Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
CA's High Construction Costs Limit Housing. A Supreme Court Decision Might Help
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 1 month ago on
April 16, 2024

Extremely high construction costs make it difficult for California to solve its housing crisis, but a Supreme Court decision on impact fees could lower some costs. (CalMatters/Rahul Lal)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

California’s chronic inability to build enough housing – particularly for low-income families – has many causes, but a big one is its extremely high cost of construction.

Dan Walters Profile Picture
Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Some costs are intrinsic and unavoidable, such as land acquisition and building materials. But some are artificial and could be lowered, especially those imposed by state and local governments. They include dictating the use of high-cost unionized construction labor, time-consuming environmental clearances, arbitrary design criteria and so-called “impact fees.”

Collectively, these costs have the effect of minimizing the number of housing units that can be constructed for a given amount of investment – less bang for the buck.

Four years ago, the Los Angeles Times illustrated the syndrome by delving into a decade-long effort to construct a small apartment project for low-income residents of Solana Beach, an affluent coastal community in San Diego County.

What was proposed in 2009 as an 18-apartment project that would cost $413,913 per unit became – after 10 years of political and legal wrangling – a 10-apartment project costing more than $1 million a unit. It simply would not pencil out and was ultimately suspended.

Solana Beach was not an isolated example. Other projects costing $1-plus million per unit have surfaced, including one approved last week in Santa Monica, another upscale coastal community.

The 122-unit project, aimed at providing shelter for homeless people and built on city-owned land, will cost an estimated $123.1 million. It could become even costlier because of an extended development timeline: It’s not expected to be built until 2030.

In Some Cases, the Cost of Housing Defies Logic

Development costs are particularly high in coastal communities, but even in interior areas building modest apartments for low-income residents easily tops $500,000 per unit, which is often costlier than single-family homes in those communities. It defies logic but that’s the reality of housing in California.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled unanimously that fees constitute an unconstitutional “taking” of private property without compensation unless based on actual costs.

As mentioned earlier, the many cost factors affecting housing in California also include impact fees.

While local governments had imposed some fees for decades, they began escalating sharply after voters in 1978 passed Proposition 13, the iconic property tax limit, to offset the loss of tax revenue.

A 2015 study found that California’s fees, averaging $23,000 a unit, were the highest in the nation and four times the national average. Housing advocates have argued that reducing fees would increase production but local governments have zealously defended them.

Supreme Court Hits the Brakes on California Impact Fees

Last week, as Santa Monica was approving the low-income housing project costing more than $1 million a unit, the U.S. Supreme Court was putting the brakes on California’s impact fees. The court ruled unanimously that fees constitute an unconstitutional “taking” of private property without compensation unless based on actual costs.

The case came out of El Dorado County, which had imposed a $23,420 “traffic impact” fee on retiree George Sheetz, who wanted to place a manufactured home on his lot. Sheetz lost in state courts, which ruled that since the traffic fee was imposed by the county Board of Supervisors – rather than an administrative agency – it was a valid exercise of authority.

The Supreme Court, however, declared, “The Constitution provides no textual justification for saying that the existence or the scope of a state’s power to expropriate private property without just compensation varies according to the branch of government effecting the expropriation.”

Oddly, even though Gov. Gavin Newsom’s administration has excoriated local governments for imposing arbitrary and costly conditions on housing projects, it supported El Dorado County’s defense of traffic mitigation fees before the Supreme Court.

The ruling is a small step toward reducing some of the costs that make housing so expensive to build in California – a syndrome that, unless altered, will forever prevent the state from solving its housing dilemma.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Will Becerra Run for Governor? He Tours UCSF Fresno With Costa

DON'T MISS

Israeli Defense Chief Opposes ‘Israeli Military Rule’ in Gaza

DON'T MISS

Nelly Korda Triumphs at Mizuho Americas Open

DON'T MISS

Sheriff’s Office to Break Ground on Memorial for Fallen Officers. What Will It Look Like?

DON'T MISS

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

DON'T MISS

Operation Gridlock: 32 Arrests, 59 Gun Seized, Violent Gangs Dismantled

DON'T MISS

Bulldogs Blasted by Air Force, Fall to 4th Seed for MW Tourney

DON'T MISS

What Drives California’s Budget Decisions? A Lot of Politics, Not as Much Data

DON'T MISS

Brunson’s Broken Left Hand in Game 7 the Final Injury for Eliminated Knicks

DON'T MISS

Students Stage Mass Walkout in Pro-Palestinian Protest, UC Academic Workers Authorize Strike

UP NEXT

Israeli Defense Chief Opposes ‘Israeli Military Rule’ in Gaza

UP NEXT

Nelly Korda Triumphs at Mizuho Americas Open

UP NEXT

Sheriff’s Office to Break Ground on Memorial for Fallen Officers. What Will It Look Like?

UP NEXT

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

UP NEXT

Operation Gridlock: 32 Arrests, 59 Gun Seized, Violent Gangs Dismantled

UP NEXT

Bulldogs Blasted by Air Force, Fall to 4th Seed for MW Tourney

UP NEXT

What Drives California’s Budget Decisions? A Lot of Politics, Not as Much Data

UP NEXT

Brunson’s Broken Left Hand in Game 7 the Final Injury for Eliminated Knicks

UP NEXT

Extremists Reign in Israel After Decades of Unchecked Violence

UP NEXT

Clovis East Alum DeChambeau Puts on a Show at PGA Championship, Falls 1 Stroke Short

Sheriff’s Office to Break Ground on Memorial for Fallen Officers. What Will It Look Like?

3 hours ago

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

4 hours ago

Operation Gridlock: 32 Arrests, 59 Gun Seized, Violent Gangs Dismantled

4 hours ago

Bulldogs Blasted by Air Force, Fall to 4th Seed for MW Tourney

5 hours ago

What Drives California’s Budget Decisions? A Lot of Politics, Not as Much Data

6 hours ago

Brunson’s Broken Left Hand in Game 7 the Final Injury for Eliminated Knicks

6 hours ago

Students Stage Mass Walkout in Pro-Palestinian Protest, UC Academic Workers Authorize Strike

6 hours ago

Extremists Reign in Israel After Decades of Unchecked Violence

6 hours ago

Clovis East Alum DeChambeau Puts on a Show at PGA Championship, Falls 1 Stroke Short

6 hours ago

Wolves Reach Western Finals With Talent and Tenacity in Quest for First NBA Title

6 hours ago

Will Becerra Run for Governor? He Tours UCSF Fresno With Costa

U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra is rumored to be a candidate for California governor in 2026. During a visit to Fres...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Will Becerra Run for Governor? He Tours UCSF Fresno With Costa

Image of Benjamin Netanyahu on a hill looking down on a West Bank neighborhood
3 hours ago

Israeli Defense Chief Opposes ‘Israeli Military Rule’ in Gaza

3 hours ago

Nelly Korda Triumphs at Mizuho Americas Open

3 hours ago

Sheriff’s Office to Break Ground on Memorial for Fallen Officers. What Will It Look Like?

4 hours ago

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

4 hours ago

Operation Gridlock: 32 Arrests, 59 Gun Seized, Violent Gangs Dismantled

5 hours ago

Bulldogs Blasted by Air Force, Fall to 4th Seed for MW Tourney

6 hours ago

What Drives California’s Budget Decisions? A Lot of Politics, Not as Much Data

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend