War in Gaza Until Hamas Is Defeated

UP NEXT

Cassie Testifies in Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs Sex Trafficking Trial. What to Know About the Star Witness

UP NEXT

Jayson Tatum Carried off Floor With Right Leg Injury and Celtics Star Will Have MRI

UP NEXT

Dallas Mavericks Win the NBA Draft Lottery, Eye Cooper Flagg for No. 1 Pick

UP NEXT

US Inflation Stable Before Expected Jump From Tariffs

UP NEXT

Trump Plans to Accept Luxury 747 From Qatar to Use as Air Force One

UP NEXT

‘The Studio’ Knows the Real Reason Movies Are Bad

Fresno Police Arrest Teen, Woman in Triple Shooting

50 minutes ago

Hanford Is Valley Location for Statewide Teachers Protest on Saturday

1 hour ago

Marte Hits 2 Homers, Suárez Adds 3-Run Blast As D-Backs Outlast Giants

1 hour ago

Dodgers Call Up Top Prospect Dalton Rushing, Cut Loose Catcher Austin Barnes

1 hour ago

Timberwolves Beat Warriors to Reach Western Conference Finals for 2nd Straight Year

1 hour ago

Dodgers Get Homers From Ohtani, Pages, Kim and Muncy and Rally Past the Athletics

2 hours ago

Palestinians Mark Nakba Day as Fears of Displacement Grow

2 hours ago

Older People in Crosshairs as Government Restarts Social Security Garnishment on Student Loans

2 hours ago

54 People Killed in Overnight Airstrikes on Southern Gaza City, Hospital Says

2 hours ago

UN Aid Chief Defends Using ‘Genocide’ in Gaza Remarks to the Security Council That Israel Rejects

2 hours ago

Is the Secret to CA Housing Affordability Buried in the Building Code?

This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters. As lawmakers scramble to turbocharge post-fire recovery ef...

18 minutes ago

https://www.communitymedical.org/thecause?utm_source=Misfit+Digital&utm_medium=GVWire+Banner+Ads&utm_campaign=Branding+2025&utm_content=thecause
18 minutes ago

Is the Secret to CA Housing Affordability Buried in the Building Code?

26 minutes ago

Students Are Short-Circuiting Chromebooks for a Social Media Challenge

Trump in the UAE
40 minutes ago

Trump says US and Iran ‘Sort of’ Agree on Terms for a Nuclear Deal

Vanessa Noriega and a 17-year-old boy were arrested after a shooting during a fight in southwest Fresno left three teenage girls wounded. (Fresno PD)
50 minutes ago

Fresno Police Arrest Teen, Woman in Triple Shooting

1 hour ago

Hanford Is Valley Location for Statewide Teachers Protest on Saturday

1 hour ago

Marte Hits 2 Homers, Suárez Adds 3-Run Blast As D-Backs Outlast Giants

1 hour ago

Dodgers Call Up Top Prospect Dalton Rushing, Cut Loose Catcher Austin Barnes

1 hour ago

Timberwolves Beat Warriors to Reach Western Conference Finals for 2nd Straight Year

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend