Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
CCW Decision Gives Wins to Both Gun Rights Advocates and CA Legislators
Edward Smith updated website photo 2024
By Edward Smith
Published 7 months ago on
September 19, 2024

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decided Sept. 6 where CCW permit holders could bring their guns. (GV Wire Composite/Paul Marshall)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled this month on the controversial California law limiting where Concealed Carry Weapons Permit holders can take their guns, maintaining large parts of the law while striking down other parts.

Senate Bill 2 in 2023 banned guns on more than two dozen types of property and required all business owners to post whether they would allow guns on their property.

Federal Judge Susan Graber in her opinion for the 9th Circuit determined that guns could still be banned in parks, beaches, and bars and restaurants that serve alcohol.

But the court ruled that categorical bans at hospitals, banks, churches, and gatherings exceeded the state’s powers. The court also said California’s requirement that property owners have to post signs stating guns are allowed could not be defended constitutionally.

Business owners and operators can still individually decide to ban guns on their property or at their event.

But the court also left open the possibility for more lawsuits, calling the method of determining whether bans are legal “arbitrary.”

In an email to GV Wire, a spokesperson with the California Attorney General’s office — the defendant in the case — said the state is continuing to litigate the matter.

The Firearms Policy Coalition, one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit against California Attorney General Rob Bonta, called the decision a partial victory.

“This partially favorable decision from the 9th Circuit shows how far we’ve come over the past decade. But this case, and our work to restore the right to bear arms, is far from over,” said coalition president Brandon Combs. “FPC will continue to fight forward until all peaceable people can fully exercise their right to carry in California and throughout the United States.”

Bars, Restaurants, Parks, Zoos, Libraries on the Ban List

The court combined the California lawsuit with another similar lawsuit in Hawaii. Both states passed rules limiting where CCW holders can take their guns. For the more than two dozen bans separated by property types, the court looked at those properties’ place in history as they relate to the Second Amendment.

For bars and restaurants, which have existed since the passage of the Second Amendment, judges used previous bans set by cities to justify upholding the two states’ laws.

For playgrounds and youth centers, the court said since those didn’t exist in a modern since when the Second Amendment was passed, the court applied the distinction of being a “sensitive place” and upheld the ban.

“Because many laws prohibited carrying firearms in parks, and the constitutionality of those laws was not in dispute, we agree with the 2nd Circuit and several district courts that the Nation’s historical tradition includes regulating firearms in parks,” Graber wrote in her opinion.

The court applied the same logic to casinos, stadiums, amusement parks, zoos, museums, and libraries.

Parking Lots Not as Clear

Courts did not make a blanket ruling on parking lots. Judges considered how connected a parking lot was to a “sensitive place.” The courts said this could be upheld because gun owners are still allowed to store their guns in their cars.

“We easily conclude that the ban on firearms at some parking lots — parking garages under government buildings, fenced parking areas adjacent to nuclear power plants, student-only parking areas at schools, and so on — are permissible,” Graber wrote.

Businesses Don’t Have to Post Whether Guns are Allowed

The court was concerned about whether a business owner has to say a gun is allowed or not.

The court acknowledged that having to get consent to carry a gun puts another burden on permit holders.

But it also stated property owners have the right to ban guns on their property. What the court was concerned with was how gun owners found out about a ban. It ruled that permit holders still needed permission to carry weapons while on private property open to the public.

It ruled that California’s law requiring businesses to post on a sign that guns are allowed at a business was too stringent.

“We acknowledge that our primary holding — that a national tradition likely exists of prohibiting the carrying of firearms on private property without the owner’s oral or written consent — differs from the decision by the 2nd Circuit and some district courts,” Graber wrote.

The court ruled that categorical bans at hospitals, public events, and on public transit were unprecedented.

But the court left open the possibility for further litigation.

The court called the historical analysis favored by the U.S. Supreme Court supporting bans at museums but not hospitals and libraries but not banks “arbitrary.”

“The seemingly arbitrary nature of Second Amendment rulings undoubtedly will inspire further litigation as state and local jurisdictions attempt to legislate within constitutional bounds,” Graber wrote.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Virginia Giuffre, Voice in Epstein Sex Trafficking Scandal, Dies at 41

DON'T MISS

California Proposes Allowing Testing of Self-Driving Heavy-Duty Trucks

DON'T MISS

Higher Taxes on Millionaires? Trump Says He’s Open, but Many in His Party Are Not

DON'T MISS

Ex-US Rep. George Santos Sentenced to Over 7 Years in Prison for Fraud and Identity Theft

DON'T MISS

Selma Mayor Charged With Electioneering Violation on Election Day

DON'T MISS

Fresno Air Improves. Where Does It Rank in the US?

DON'T MISS

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

DON'T MISS

Stocks Rise With Tech-Related Shares, Notch Weekly Gains; Dollar Up

DON'T MISS

Conflicting US-China Talks Statements Add to Global Trade Confusion

DON'T MISS

Driving Near the Fresno Airport Next Week? Plan for Road Closures

UP NEXT

Tulare Man Sentenced to State Prison for DUI Crash That Injured Two Women

UP NEXT

Judge Partly Blocks Trump Order Seeking to Overhaul US Elections

UP NEXT

Trump Asks Supreme Court to Reinstate Transgender Military Ban, for Now

UP NEXT

California Judge Blocks Trump’s Bid to Cut Funds to ‘Sanctuary’ Cities

UP NEXT

Jury Finds NY Times Not Liable in Sarah Palin Defamation Case

UP NEXT

US Supreme Court Appears Likely to Uphold Obamacare’s Preventive Care Coverage Mandate

UP NEXT

Woman in Fresno Mansion Fraud Case Sentenced to Prison for Tax Evasion

UP NEXT

California Prisoner Indicted for Exploiting Child Victim While Incarcerated

UP NEXT

Fresno Woman, Tied to Fentanyl ‘M30 King,’ Sentenced to Federal Prison

UP NEXT

Tesla Settles Wrongful Death Lawsuit Claiming Sudden Acceleration in Ohio Crash

Edward Smith,
Multimedia Journalist
Edward Smith began reporting for GV Wire in May 2023. His reporting career began at Fresno City College, graduating with an associate degree in journalism. After leaving school he spent the next six years with The Business Journal, doing research for the publication as well as covering the restaurant industry. Soon after, he took on real estate and agriculture beats, winning multiple awards at the local, state and national level. You can contact Edward at 559-440-8372 or at Edward.Smith@gvwire.com.

Ex-US Rep. George Santos Sentenced to Over 7 Years in Prison for Fraud and Identity Theft

6 hours ago

Selma Mayor Charged With Electioneering Violation on Election Day

6 hours ago

Fresno Air Improves. Where Does It Rank in the US?

7 hours ago

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

7 hours ago

Stocks Rise With Tech-Related Shares, Notch Weekly Gains; Dollar Up

7 hours ago

Conflicting US-China Talks Statements Add to Global Trade Confusion

8 hours ago

Driving Near the Fresno Airport Next Week? Plan for Road Closures

8 hours ago

Misty Her: Push for Fresno Unified Turnaround Starts Now With ‘Boots on the Ground’

8 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest 17 in Domestic Violence Crackdown

8 hours ago

What’s Next for Fresno Smoke Shop Ordinance: Lawsuit, Veto, Override?

9 hours ago

Virginia Giuffre, Voice in Epstein Sex Trafficking Scandal, Dies at 41

Virginia Giuffre, a former victim of Jeffrey Epstein’s sex-trafficking ring who said she was “passed around like a platter of fruit” as a te...

2 hours ago

Virginia Roberts Giuffre speaks to reporters in New York on Aug. 27, 2019. Giuffre, a former victim of Jeffrey Epstein’s sex-trafficking ring who said she was “passed around like a platter of fruit” as a teenager to rich and powerful predators, including Prince Andrew of Britain, died on Friday at her farm in Western Australia. She was 41. (Jefferson Siegel/The New York Times)
2 hours ago

Virginia Giuffre, Voice in Epstein Sex Trafficking Scandal, Dies at 41

6 hours ago

California Proposes Allowing Testing of Self-Driving Heavy-Duty Trucks

6 hours ago

Higher Taxes on Millionaires? Trump Says He’s Open, but Many in His Party Are Not

6 hours ago

Ex-US Rep. George Santos Sentenced to Over 7 Years in Prison for Fraud and Identity Theft

Selma Mayor Scott Robertson (left) has been charged with misdemeanor electioneering for allegedly campaigning near voters at a polling place during the November 2024 election. (Facebook)
6 hours ago

Selma Mayor Charged With Electioneering Violation on Election Day

7 hours ago

Fresno Air Improves. Where Does It Rank in the US?

7 hours ago

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

7 hours ago

Stocks Rise With Tech-Related Shares, Notch Weekly Gains; Dollar Up

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend