Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

PBS and NPR Mount Last-Ditch Fight to Save Federal Funding

22 hours ago

Netanyahu Under Mounting Political Pressure After Party Quits

23 hours ago

Wall Street Opens Higher After Inflation, Bank Results

23 hours ago

Sick of Loud Ads on Netflix? A Proposed California Law Turns Down the Volume

2 days ago

Record Numbers of Americans Say Immigration Is Good for Country: Gallup Poll

2 days ago

In California Strawberry Fields, Immigration Raids Sow Fear

2 days ago

Newsom’s Office Attacks Stephen Miller, Calling Him a ‘Fascist Cuck’

2 days ago

Trump’s Spending Bill Will Likely Boost Costs for Insurers, Shrink Medicaid Coverage

2 days ago
Valley Children's Hopes Paying $400K to Settle a Lawsuit Will Make Another One Go Away
Edward Smith updated website photo 2024
By Edward Smith
Published 10 months ago on
September 9, 2024

A court-approved settlement involving Valley Children's could absolve the hospital from other labor claims, including a major class-action lawsuit regarding on-call pay. (GV Wire Composite/Paul Marshall)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

When one Valley Children’s nurse saw a $55 settlement check in the mail, he was confused. He knew about the lawsuit against the hospital for paying on-call wages far below California minimum wage, but the settlement description said nothing about on-call rates.

He didn’t know about a separate class-action lawsuit from 2021 regarding meal and rest period pay, Westfall v. Valley Children’s. The $400,000 settlement paid by the hospital — filed 11 days after the on-call lawsuit was filed — releases claims beyond the meal and rest period, including on-call rates.

That nurse did not want to be named, but for lead plaintiff Bonnie Ferreria, in her on-call lawsuit, the settlement payment covers less than an hour’s wages.

A timeline of events shows Valley Children’s attorneys knew about the class-action lawsuit for on-call wages before Westfall was decided, said Fresno attorney Brian Whelan, who represents Ferreria and other hospital workers in their on-call case.

Despite knowing that the case would destroy Whelan’s, it wasn’t until more than a month after the settlement agreement was decided that Whelan was informed how the Westfall case would affect his claimants.

“(The) Westfall release is overly broad, and it sweeps all these different claims that were not even envisioned or discussed in that case,” Whelan said Monday. “The Westfall case destroys the Ferreria case for less than pennies on the dollar, like fractions of a penny on the dollar.”

Valley Children’s denies allegations made in the Westfall lawsuit, said hospital chief communications officer Zara Arboleda.

“Although Valley Children’s Hospital strongly denies all allegations in the Westfall lawsuit, we’ve agreed to a settlement so we and our employees can focus on providing high-quality healthcare to our patients and our community, rather than on litigation,” Arboleda said. “The court has preliminarily approved the settlement. A duplicate lawsuit, known as the Ferreria matter, similarly is without merit. Its potential claims will be settled under the ‘Westfall’ resolution. Valley Children’s looks forward to putting these cases behind us.”

Ferreria Says She’s Owed $27,000

Despite blocking Ferreria’s claims, nowhere in the Westfall case does it address on-call wages, Whelan said.

Ferreria, in her statement to the court, said she only received between $5 and $8 an hour for being on call. Based on the number of on-call hours worked, she said the hospital owes her $27,832.

She said dozens of employees she’s spoken with are “frustrated” about the settlement. Whelan said many of the claimants did not know that the Westfall case about meals and rest periods affected Ferreria’s, lawsuit about on-call rates. Now, the window for employees to object to the settlement is fast closing, ending on Sept. 30.

“People are frustrated and upset that VCH is trying to reduce their claims to less than a single hour of their base pay when they are owed significantly more,” Ferreria said in her declaration.

VCH Attorneys Asked Whelan for Ferreria Case Documents

When Whelan’s lawsuit was filed June 6, it made major news. GV Wire’s story came out June 12. That same day, attorney Daniel McQueen representing Valley Children’s Hospital contacted Whelan for a copy of his lawsuit, Whelan told GV Wire.

The settlement in Westfall was filed six days later, June 18. It was preliminarily approved on July 16.

Whelan said he was never notified by Valley Children’s attorneys about the lawsuit. He wouldn’t find out about the Westfall case until his client received the preliminary terms in the mail on Aug. 25. It was then that he found out that employees only had until Sept. 30 to object to the settlement terms.

McQueen and Valley Children’s other attorney, Ian Wieland, did not respond to emails from GV Wire. Attorneys for plaintiff Briana Westfall did not respond to emails from GV Wire, either.

“At no point did Mr. McQueen or anyone with VCH or any of their many defense attorneys provide any information about this Westfall case,” Whelan said in his declaration. “VCH and its counsel knew and know about the differences in claims between this Westfall case and Ferreria action. Indeed, in June 2024 VCH, through its authorized spokespeople, commented to multiple press outlets on the Ferreria Action.”

Employees Have Short Window to Object: Whelan

Once he found out about the Westfall case in June, Whelan reached out to attorneys representing Westfall, as well as the claims administrator, to find out how the settlement might affect his case.

Despite being told they would get him the documents that day, those documents never came, Whelan said.

Whelan said Wieland contacted him Sept. 3, but told him because of attorney-client privilege, he could not discuss or send out settlement terms earlier. Whelan said that he contacted Westfall’s attorneys asking for documents. He didn’t get them until he filed his motion.

In the settlement, attorneys for Westfall will receive no more than $133,333, according to court documents. Reimbursement for costs and expenses will not exceed $25,000.

Being a case about meals and rest periods, the Westfall case includes a broader class of employees than the Ferreria case. Whelan’s case involves non-exempt employees who work on-call shifts. Whelan estimates that the claimants should be awarded $25,000 each.

Whelan called the settlement terms “unfair” for employees.

“Bonnie Ferreria, she’s owed at least $28,000 or something like that,” Whelan told GV Wire. “So, in this Westfall case, they proposed to pay her $54. So if she were to accept $54 or if she doesn’t object or opt out timely, then her claims are all wiped out, it’s the same for everybody else.”

Whelan said employees objecting to the settlement have until Sept. 30 to file their response, either by contacting the claim administrator or Whelan’s office.

Fresno Wage Theft Investigation Continues

Shortly after Whelan’s lawsuit was filed, the Fresno City Attorney’s office launched an investigation into potential violations by the hospital. The hospital has some operations within the city.

City Attorney Andrew Janz said when it comes to wage theft allegations, the preference is always to have the employees and employers come to a mutual agreement.

“Unfortunately, this office cannot support the proposed settlement as it stands,” Janz said. “For that reason, our investigation into these claims will remain open.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Open Mic Contest Offers Fans a Chance to Perform at Outside Lands 2025

DON'T MISS

So Your Doctor Is a DO. Does That Matter?

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Found Dead After Hike Near Courtright Reservoir

DON'T MISS

Former US Army Soldier Pleads Guilty in Phone Company Hacking, Extortion Case

DON'T MISS

Fresno City Attorney Briefly Ineligible to Practice Law, Cites State Bar Error

DON'T MISS

Grass Fire East of Sanger Contained at 21 Acres, CalFire Says

DON'T MISS

Age Is Just a Number: 80-Year-Old Conquers Death Valley to Mt. Whitney Ultramarathon

DON'T MISS

What to Know About the Epstein Files, a Perfect Recipe for Conspiracy Theories

DON'T MISS

US Military to Remove 2,000 National Guard Troops From Los Angeles

DON'T MISS

Mexico Pledges Action Should US Talks Fail by August Tariff Deadline

UP NEXT

So Your Doctor Is a DO. Does That Matter?

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Found Dead After Hike Near Courtright Reservoir

UP NEXT

Former US Army Soldier Pleads Guilty in Phone Company Hacking, Extortion Case

UP NEXT

Fresno City Attorney Briefly Ineligible to Practice Law, Cites State Bar Error

UP NEXT

Grass Fire East of Sanger Contained at 21 Acres, CalFire Says

UP NEXT

Age Is Just a Number: 80-Year-Old Conquers Death Valley to Mt. Whitney Ultramarathon

UP NEXT

What to Know About the Epstein Files, a Perfect Recipe for Conspiracy Theories

UP NEXT

US Military to Remove 2,000 National Guard Troops From Los Angeles

UP NEXT

Mexico Pledges Action Should US Talks Fail by August Tariff Deadline

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Arrest Armed Man Found Asleep in Car

Edward Smith,
Multimedia Journalist
Edward Smith began reporting for GV Wire in May 2023. His reporting career began at Fresno City College, graduating with an associate degree in journalism. After leaving school he spent the next six years with The Business Journal, doing research for the publication as well as covering the restaurant industry. Soon after, he took on real estate and agriculture beats, winning multiple awards at the local, state and national level. You can contact Edward at 559-440-8372 or at Edward.Smith@gvwire.com.

Former US Army Soldier Pleads Guilty in Phone Company Hacking, Extortion Case

15 hours ago

Fresno City Attorney Briefly Ineligible to Practice Law, Cites State Bar Error

15 hours ago

Grass Fire East of Sanger Contained at 21 Acres, CalFire Says

15 hours ago

Age Is Just a Number: 80-Year-Old Conquers Death Valley to Mt. Whitney Ultramarathon

15 hours ago

What to Know About the Epstein Files, a Perfect Recipe for Conspiracy Theories

15 hours ago

US Military to Remove 2,000 National Guard Troops From Los Angeles

15 hours ago

Mexico Pledges Action Should US Talks Fail by August Tariff Deadline

15 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Armed Man Found Asleep in Car

16 hours ago

Trump Says Democratic Rival Schiff Should Be ‘Brought to Justice’ for Alleged Fraud

17 hours ago

Madera County Authorities Seeks Help Finding Missing Bass Lake Man

17 hours ago

Open Mic Contest Offers Fans a Chance to Perform at Outside Lands 2025

For the first time in its 17-year history, Outside Lands is inviting fans to take the stage. The 2025 edition of the iconic Golden Gate Park...

47 minutes ago

Outside Lands 2025 will debut its first-ever open mic contest, offering fans the opportunity to perform on the new Duboce Triangle stage. Pictured: Chappell Roan performing at Outside Lands 2024. (Alive Coverage/Outside Lands)
47 minutes ago

Open Mic Contest Offers Fans a Chance to Perform at Outside Lands 2025

The number of osteopathic doctors has increased dramatically. People still don’t know what they are. (Sonia Pulido/The New York Times)
13 hours ago

So Your Doctor Is a DO. Does That Matter?

14 hours ago

Fresno Man Found Dead After Hike Near Courtright Reservoir

A hooded man holds a laptop computer as cyber code is projected on him in this illustration picture taken on May 13, 2017. (Reuters File)
15 hours ago

Former US Army Soldier Pleads Guilty in Phone Company Hacking, Extortion Case

15 hours ago

Fresno City Attorney Briefly Ineligible to Practice Law, Cites State Bar Error

A grass fire east of Sanger burned 21 acres Tuesday, July 15, 2025, afternoon before being contained, CalFire said. (CalFire)
15 hours ago

Grass Fire East of Sanger Contained at 21 Acres, CalFire Says

15 hours ago

Age Is Just a Number: 80-Year-Old Conquers Death Valley to Mt. Whitney Ultramarathon

Jack Posobiec, a far-right political activist, carries a binder labeled “The Epstein Files: Phase 1” as he exits the White House in Washington, Feb. 27, 2025. Here’s what to know about the disturbing facts and unsubstantiated suspicions that make Jeffrey Epstein, a registered sex offender, a politically potent obsession. (Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times)
15 hours ago

What to Know About the Epstein Files, a Perfect Recipe for Conspiracy Theories

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend