Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Real Estate Group Won't Fight Affordable Housing Measure — for a Price
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 6 months ago on
June 26, 2024

In a surprising twist, California's real estate lobby has agreed to stop opposing an affordable housing measure, but there's a catch. (CalMatters/CatchLight Local/Larry Valenzuela)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

A November ballot measure to make it easier for local governments to borrow money for new infrastructure and affordable housing will likely include a big exception, preventing that money from being used to buy single-family homes. That’s thanks to a last-minute deal hammered out between a top legislative Democrat and the state real estate lobby.

Author Profile Picture

Ben Christopher

CalMatters

Thursday is the deadline for state lawmakers to get their preferred initiatives finalized for the Nov. 5 ballot. That makes these final weeks of June peak sausage-making season in the state Capitol.

The affordable housing measure is a prime example of legislative bratwurst.

Last year, Davis Democratic Assemblymember Cecilia Aguiar-Curry pushed through the proposed amendment to the state constitution that would lower the electoral bar that local infrastructure and housing bonds need to clear. Currently, that threshold sits at a heightened two-thirds majority of voters. Aguiar-Curry’s proposal, which had failed to get out of the Legislature three times until last session, would bring that figure down to a more attainable 55%.

Though the amendment passed last year, it left some implementation questions unanswered. Two bills — ACA 10 and AB 2813 — were introduced to do that tweaking. That set of a fresh months-long round of negotiations.

After winning an exemption for single-family home, duplex, triplex and fourplex purchases, the California Association of Realtors announced that it would no longer oppose the legislation — and by implication, the Nov. 5 ballot measure.

“Over the course of several months, the author, her staff and stakeholders were able to reach an agreement that satisfies the concerns C.A.R. raised. C.A.R. would like to thank the author for her leadership and steadfast commitment to ensuring that homeownership can become a reality for generations of Californians,” the organization’s lobbyist Vanessa Chavez said in a letter obtained by CalMatters.

The ballot measure would still allow local bond issues to provide funds for the construction of smaller affordable units. The ban applies to purchasing existing homes — notably, one of the ways that Realtors make money.

The neutrality of the Realtors — regularly among the biggest campaign spenders in California — is a political win for backers of the initiative. (It is still opposed by the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, which issued a statement saying it will fight it “with all our strength.)

The Opposition to the Realtors’ Deal

But many of the supporters of the constitutional amendment aren’t pleased about the last-minute agreement. Earlier this week, a coalition of tenant rights groups, “Yes in My Backyard” advocates and legal aid associations penned a letter urging Aguiar-Curry not to accept the Realtors deal, saying that it would “enshrine a discriminatory housing policy in state law.”

Exempting single-family homes from a statewide affordable housing policy is also symbolically hard to swallow, said Francisco Dueñas, executive director of the nonprofit advocacy organization Housing Now!

“The single family map that we have now comes from a lot of redlining, from racist systems that we’ve had in the past,” he said. “If we are again saying that those areas are off the table for these solutions, are we then further enshrining the legacy of these racist policies?”

Dueñas also said the new restrictions on bond funds would prohibit local governments from pursuing novel approaches to housing affordability, including community land trusts.

Though the Realtors won a key exemption, there are exceptions to that exemption. Local governments could still use the funds to purchase homes and reserve them for “survivors of domestic violence, refugees, or people with developmental disabilities.”

Making it easier to pass housing bonds is a top priority for affordable housing advocates this year. That’s especially true for those in the San Francisco Bay Area, where a first-of-its-kind regional housing finance authority plans to float an IOU of as much as $20 billion to fund housing projects across the region, if voters approve in November.

About the Author

Ben Christopher covers housing policy for CalMatters. Ben has profiled the people who fell through the cracks of California’s rickety COVID rent relief program, demystified the perennial debate between state regulators and local governments opposed to new housing, covered innovative ideas from cities on how to tackle their local housing shortages and explained how complicated legislative proposals about zoning, bonds and corporate ownership of single-family homes affect everyday Californians.

About CalMatters

CalMatters is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom committed to explaining California policy and politics.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Ukraine Slows Firing of Missiles Into Russia as Trump Prepares to Take Office

DON'T MISS

Migrants and End of COVID Restrictions Fuel Jump in US Homelessness

DON'T MISS

Tesla Investors Are Still Bullish. Can Elon Musk Deliver?

DON'T MISS

Visalia Police Investigate Armed Robbery at Spa Involving Four Masked Men

DON'T MISS

Surging Rams Host Cardinals in Rematch of Rare Blowout Loss for McVay

DON'T MISS

Tulare County Drive-By Shooting Leaves One Injured

DON'T MISS

Chargers Focus on Avoiding a Letdown in Matchup with Patriots

DON'T MISS

Lions Head Into NFC Title Game Rematch vs. 49ers Seeking Top Seed

DON'T MISS

Gavin Newsom Faces National Spotlight: 2024 Year in Review

DON'T MISS

Azerbaijani Minister Says Plane That Crashed Was Hit From the Outside, Possibly by a Weapon

UP NEXT

Migrants and End of COVID Restrictions Fuel Jump in US Homelessness

UP NEXT

Tesla Investors Are Still Bullish. Can Elon Musk Deliver?

UP NEXT

Visalia Police Investigate Armed Robbery at Spa Involving Four Masked Men

UP NEXT

Surging Rams Host Cardinals in Rematch of Rare Blowout Loss for McVay

UP NEXT

Tulare County Drive-By Shooting Leaves One Injured

UP NEXT

Chargers Focus on Avoiding a Letdown in Matchup with Patriots

UP NEXT

Lions Head Into NFC Title Game Rematch vs. 49ers Seeking Top Seed

UP NEXT

Gavin Newsom Faces National Spotlight: 2024 Year in Review

UP NEXT

Azerbaijani Minister Says Plane That Crashed Was Hit From the Outside, Possibly by a Weapon

UP NEXT

China Sanctions 7 Companies Over US Military Assistance to Taiwan

Visalia Police Investigate Armed Robbery at Spa Involving Four Masked Men

57 minutes ago

Surging Rams Host Cardinals in Rematch of Rare Blowout Loss for McVay

2 hours ago

Tulare County Drive-By Shooting Leaves One Injured

2 hours ago

Chargers Focus on Avoiding a Letdown in Matchup with Patriots

2 hours ago

Lions Head Into NFC Title Game Rematch vs. 49ers Seeking Top Seed

2 hours ago

Gavin Newsom Faces National Spotlight: 2024 Year in Review

2 hours ago

Azerbaijani Minister Says Plane That Crashed Was Hit From the Outside, Possibly by a Weapon

2 hours ago

China Sanctions 7 Companies Over US Military Assistance to Taiwan

2 hours ago

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Wants to Ban Drug Ads on TV. It Wouldn’t Be Easy.

2 hours ago

Man Indicted in Burning Death of Woman Inside a New York City Subway Train, Prosecutors Say

2 hours ago

Ukraine Slows Firing of Missiles Into Russia as Trump Prepares to Take Office

KYIV, Ukraine — With much fanfare, Ukraine was granted permission to fire Western long-range missiles at Russian military targets more than ...

13 minutes ago

An image released by Russia’s defense ministry on Nov. 26, 2024, purportedly of the remains of a U.S.-produced ATACMS missile, at the airport Kursk-Vostochny airport, outside Kursk. With much fanfare, Ukraine was granted permission to fire Western long-range missiles at Russian military targets more than a month ago. But after initially firing a flurry of them, Ukraine has already slowed their use. (Russian Defense Ministry via The New York Times)
13 minutes ago

Ukraine Slows Firing of Missiles Into Russia as Trump Prepares to Take Office

Tents of unhoused people in Ashland, Ore. on Dec. 7, 2024. The number of people experiencing homelessness in America topped 770,000, a one-year increase of more than 18% and the largest annual increase since data began in 2007, according to a Department of Housing and Urban Development report released on Dec. 27. (Ruth Fremson/ The New York Times)..
24 minutes ago

Migrants and End of COVID Restrictions Fuel Jump in US Homelessness

A Tesla Cybertruck in the Mission District of San Francisco on Nov. 6, 2024. The Cybertruck is Tesla’s first new model since 2020, but its sales have been much more modest than those of the company’s most popular car, the Model Y. (Loren Elliott/The New York Times)
48 minutes ago

Tesla Investors Are Still Bullish. Can Elon Musk Deliver?

57 minutes ago

Visalia Police Investigate Armed Robbery at Spa Involving Four Masked Men

Rams
2 hours ago

Surging Rams Host Cardinals in Rematch of Rare Blowout Loss for McVay

A victim was injured in a Pixley drive-by shooting early Friday, with the suspect fleeing in a silver or gray Toyota sedan. (Tulare County SO)
2 hours ago

Tulare County Drive-By Shooting Leaves One Injured

2 hours ago

Chargers Focus on Avoiding a Letdown in Matchup with Patriots

2 hours ago

Lions Head Into NFC Title Game Rematch vs. 49ers Seeking Top Seed

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend