Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Fresno Arts Council Clings to Recovered Measure P Funds. City Is Suing
Edward Smith updated website photo 2024
By Edward Smith
Published 30 seconds ago on
November 19, 2026

The city of Fresno is suing the Fresno Arts Council. City officials say the arts council needs to return to the taxpayers nearly $1 million in restitution made by PayPal following an $1.5 million embezzlement of Measure P Funds. (GV Wire Composite)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The Fresno City Attorney’s Office announced it was suing the Fresno Arts Council over how it handled Measure P, allowing $1.5 million to be stolen by an officer with the nonprofit.

Additionally, the city in its lawsuit says the arts council is holding onto nearly $1 million of recovered funds they previously agreed to pay back. The Fresno Arts Council declined to comment.

In August, a federal grand jury sentenced former arts council operations manager Suliana Caldwell to 33 months in federal prison for embezzlement.

The city’s lawsuit seeks full restitution, damages for breach of contract, and strict enforcement of public accountability standards. It has requested $2.1 million to cover losses and attorney and expert fees.

“Sending one employee to federal prison does not let the Fresno Arts Council off the hook for its gross negligence and breach of contract,” City Attorney Andrew Janz said. “We are taking them to court to aggressively claw back every single dollar stolen from Fresno taxpayers.”

Arts Council Received $901k Payout From PayPal in September

In September, the Fresno Arts Council received $901,884 in PayPal funds as reimbursement for the theft. Two days after that, the court ordered Caldwell to pay nearly $1.2 million to the city as restitution. Caldwell’s plea agreement does not grant any restitution to PayPal or the arts council, the lawsuit states.

The lawsuit states that the arts council told the city it would not spend the money without notice to the city.

The city now says it is owed the money returned to the arts council.

“To date, none of the Measure P funds have been returned to the City despite repeated demands by the city under the agreement,” the lawsuit states. “These funds belong to the citizens of the city and were unlawfully returned by PayPal to the Arts Council, rather than the city.”

Arts Council Didn’t Monitor Accounts

In February, the city announced that $1.5 million of Measure P funds had been stolen by an arts council worker. It later came out that the employee was Caldwell. In total, including other funds, Caldwell stole $1.8 million.

According to the city’s legal complaint, Caldwell had only a high school level education and was a truck driver before becoming the council’s operations manager.

Beginning in June 2022, Caldwell began stealing money from the arts council, transferring money from a PayPal account overseen by former executive director Liliana Gonzalez-Chavez to her own.

The complaint states that Gonzalez-Chavez was not monitoring the accounts.

The city began sending Measure P money in August 2022 to the arts council to administer as grants to local artists.

“The unauthorized transfers by Caldwell significantly increased in 2023 when the Arts Council received millions of dollars in Measure P funds from the City,” the lawsuit states.

City Pays to Make Artists Whole, Wants Money Back

Problems began in 2024, the lawsuit states.

That September, when the arts council gave its annual financial report, it told the city that no grants had been awarded, despite receiving $9.7 million in November 2023 and money being expended.

Regardless, the city gave the arts council $5.7 million to distribute for the next year.

Throughout much of 2025, Caldwell had been absent from work, the lawsuit states. Despite that, the arts council kept her on staff.

By September 2025, when the city received its second financial report from the organization, they found an incomplete spending spreadsheet.

About that same time, artists reported that checks were bouncing due to insufficient funds in the organization’s accounts.

After hearing those complaints, Gonzalez-Chavez logged into the official account and saw large transfers of Measure P funds to Caldwell’s accounts, including PayPal accounts in her name, her maiden name, and an account titled “Suliana25.”

The Fresno Police Department and the FBI began investigating, and by Feb. 9, the city paid to make artists whole.

“The city has fulfilled its obligations to the citizens of the city to fund the arts community,” the lawsuit states. “However, because of defendant’s conduct, the City was forced to use funding, earmarked for other City programs, to fund the arts community.”

RELATED TOPICS:

Edward Smith,
Multimedia Journalist
Edward Smith began reporting for GV Wire in May 2023. His reporting career began at Fresno City College, graduating with an associate degree in journalism. After leaving school he spent the next six years with The Business Journal, doing research for the publication as well as covering the restaurant industry. Soon after, he took on real estate and agriculture beats, winning multiple awards at the local, state and national level. You can contact Edward at 559-440-8372 or at Edward.Smith@gvwire.com.
Send this to a friend