Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Military Veteran Rios Challenging Costa for Congress in 2026

8 hours ago

OpenAI to Release Web Browser in Challenge to Google Chrome

8 hours ago

Fuel Shortage Threatens to Turn Gaza’s Biggest Hospital Into Graveyard, Doctors Say

8 hours ago

Why Measure C Is Not Measured

8 hours ago
Why Every California Student Should Have Access to 'Gifted' Classes
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 1 year ago on
June 24, 2024

In the Golden State, the 'gifted' label can be a double-edged sword, offering opportunities but also isolating students who would benefit from more diverse educational settings. (CalMatters/Lauren Justice)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Academic success is as much dependent on how students feel about themselves as the letter grades that fill their transcripts. In fact, the two might be more correlated than they appear.

Dan Walters Profile Picture
Thomas Stewart

CalMatters

Opinion

When I was in first grade, my parents applied for a local elementary school in Fresno that featured a so-called Gifted and Talented Education program. The school was nationally recognized and boasted impressive academic success rates, so who wouldn’t want to send their kid there?

After passing a test, I was admitted into the school. My family was so excited. I had gained access to take strategically accelerated courses taught by specially trained teachers.

The world was at my fingertips.

But now as a rising sophomore in college, I think about the consequences of applying a “gifted” label to California children. I eventually realized that students in the program rarely got the chance to interact with those outside of it. This separation endured throughout high school and was paired with the pressure of living up to the gifted label.

Studies have shown that gifted students have a higher risk of adverse mental health issues than the average student. On the other hand, students that participate in standard or remedial courses are more likely to remain stuck on that academic track — even if they are perfectly capable of performing at a higher level. It’s been proven that a student’s collegiate performance is proportional to the rigor of their high school curriculum, which means that underestimating a student can limit their potential.

The Psychological Impact on All Students

We are left with a lose-lose situation that has detrimental psychological effects on all students. Gifted students lack the opportunity to engage with more of their school community while standardized students are deprived of amazing educational opportunities. This social distinction endures throughout and after high school, leaving both groups feeling as though there is no place in which they can interact — as though they are inherently different.

We cherished the years I spent in the gifted program during elementary school, and I thrived with the knowledge that I had the potential to challenge myself academically. Being immersed in an enriched academic environment early on gave me the confidence and preparation to tackle advanced placement and honors courses in high school without a second thought.

By the time I reached high school I immediately felt at home, but it was largely because I was going to school with the same kids from elementary school. While this fostered a sense of community, I often felt restricted when it came to meeting students who weren’t taking advanced courses.

After years of gifted classes, I began to question just what this system was. A conversation with my high school principal later revealed that my high school didn’t actually feature any gifted courses.

Since these courses were not taught by teachers specially trained in the program’s methods, there was no meaningful difference between gifted courses and regular courses. Given how the state funds its public school system, California’s gifted program has become more of a label than an access point to advanced education.

The Need for Equal Access to Gifted Education

As I reflect on my experiences, I think of how my mother often credits my experience in the gifted program as the kickstarter to my success in secondary schooling and my overall development.

I couldn’t agree more. I believe that all children should have access to the resources of the gifted education program. This approach would eliminate the isolating effects of the current system, while providing “gifted” and “standard” students with different educational experiences that better fit their abilities.

Limiting either group is, and has been, a disservice. Through an equalized curriculum, we can initiate change and build a brighter, stronger future for California students.

About the Author

Thomas Stewart is a student at Columbia University and a Fresno native.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

UP NEXT

Fresno County Man Sentenced to 13 Years in Fiery DUI Crash That Killed One, Injured Several

Hiker Rescued by Helicopter After Injury on Pacific Crest Trail in Kern County

3 hours ago

US Military Delivering Some Weapons to Ukraine After Pause

3 hours ago

US Lawmakers Renew Concerns About GenScript’s Ties to China

The U.S. House of Representatives committee on China on Tuesday sent a letter to the directors of the FBI and national intelligence, renewin...

2 hours ago

U.S. and Chinese flags are seen in this illustration created on March 20, 2025. (Reuters File)
2 hours ago

US Lawmakers Renew Concerns About GenScript’s Ties to China

2 hours ago

Fresno County Man Sentenced to 13 Years in Fiery DUI Crash That Killed One, Injured Several

3 hours ago

‘Hollywood-Level Scares’ at Immersive Horror Attraction Coming to Fresno This Halloween

A hiker with an ankle injury was rescued by helicopter after becoming stranded on a steep slope along the Pacific Crest Trail near Rosamond, authorities said. (Kern County SO)
3 hours ago

Hiker Rescued by Helicopter After Injury on Pacific Crest Trail in Kern County

The Ukrainian and U.S. national flags fly outside a building, amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, in Kyiv, Ukraine, May 12, 2025. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

US Military Delivering Some Weapons to Ukraine After Pause

A Qantas plane is seen at a domestic terminal at Sydney Airport in Sydney, Australia, November 16, 2020. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

Qantas Confirms Personal Data of Over a Million Customers Leaked in Breach

UN Special Rapporteur for the occupied Palestinian territories, Francesca Albanese gives a press conference at the UN City in Copenhagen, Denmark February 5, 2025. (Reuters File)
4 hours ago

US Sanctions UN Expert Critical of Israel’s War in Gaza

A structure fire in Coarsegold has spread to nearby vegetation, prompting road closures and evacuation warnings for multiple zones in Madera County. (Madera County SO)
4 hours ago

Madera County Structure Fire Spreads to Vegetation in Coarsegold Area, Evacuations Ordered

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend