Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Kamala Harris Hasn’t Yet Earned My Vote
d8a347b41db1ddee634e2d67d08798c102ef09ac
By The New York Times
Published 7 months ago on
September 19, 2024

The stage is set up for a campaign event for Vice President Kamala Harris, the Democratic presidential nominee, and Gov. Tim Walz of Minnesota, the Democratic vice presidential nominee, in Detroit, Aug. 7, 2024. “She did well in the debate with Donald Trump, showing poise and intelligence against a buffoonish opponent,” writes New York Times columnist Bret Stephens. “But her answers in two sit-down interviews, first with CNN’s Dana Bash and then with Brian Taff of 6ABC in Philadelphia, were lighter than air.” (Daniel Ribar/The New York Times)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Bret Stephens

Opinion

Opinion by Bret Stephens on Sept. 17, 2024.

What does Kamala Harris think the United States should do about the Houthis, whose assaults on commercial shipping threaten global trade, and whose attacks on Israel risk a much wider Mideast war? If an interviewer were to ask the vice president about them, would she be able to give a coherent and compelling answer?

It’s not an unfair or unprecedented question. As a presidential candidate, George W. Bush was quizzed on the names of the leaders of Taiwan, India, Pakistan and Chechnya. He got one right (Taiwan’s Lee Teng-hui) but drew blanks on the rest. It fueled criticism, as The New York Times’ Frank Bruni reported in 1999, that “he is not knowledgeable enough about foreign policy to lead the nation.”

A few more questions for Harris: If, as president, she had intelligence that Iran was on the cusp of assembling a nuclear weapon, would she use force to stop it? Are there limits to American support for Ukraine, and what are they? Would she push for the creation of a Palestinian state if Hamas remained a potent political force within it? Are there any regulations she’d like to get rid of in her initiative to build 3 million new homes in the next four years? What role, if any, does she see for nuclear power in her energy and climate plans? If there were another pandemic similar to COVID-19, what might her administration do differently?

It may be that Harris has thoughtful answers to these sorts of questions. If so, she isn’t letting on. She did well in the debate with Donald Trump, showing poise and intelligence against a buffoonish opponent. But her answers in two sit-down interviews, first with CNN’s Dana Bash and then with Brian Taff of 6ABC in Philadelphia, were lighter than air. Asked what she’d do to bring down prices, she talked at length about growing up middle-class among people who were proud of their lawns before pivoting to vague plans to support small business and create more housing.

Lovely. Now how about interest-rate policy, federal spending and the resilience of our supply chains?

All this helps explain my unease with the thought of voting for Harris — an unease I never felt, despite policy differences, when Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden were on the ballot against Trump. If Harris can answer the sorts of questions I posed above, she should be quick to do so, if only to dispel a widespread perception of unseriousness. If she can’t, then what was she doing over nearly eight years as a senator and vice president?

It’s not the only thing that makes a voter like me uneasy.

Biden has said we’re living through a “decisive decade” for the future of the free world, and he’s right. Does Harris have an overriding strategic concept for how to steer through it, or the instincts to respond to fast-moving crises?

Illiberal populism has taken root in response to well-founded perceptions of elite incompetence, highhandedness and self-dealing. Does Harris have anything to offer disaffected voters, or does she merely embody the elitist perspective that they despise?

When Harris says “my values have not changed” in the face of questions about her shifting positions on fracking, a border wall and health care for immigrants without legal status, does it suggest any values beyond political expediency?

But: Trump.

That’s the all-purpose response for many voters to any doubts about Harris’ qualifications. It makes November’s choice easy for anyone sincerely convinced that the former president poses an existential threat to the perpetuation of our political institutions. It also makes it easy for Never-Trumpers who hope that a decisive electoral rebuke of the former president might return the GOP to its pre-MAGA incarnation as the party of John McCain or Mitt Romney.

Yet Trump victory or no, the Republican Party isn’t likely to revert to its former ideological leanings. And the argument that Trump is our Benito Mussolini, scheming with ever-greater malevolence and cunning to end the Republic, is getting a little long in the tooth.

Trump may be much the worse sinner, but Democrats aren’t blameless when it comes to weaponizing the instruments of state power to interfere with the will of the voters. Otherwise, what does it mean to try to kick a candidate off a state ballot, or use a nakedly politicized prosecution to turn an opponent into a felon, or have powerful insiders anoint a presidential candidate without the benefit of a single primary vote?

For what my vote is worth — very little, considering I live in New York — I’d much rather cast a ballot for Harris than stay home. But votes need to be earned.

It should not be hard for Harris to demonstrate that she can give detailed answers to urgent policy questions. Or to express a sense, beyond a few canned phrases, of how she sees the American interest in a darkening world. Or to articulate a politics of genuine inclusion that reaches out to tens of millions of distrustful voters. Or to prove that she’s more than another factory-settings liberal Democrat whose greatest virtue, like her greatest fault, is that she won’t step too far from the conventional wisdom.

Seven weeks to go. Here’s hoping.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

By Bret Stephens/Daniel Ribar
c. 2024 The New York Times Company

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

This Is Who Trump Has Targeted for Retribution

DON'T MISS

Golden Charter Academy Scholars Dig Deep for a Greener Fresno

DON'T MISS

US Colleges Say International Student Visas Are Being Revoked

DON'T MISS

Trump Says US Will Talk to Iran About Ending Tehran’s Nuclear Weapons Program

DON'T MISS

Tracy Chapman Wants to Speak for Herself

DON'T MISS

Despite Councilmember’s Plea, No Beer Selling for This Fresno Store

DON'T MISS

Mega Millions Tickets Rise to $5 Each. Will That Mean More Giant Jackpots?

DON'T MISS

Hurtado’s Bill Seeks More Funds to Protect South Valley From Floods

DON'T MISS

Signs of a More Buyer-Friendly Housing Market Emerge for Spring

DON'T MISS

CA’s Homeless Shelters Aren’t for Everyone. That Doesn’t Mean They Don’t Work

UP NEXT

Trump Says US Will Talk to Iran About Ending Tehran’s Nuclear Weapons Program

UP NEXT

Tracy Chapman Wants to Speak for Herself

UP NEXT

Despite Councilmember’s Plea, No Beer Selling for This Fresno Store

UP NEXT

Mega Millions Tickets Rise to $5 Each. Will That Mean More Giant Jackpots?

UP NEXT

Hurtado’s Bill Seeks More Funds to Protect South Valley From Floods

UP NEXT

Signs of a More Buyer-Friendly Housing Market Emerge for Spring

UP NEXT

CA’s Homeless Shelters Aren’t for Everyone. That Doesn’t Mean They Don’t Work

UP NEXT

Landmark $2.8B NCAA Settlement Hearing Could Transform College Sports

UP NEXT

Alex Ovechkin Breaks Wayne Gretzky’s NHL Career Goals Record by Scoring His 895th

UP NEXT

Doncic Scores 30 Points as Lakers Dominate NBA-Leading Thunder

Trump Says US Will Talk to Iran About Ending Tehran’s Nuclear Weapons Program

1 hour ago

Tracy Chapman Wants to Speak for Herself

2 hours ago

Despite Councilmember’s Plea, No Beer Selling for This Fresno Store

2 hours ago

Mega Millions Tickets Rise to $5 Each. Will That Mean More Giant Jackpots?

3 hours ago

Hurtado’s Bill Seeks More Funds to Protect South Valley From Floods

5 hours ago

Signs of a More Buyer-Friendly Housing Market Emerge for Spring

5 hours ago

CA’s Homeless Shelters Aren’t for Everyone. That Doesn’t Mean They Don’t Work

6 hours ago

Landmark $2.8B NCAA Settlement Hearing Could Transform College Sports

7 hours ago

Is Your CA Career College or Training Program Legit? Check Its License or Violations

7 hours ago

Alex Ovechkin Breaks Wayne Gretzky’s NHL Career Goals Record by Scoring His 895th

7 hours ago

This Is Who Trump Has Targeted for Retribution

Since returning to office, President Donald Trump’s campaign to exact revenge against his foes has turned out to be far more expansive, crea...

1 minute ago

Trump Signs Executive Order
1 minute ago

This Is Who Trump Has Targeted for Retribution

32 minutes ago

Golden Charter Academy Scholars Dig Deep for a Greener Fresno

Photo of people at Harvard
39 minutes ago

US Colleges Say International Student Visas Are Being Revoked

Trump and Netanyahu in the West Wing, April 7, 2025
1 hour ago

Trump Says US Will Talk to Iran About Ending Tehran’s Nuclear Weapons Program

2 hours ago

Tracy Chapman Wants to Speak for Herself

2 hours ago

Despite Councilmember’s Plea, No Beer Selling for This Fresno Store

Mega Millions Price Increase
3 hours ago

Mega Millions Tickets Rise to $5 Each. Will That Mean More Giant Jackpots?

5 hours ago

Hurtado’s Bill Seeks More Funds to Protect South Valley From Floods

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend