Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Supreme Court to Hear California Case That Could Raise Price of Pork
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 2 years ago on
October 11, 2022

Share

 

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court will hear arguments over a California animal cruelty law that could raise the cost of bacon and other pork products nationwide.

The case’s outcome is important to the nation’s $26-billion-a-year pork industry, but the outcome could also limit states’ ability to pass laws with impact outside their borders, from laws aimed at combating climate change to others intended to regulate prescription drug prices.

The case before the court on Tuesday involves California’s Proposition 12, which voters passed in 2018. It said that pork sold in the state needs to come from pigs whose mothers were raised with at least 24 square feet of space, including the ability to lie down and turn around. That rules out the confined “gestation crates,” metal enclosures that are common in the pork industry.

Two industry groups, the Iowa-based National Pork Producers Council and the American Farm Bureau Federation, sued over the proposition. They say that while Californians consume 13% of the pork eaten in the United States, nearly 100% of it comes from hogs raised outside the state, primarily where the industry is concentrated in the Midwest and North Carolina. The vast majority of sows, meanwhile, aren’t raised under conditions that would meet Proposition 12’s standards.

The question for the high court is whether California has impermissibly burdened the pork market and improperly regulated an industry outside its borders.

Pork producers argue that 72% of farmers use individual pens for sows that don’t allow them to turn around, and that even farmers who house sows in larger group pens don’t provide the space California would require.

They also say that the way the pork market works, with cuts of meat from various producers being combined before sale, it’s likely all pork would have to meet California standards, regardless of where it’s sold. Complying with Proposition 12 could cost the industry $290 million to $350 million, they say.

Law Still Pending

So far, lower courts have sided with California and animal-welfare groups that had supported the proposition. But for a number of reasons the law has yet to go into effect.

The Biden administration, for its part, is urging the justices to side with pork producers. The administration says Proposition 12 would be a “wholesale change in how pork is raised and marketed in this country.” And it says the proposition has “thrown a giant wrench into the workings of the interstate market in pork.”

California’s Proposition 12 also covers other animals. It says egg-laying hens and calves being raised for veal need to be raised in conditions in which they have enough room to lie down, stand up, and turn around freely. Those parts of the law aren’t at issue in the case.

The case is National Pork Producers Council v. Ross, 21-468.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Filmmaker Jeff Aiello Is Leaving Valley PBS. Station Is Seeking New CEO/President.

DON'T MISS

Students, Faculty Call for University of Texas President to Resign Over Handling of Gaza Protests

DON'T MISS

Why Is Fresno Unified Holding a Rare Wednesday Morning Special Meeting?

DON'T MISS

Here’s Why There’s Global Alarm Over Israel’s Rafah Offensive

DON'T MISS

This Fresno University Hopes to Cash in on $1.5 Million Matching Challenge

DON'T MISS

As California Cracks Down on Groundwater, What Happens to Fallowed Farmland?

DON'T MISS

Study Says California’s 2023 Snowy Megadrought Rescue Was a Freak Event

DON'T MISS

Planning for Potential Presidential Transition Underway by Biden Administration

DON'T MISS

US Is Building a Pier off Gaza to Bring in Humanitarian Aid. Here’s How It Would Work.

DON'T MISS

Earth Day Offers Family Friendly Activities Saturday at Fresno City College

UP NEXT

Ex-State Department Official: Israeli Military Gets Preferential Treatment on Abuses

UP NEXT

Biden Signs a $95 Billion War Aid Measure With Assistance for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan

UP NEXT

Columbia Cancels In-Person Classes as Demonstrations Sprout on US Campuses to Protest Israel War

UP NEXT

Senate Will Convene the Mayorkas Impeachment Trial as Democrats Plot a Quick Dismissal

UP NEXT

Cranes Arriving to Start Removing Wreckage From Deadly Baltimore Bridge Collapse

UP NEXT

Biden ‘Continues to Be Fit for Duty’ His Doctor Says After President’s Annual Exam

UP NEXT

Federal Student Loans for Nearly 153,000 Borrowers Being Canceled, Biden Says

UP NEXT

Fani Willis’ Father Says He Didn’t Know About Willis’ Relationship with Prosecutor Until Recently

UP NEXT

Shooting After Chiefs Super Bowl Parade Seemed to Stem from Dispute Among Several People, Police Say

UP NEXT

Russia Has Obtained a ‘Troubling’ Emerging Anti-Satellite Weapon, The White House Says

Here’s Why There’s Global Alarm Over Israel’s Rafah Offensive

1 hour ago

This Fresno University Hopes to Cash in on $1.5 Million Matching Challenge

Local Education /

2 hours ago

As California Cracks Down on Groundwater, What Happens to Fallowed Farmland?

2 hours ago

Study Says California’s 2023 Snowy Megadrought Rescue Was a Freak Event

3 hours ago

Planning for Potential Presidential Transition Underway by Biden Administration

3 hours ago

US Is Building a Pier off Gaza to Bring in Humanitarian Aid. Here’s How It Would Work.

4 hours ago

Earth Day Offers Family Friendly Activities Saturday at Fresno City College

4 hours ago

The 49ers Balance Immediate Needs With Long-Term Plans in NFL Draft

4 hours ago

Dodgers Play an Entire Game Without Striking out Once for the First Time Since 2006

4 hours ago

Uncertain Futures for LeBron, Lakers’ Coach After Elimination From Playoffs by Nuggets Again

4 hours ago

Filmmaker Jeff Aiello Is Leaving Valley PBS. Station Is Seeking New CEO/President.

Valley PBS is embarking on a search for a new president/CEO to replace Jeff Aiello, a local filmmaker who took the top job three years ago w...
Local /

30 mins ago

Local /
30 mins ago

Filmmaker Jeff Aiello Is Leaving Valley PBS. Station Is Seeking New CEO/President.

44 mins ago

Students, Faculty Call for University of Texas President to Resign Over Handling of Gaza Protests

Local Education /
57 mins ago

Why Is Fresno Unified Holding a Rare Wednesday Morning Special Meeting?

1 hour ago

Here’s Why There’s Global Alarm Over Israel’s Rafah Offensive

Local Education /
2 hours ago

This Fresno University Hopes to Cash in on $1.5 Million Matching Challenge

2 hours ago

As California Cracks Down on Groundwater, What Happens to Fallowed Farmland?

Mammoth snow
3 hours ago

Study Says California’s 2023 Snowy Megadrought Rescue Was a Freak Event

3 hours ago

Planning for Potential Presidential Transition Underway by Biden Administration

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend