Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Grownups Have Messed Up School Budgets. Turn It Over to the Kids.
Joe-Mathews
By Joe Mathews
Published 7 years ago on
March 22, 2018

Share

California education finances are an unholy mess — with incomprehensible budget formulas, equity funding that doesn’t produce equity, and cuts to schools even during the current economic expansion. And our state’s so-called education leaders refuse to fix the system.
We should let the kids fix it instead.


Opinion
Joe Mathews
This isn’t a modest proposal: I’m as serious as a month’s detention. To fashion something workable from California’s broken education-funding system, we should give budget powers to the students themselves.
Sounds radical, but it’s not a new idea. Students already make financial decisions in schools in San Jose, Sacramento, Phoenix and Chicago — often about school-site capital spending—as part of a popular process called participatory budgeting. In New York, Mayor Bill De Blasio recently said he’d give students in all his city’s public high schools these budgeting powers.
Typically, students in these processes spend less than $100,000 (though Paris, France allows its students to allocate $10 million). But given California’s problems, we should expand participatory budgeting for bigger budgets at the district and statewide level.
Without real plans, LCFF spending is becoming a multi-billion-dollar black hole. No one really knows whether the dollars are used for equity purposes, like closing the achievement gaps between disadvantaged students and other students.

Adults Have Shown They’re Terrible at School Budgeting

You might think that decisions about the $80 billion that California spends annually on schools should be made exclusively by adults.
Except that we’ve already let the adults do it, and it would be impossible for the kids to do any worse. Indeed, the grownups — the governor, legislators, teachers’ unions — supposedly in charge of school funding don’t really understand how the funding system works. It’s that complicated.
The logical place for the kids to start making decisions involves the latest faulty adult attempt to fix education funding: 2013’s Local Control Funding Formula, or LCFF.
LCFF was supposed to bring democracy, equity, and simplification to school funding. It replaced existing spending categories with a new formula to direct more money to poorer school districts. This LCFF system also required local school districts to work with teachers, parents, and students to set goals and make plans — called Local Control and Accountability Plans, or LCAPs — for spending the money. Gov. Jerry Brown has touted this as a democratic advance.

Local Control Formula Funding Isn’t Truly Local

But, in practice, it’s not democratic. The Local Control and Accountability Plans aren’t local, don’t provide control or accountability, and aren’t even plans. Instead of setting their own goals, communities must answer complicated questions posed by the state, creating bureaucratic documents that are often hundreds of pages long. Asking someone to read one should be prohibited under the Geneva Convention.

Gov. Brown has said no one should expect achievement gaps with disadvantaged students to be closed.
Without real plans, LCFF spending is becoming a multi-billion-dollar black hole. No one really knows whether the dollars are used for equity purposes, like closing the achievement gaps between disadvantaged students and other students.
This uncertainty doesn’t seem to bother state officials. Gov. Brown has said no one should expect achievement gaps with disadvantaged students to be closed: “The gap has been pretty persistent, so I don’t want to set up what hasn’t been done ever as the test of whether the LCFF is a success or failure.”

Grownups Already Have Surrendered

In other words, the grownups have surrendered. We should turn to students to fill the void. The most proven and democratic method would be participatory budgeting.


Participatory budgeting is taking place at schools in Sacramento and San Jose.
In recent years, schools have begun using participatory budgeting. In these processes, students, along with parents and teachers, study a budget question and make plans that are put up to a public vote of the school community. In California, participatory budgeting has been used at Sacramento’s Met High School and in San Jose’s East Side Union High School District, where students voted to reinstate a driver’s education program targeted for budget cuts.
Scaling such processes up in order to budget LCFF money would be challenging, but doable. Students in each school district could elect their fellow students to committees that would decide how best to spend the money. The plans made by those student committees then would go back to the student voters for approval.
This would be more than just a real civics class for California kids. It would provide a dose of democracy — and authentic local control — for an ineffective system dominated by a few adult interests in Sacramento.

Let’s Get Rid of Proposition 98

Student control of school budgets shouldn’t stop at LCFF. I’d love to see today’s students replace the misbegotten constitutional formula at the heart of California school funding — Proposition 98. Voters approved it in 1988, well before today’s public school students were born.
Prop. 98’s funding guarantee has kept school funding below the national average for a generation. Surely California’s students can design something better.
About the Author
Joe Mathews writes the Connecting California column for Zócalo Public Square.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Leo XIV’s Service to Poor Propelled Him to Papacy, Cardinals Say

DON'T MISS

The State Law Taking a Financial Toll on California Budgets

DON'T MISS

Iran to Send Russia Launchers for Short-Range Missiles, Sources Say

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Draws Union Pushback in Social Media Battle With Teachers

DON'T MISS

Today Harvard Is the Target. Tomorrow It Could Be Your Church.

DON'T MISS

‘Luigi Mangione Act’ Seeks to Block Health Insurance Denials, Sparks Outrage Over Name

DON'T MISS

Jerry Springer — Yes, That Jerry Springer — Can Save the Democrats

DON'T MISS

Newark Airport Has Another Radar Outage

DON'T MISS

Judge Orders Release of Tufts Student Detained by ICE

DON'T MISS

White House Confirms Trump Fired Librarian of Congress

UP NEXT

Fresno Unified Draws Union Pushback in Social Media Battle With Teachers

UP NEXT

Today Harvard Is the Target. Tomorrow It Could Be Your Church.

UP NEXT

‘Luigi Mangione Act’ Seeks to Block Health Insurance Denials, Sparks Outrage Over Name

UP NEXT

Jerry Springer — Yes, That Jerry Springer — Can Save the Democrats

UP NEXT

Fresno State Awards Honorary Doctorates to Educator, Prisons Official, Businessman

UP NEXT

Floods Exposed Weaknesses in California Prisons’ Emergency Plans. They Still Aren’t Ready

UP NEXT

Other States Are Showing California How to Protect Its Budget Without Cutting Needed Services

UP NEXT

How Much Has Central Unified Shelled Out to Get Rid of Its Superintendents?

UP NEXT

Republicans’ Trust in Media Increases Following Trump’s Return to White House

UP NEXT

Los Angeles Coliseum and SoFi Stadium to Share Opening and Closing Ceremonies for 2028 Olympics

Fresno Unified Draws Union Pushback in Social Media Battle With Teachers

1 hour ago

Today Harvard Is the Target. Tomorrow It Could Be Your Church.

1 hour ago

‘Luigi Mangione Act’ Seeks to Block Health Insurance Denials, Sparks Outrage Over Name

1 hour ago

Jerry Springer — Yes, That Jerry Springer — Can Save the Democrats

2 hours ago

Newark Airport Has Another Radar Outage

2 hours ago

Judge Orders Release of Tufts Student Detained by ICE

2 hours ago

White House Confirms Trump Fired Librarian of Congress

2 hours ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Michael Lee Brewer

3 hours ago

Fresno State Awards Honorary Doctorates to Educator, Prisons Official, Businessman

3 hours ago

Floods Exposed Weaknesses in California Prisons’ Emergency Plans. They Still Aren’t Ready

3 hours ago

Leo XIV’s Service to Poor Propelled Him to Papacy, Cardinals Say

ROME — Pope Leo XIV presided over his first Mass as leader of 1.4 billion Roman Catholics on Friday, pledging to align himself with “ordinar...

8 minutes ago

https://www.communitymedical.org/thecause?utm_source=Misfit+Digital&utm_medium=GVWire+Banner+Ads&utm_campaign=Branding+2025&utm_content=thecause
8 minutes ago

Leo XIV’s Service to Poor Propelled Him to Papacy, Cardinals Say

11 minutes ago

The State Law Taking a Financial Toll on California Budgets

Russia's Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov and Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi shake hands during a press conference following their talks in Moscow, Russia, April 18, 2025. Tatyana Makeyeva/Pool via REUTERS/File Photo
24 minutes ago

Iran to Send Russia Launchers for Short-Range Missiles, Sources Say

1 hour ago

Fresno Unified Draws Union Pushback in Social Media Battle With Teachers

1 hour ago

Today Harvard Is the Target. Tomorrow It Could Be Your Church.

Suspect Luigi Mangione is taken into the Blair County Courthouse on Tuesday, Dec. 10, 2024, in Hollidaysburg, Pa. (Benjamin B. Braun/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette via AP)
1 hour ago

‘Luigi Mangione Act’ Seeks to Block Health Insurance Denials, Sparks Outrage Over Name

2 hours ago

Jerry Springer — Yes, That Jerry Springer — Can Save the Democrats

Newark Liberty International Airport in Newark, N.J., on Wednesday, May 7, 2025. An air traffic control facility that guides planes at Newark Liberty suffered a 90-second radar outage just before 4 a.m on the morning of May 9, the latest technological disruption at one of the nation’s busiest airports. (Dakota Santiago/The New York Times)
2 hours ago

Newark Airport Has Another Radar Outage

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend