Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Fresno Breaks Up with Park Operator Over Alleged Million Dollar Miss
David Website Replacement
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 2 weeks ago on
November 6, 2024

The city of Fresno is terminating its lease with the Central Valley Community Sports Foundation for Granite Park due to over $1 million in unpaid fees, with a three-day notice to vacate and potential legal action if not complied with. (GV Wire Composite/Paul Marshall)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Citing more than a million dollars in unpaid fees, the city of Fresno announced it is terminating its lease for the Granite Park with the nonprofit that runs the sports park.

In a letter dated Nov. 6 from City Manager Georgeanne White, the city informed Central Valley Community Sports Foundation of a three-day termination notice.

“You are required to vacate and surrender possession of the premises to the City within three days,” the letter said.

If CVCSF does not comply, “legal proceedings will be initiated.”

“The City will no longer be subsidizing CVCSF’s operations at Granite Park. However, all existing agreements for baseball and soccer events will continue to be honored by the City,” the city said in a news release.

News of the lease termination was a surprise to Terance Frazier, CVCSF president, when asked for comment. He did not have any further comment at this time.

Frazier’s nonprofit is also in litigation with neighbor Club One Casino over the use of parking spaces. Last month, a judge denied an injunction request that would deny patrons of the sports complex at Granite Park to use the parking lot at Club One Casino.

At the time, Frazier said he is committed to operating Granite Park.

“I thought about my purpose in life. I don’t think there’s ever been a time where I felt like I should give it back. I think kids need a place to play. The community enjoys the park. I enjoy going out there, listen to the kids having a great time,” Frazier said.

CVCSF filed a countersuit that also named the city of Fresno as a cross-defendant. The case returns to court Jan. 15.

City and Foundation Battling for Years

Once a weed-infested eye sore, the city entered into a lease with CVCSF in 2015. The nonprofit would run the park and receive a $150,000 yearly subsidy. CVCSF and the city would also share in electronic billboard revenue, for the signs that are visible from Highway 168.

Things turned sour in 2018, when CVCSF asked the city to double its payment. That resulted in an audit that found financial irregularities — that Frazier, and his then CVCSF-partner TJ Cox denied — and eventually a lawsuit. That case is set to resume in federal court next year.

City: CVCSF Owes $1.3 Million

In a May 17 letter to Frazier, White wrote that nonprofit owes $708,298 in back rent. Furthermore, the city paid $262,899 to PG&E, and $151,208 for water and sewer.

The lease also calls for a split of digital billboard revenues for the signs along the edge of Granite Park visible from Highway 168. The city said the foundation owes $181,000 as part of the sharing agreement.

White also accused CVCSF of multiple lease violations, including not maintaining a separate fund for capital improvements, failing to seek approval for concessions and improvements, neglecting park maintenance, not indemnifying the city, granting unauthorized licenses, and violating parking regulations.

The city said CVCSF has not made required improvements for the basketball and volleyball courts. It accused CVCSF of building soccer fields without the city’s consent.

White demanded CVCSF make good on its rent and utilities, cancel a concert (CVCSF did not), and cancel its deal with the soccer team. It it did not comply within 60 days, “the City will be forced to pursue its rights and remedies, at law and in equity, including, but not limited to, termination of the Ground Lease,” the letter said.

Granite Park: Read the Lease

CVCSF responded with a May 22 letter from attorney Kevin Little, saying the city has misinterpreted the lease, and to let the pending court case settle certain matters.

A second letter, dated Aug. 12, answered the city’s charges in a more point-by-point manner. It said the city “falsely” accused the nonprofit of defaulting on its ground lease “all of which are completely false.”

“It is obvious that whoever drafted your letter for you (sent by the city to CVSCSF on May 17, 2024) did not bother to even read the lease, nor attempt to reconcile the various provisions of the lease,” the Aug. 12 CVCSF response said.

Regarding the unpaid rent, the nonprofit countered that any rent would be credited against the value of improvements made, estimated at $2.7 million.

CVSCSF said it made more than $2 million in improvements and Granite Park appraised for $4.3 million in 2021.

“The Foundation has an accrued rent credit of between 35 years and 70 years, which makes the allegation of your letter not only patently false but also defamatory,” the Aug. 12 letter said. CVCSF demanded a retraction from City Manager Georgeanne White.

The CVSCSF letter said it has “a legally binding payment plan in effect with PG&E, which made the payments from the City gratuitous and without basis in law or in fact. You should contact PG&E and demand a refund.”

CVSCSF pointed out that the city, in the lease, would make a “reasonable effort” to provide purple pipe water — also known as recycled water — to help irrigate the fields, and in theory, keep the park’s water costs down.

The nonprofit said those efforts have been illusionary.

“(The city’s promise) has never been fulfilled and no reasonable efforts have ever been made by the City to provide such water, even though the infrastructure to receive the ‘purple pipe’ water have been installed,” the response letter said.

CVSCSF said the lease allows it to keep the first $60,000 of yearly billboard revenue to help fund the capital reserve account. The rest is split between the nonprofit and the city.

The nonprofit said it re-invests all revenue back into the park, noting that it still operates the park at a deficit.

“Since the City has never operated any programming at Granite Park all of the revenue generated is used to support the Foundation’s efforts to provide all of the programming. The City does not get to keep what you describe as its share of the billboard money,” the response letter said.

Pending Lawsuit in Federal Court

While the parking lawsuit and the letters continue, Frazier still has a lawsuit stemming from the audit in federal court.

Even an attempted settlement in 2021 led to the unusual intervention of Fresno County District Attorney Lisa Smittcamp.

A day before the scheduled June 2021 city council discussion, Smittcamp sent a letter to the city alleging possible Brown Act violations — the state’s open meeting laws.

The city council canceled the Frazier settlement talks. Smittcamp eventually dropped her investigation into possible illegal secret meetings — citing a lack of cooperation and not enough evidence to move forward.

The August Granite Park letter to the city addressed the upcoming federal court hearing.

“We are aware that the City Council set aside $1,000,000 to address deferred maintenance at Granite Park. What happened to that money? Did you purposefully can it out of spite for the federal lawsuit?” the letter said.

The letter also ponders if the city is treating other tenants of city-owned properties differently, such as the Fresno Grizzlies lease at Chukchansi Park.

The city has renegotiated the lease for the minor league baseball team several times, mostly in the team’s favor.

“Considering Granite Park serves approximately 300,000 customers, the same as the Grizzlies baseball club, why is Granite Park being treated differently? The City will eventually need to answer that question,” the letter said.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Many in Gaza Are Eating Just Once a Day, as Hunger Spreads Amid Aid Issues

DON'T MISS

Norwegian Student Arrested on Charges of Spying on US for Russia

DON'T MISS

Eagles Seek to Extend Win Streak in Prime-Time Clash With Resurgent Rams

DON'T MISS

Nick Chubb Plows Through Heavy Snow as Browns Beat Steelers

DON'T MISS

German Auto Supplier Bosch to Cut 5,500 Jobs in Further Sign of Carmakers’ Woes

DON'T MISS

Woman Found Dead in Fresno. Homicide Investigation Underway.

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Allows Multibillion-Dollar Class Action to Proceed Against Meta

DON'T MISS

Brock Purdy’s Status for the 49ers in Doubt This Week Because of Sore Shoulder

DON'T MISS

JD Vance Is Leaving the Senate for the Vice Presidency. That’s Set Off a Scramble for His Ohio Seat

DON'T MISS

A Proposed Deal on Climate Cash at UN Summit Highlights Split Between Rich and Poor Nations

UP NEXT

Norwegian Student Arrested on Charges of Spying on US for Russia

UP NEXT

Eagles Seek to Extend Win Streak in Prime-Time Clash With Resurgent Rams

UP NEXT

Nick Chubb Plows Through Heavy Snow as Browns Beat Steelers

UP NEXT

German Auto Supplier Bosch to Cut 5,500 Jobs in Further Sign of Carmakers’ Woes

UP NEXT

Woman Found Dead in Fresno. Homicide Investigation Underway.

UP NEXT

Supreme Court Allows Multibillion-Dollar Class Action to Proceed Against Meta

UP NEXT

Brock Purdy’s Status for the 49ers in Doubt This Week Because of Sore Shoulder

UP NEXT

JD Vance Is Leaving the Senate for the Vice Presidency. That’s Set Off a Scramble for His Ohio Seat

UP NEXT

A Proposed Deal on Climate Cash at UN Summit Highlights Split Between Rich and Poor Nations

UP NEXT

Amazon to Invest an Additional $4 Billion in AI Startup Anthropic

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Nick Chubb Plows Through Heavy Snow as Browns Beat Steelers

17 minutes ago

German Auto Supplier Bosch to Cut 5,500 Jobs in Further Sign of Carmakers’ Woes

22 minutes ago

Woman Found Dead in Fresno. Homicide Investigation Underway.

22 minutes ago

Supreme Court Allows Multibillion-Dollar Class Action to Proceed Against Meta

27 minutes ago

Brock Purdy’s Status for the 49ers in Doubt This Week Because of Sore Shoulder

32 minutes ago

JD Vance Is Leaving the Senate for the Vice Presidency. That’s Set Off a Scramble for His Ohio Seat

54 minutes ago

A Proposed Deal on Climate Cash at UN Summit Highlights Split Between Rich and Poor Nations

1 hour ago

Amazon to Invest an Additional $4 Billion in AI Startup Anthropic

1 hour ago

Northern California Gets Record Rain and Heavy Snow. Many Have Been in the Dark for Days in Seattle

1 hour ago

Franz Wagner Hits a Clutch 3, and the Magic Exploit Davis’ Mistakes for a Win Over Lakers

1 hour ago

Many in Gaza Are Eating Just Once a Day, as Hunger Spreads Amid Aid Issues

DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip — Yasmin Eid coughs and covers her face, cooking a small pot of lentils over a fire fed with twigs and scrap paper...

5 minutes ago

5 minutes ago

Many in Gaza Are Eating Just Once a Day, as Hunger Spreads Amid Aid Issues

14 minutes ago

Norwegian Student Arrested on Charges of Spying on US for Russia

Rams
15 minutes ago

Eagles Seek to Extend Win Streak in Prime-Time Clash With Resurgent Rams

17 minutes ago

Nick Chubb Plows Through Heavy Snow as Browns Beat Steelers

22 minutes ago

German Auto Supplier Bosch to Cut 5,500 Jobs in Further Sign of Carmakers’ Woes

22 minutes ago

Woman Found Dead in Fresno. Homicide Investigation Underway.

27 minutes ago

Supreme Court Allows Multibillion-Dollar Class Action to Proceed Against Meta

32 minutes ago

Brock Purdy’s Status for the 49ers in Doubt This Week Because of Sore Shoulder

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend