Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
CA's Perpetual Tax Reform Debate Resumes. Will Anything Change?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 3 months ago on
August 12, 2024

California grapples with the ongoing challenge of managing unpredictable tax revenues and budget reserves. (CalMatters/Miguel Gutierrez Jr.)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

For the last two decades, California’s governors and legislators — and lobbyists for countless groups with stakes in the state budget — have engaged in a running debate over ever-increasing volatility in tax revenues.

Dan Walters Profile Picture

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

As the revenue stream grew, personal income taxes became the dominant source. The state’s highest-income taxpayers generated half those taxes largely from profits on their investments, which can vary widely year to year.

Moreover, as revenues became less predictable the state’s spending became less flexible. For example, a 1988 ballot measure, Proposition 98, requires that about 40% of state revenues be spent on public schools and community colleges.

The Great Recession and Its Aftermath

When revenues plummeted during the Great Recession and the state faced historically large budget deficits, then-Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and legislative leaders created a commission to recommend solutions to revenue volatility.

The commission debated for months but was hopelessly divided over whether to overhaul the tax system to de-emphasize income taxes or increase budget reserves to cushion periodic decreases in revenues. Its report, favoring the former approach, was promptly filed away and largely forgotten.

A few years later, Schwarzenegger’s successor, Democrat Jerry Brown confronted the lingering deficits from the Great Recession’s sharp revenue declines. He covered the gaps with a temporary tax increase approved by voters in 2012, primarily income taxes on the wealthy, and proposed a “rainy day fund” to ease the impact of future revenue downturns.

The Rise of Budget Reserves

Voters approved that approach in 2014 and the reserve, along with other smaller reserve funds for specific purposes, amassed substantial balances, roughly $30 billion, during the ensuing half-decade.

Gov. Gavin Newsom used reserves a bit in 2020 to offset a revenue decline during the COVID-19 pandemic and, when facing a nearly $50 billion budget deficit this year, he and the Legislature turned to them again.

Initially Newsom proposed a $13.1 billion draw from reserves, but the final 2024-25 budget approved in June took just $5.1 billion from the rainy fund and envisions another $7.1 drawdown in 2025-26. It also largely drains two other reserves, including one for schools.

Debate Over Budget Reserves Intensifies

This year’s deficit resulted from a massive overestimate of revenues by Newsom’s administration in 2022, rather than an economic turndown, and some critics have complained that misusing reserves this year could leave them unable to cope with a recession.

The wonkish debate over budgets, reserves and revenue volatility resumed this week during an Assembly Budget Committee hearing — specifically over whether the state needs a larger rainy day fund.

Newsom, whose 2022 projection of a huge budget surplus from explosive revenue gains proved to be incredibly wrong, now wants the state to avoid spending estimates of windfall revenues until they are actually in the bank — a prudence that should have been adopted many years ago.

However, his proposal and/or increasing rainy day reserves run afoul of groups that believe the state should be spending more on support for poor Californians rather than setting more money aside.

Scott Graves of the left-leaning California Budget & Policy Center warned legislators that “significantly raising the cap for the rainy day fund could tip the balance too far in the direction of saving, leaving less revenue to meet the immediate needs of Californians. This would make it harder to address poverty and inequality and to create an equitable California where everyone can share in the state’s prosperity.”

The hearing essentially sets the stage for a potential 2026 ballot measure to revise the state’s budget reserve, but it could also renew the revenue aspect of the perpetual debate, because in 2030 the latest extension of Jerry Brown’s 2012 income tax increase will expire.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times.

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Trump Says Musk, Vivek Will Form Outside Group to Advise White House on Government Efficiency

DON'T MISS

Fate of Clovis Trustee Race Still Up in the Air. So Are Clovis, Sanger School Bond Measures.

DON'T MISS

Richardson Widens Lead Over Bonakdar in Nail-Biting Race for Fresno City Council

DON'T MISS

What to Know About John Ratcliffe, Trump’s Pick for CIA Director

DON'T MISS

Here Are the People Trump Has Picked for Key Positions So Far

DON'T MISS

Waymo’s Robotaxis Now Open to Anyone Who Wants a Driverless Ride in Los Angeles

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Man Accused of Filing Fake Disability Claims in $300K Fraud Scheme

DON'T MISS

Trump Nominates Fox News Host Pete Hegseth for Defense Secretary

DON'T MISS

Economists Warn of Inflation and Debt Risks in Trump’s Second Term Plans

DON'T MISS

How Many Smoke Shops Is Too Many? Fresno Plan Would Allow Only 49

UP NEXT

If You Thought Trump Wasn’t Serious About Deportations, Look at His First Appointments

UP NEXT

Wall Street Slips as the Trump Trade Cools

UP NEXT

Stock Market Today: Most of Wall Street Rolls Higher as Bitcoin Bounces Above $84,000

UP NEXT

How Democrats Helped Trump

UP NEXT

Do Trump and Newsom Agree On Anything? Yes, Homeless Encampments

UP NEXT

Average Homebuyers Get Older. What’s Freezing Out Younger Fresno Families?

UP NEXT

Frustrated Americans Await the Economic Changes They Voted for With Trump

UP NEXT

Newsom Uses a Stunt to Position Himself as a Leader of Anti-Trump Resistance

UP NEXT

CA Legislature Sets Record for Women in Office and Could See Historic Gender Parity

UP NEXT

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Cruises Toward the Close of Its Best Week in a Year

What to Know About John Ratcliffe, Trump’s Pick for CIA Director

8 hours ago

Here Are the People Trump Has Picked for Key Positions So Far

8 hours ago

Waymo’s Robotaxis Now Open to Anyone Who Wants a Driverless Ride in Los Angeles

8 hours ago

Fresno County Man Accused of Filing Fake Disability Claims in $300K Fraud Scheme

8 hours ago

Trump Nominates Fox News Host Pete Hegseth for Defense Secretary

8 hours ago

Economists Warn of Inflation and Debt Risks in Trump’s Second Term Plans

8 hours ago

How Many Smoke Shops Is Too Many? Fresno Plan Would Allow Only 49

9 hours ago

US Says It Will Not Limit Israel Arms Transfers After Some Improvements in Flow of Aid to Gaza

9 hours ago

Who With Valley Ties Could Land Spots in the Trump Administration?

10 hours ago

Tulare Gang Member Gets Life Without Parole for 2022 Murders

11 hours ago

Trump Says Musk, Vivek Will Form Outside Group to Advise White House on Government Efficiency

WASHINGTON — President-elect Donald Trump on Tuesday said Elon Musk and former GOP presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy will lead a new “D...

7 hours ago

7 hours ago

Trump Says Musk, Vivek Will Form Outside Group to Advise White House on Government Efficiency

7 hours ago

Fate of Clovis Trustee Race Still Up in the Air. So Are Clovis, Sanger School Bond Measures.

7 hours ago

Richardson Widens Lead Over Bonakdar in Nail-Biting Race for Fresno City Council

8 hours ago

What to Know About John Ratcliffe, Trump’s Pick for CIA Director

8 hours ago

Here Are the People Trump Has Picked for Key Positions So Far

8 hours ago

Waymo’s Robotaxis Now Open to Anyone Who Wants a Driverless Ride in Los Angeles

A Fresno County man has been indicted on mail fraud charges for allegedly submitting over $300,000 in falsified disability claims using stolen identities. (GV Wire File)
8 hours ago

Fresno County Man Accused of Filing Fake Disability Claims in $300K Fraud Scheme

Pete Hegseth walks to an elevator for a meeting with President-elect Donald Trump at Trump Tower in New York, Dec. 15, 2016. (AP File)
8 hours ago

Trump Nominates Fox News Host Pete Hegseth for Defense Secretary

Search

Send this to a friend