Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Charter School Battles Intensify as Education Finances Get Squeezed
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 3 weeks ago on
April 28, 2024

California public school financing has been clobbered in recent years, ramping up a long-running battle over charter schools. (CalMatters/Miguel Gutierrez Jr.)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

California’s public schools, with nearly 6 million students, are feeling the financial impacts of a quintuple whammy.

Dan Walters Profile Picture
Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Billions of federal dollars to cushion the impacts of COVID-19 have been exhausted, school closures during the pandemic magnified declines in enrollment, chronic absenteeism has worsened, inflation is increasing operating costs, and the state budget is plagued by a huge deficit.

Since the state largely finances schools based on their attendance, many local districts are seeing ever-widening gaps between income and outgo, stalling what had been a decade-long pattern of increasing per pupil spending.

Local school trustees have few options to balance their budgets. They can close schools with low enrollments, lay off teachers and other staff or ask voters to approve tax increases, usually what are called “parcel taxes” on homes and commercial property – all of which encounter resistance.

Budget Trick: Make It Tougher on Charter Schools

There is one other way for school officials to reduce their financial gaps: make it more difficult for charter schools to operate.

Charter schools also get their money from the state, but operate independently. For years, they have been engaged in a running battle with school unions, particularly those of teachers, which contend that they undermine regular public schools by siphoning away students and money.

As overall school finances are squeezed by the phalanx of interrelated issues, the battle over charter schools is becoming more intense. Earlier this year, after union-backed candidates achieved a majority on the board that governs the state’s largest school district, Los Angeles Unified, it cracked down on housing charter schools within traditional schools.

LA Unified now bars charters from sharing space in schools considered to be serving vulnerable students, affecting more than a third of LAUSD’s 850 campuses. Its immediate effect was to force about 21 charter schools to find new quarters.

This month, an even more direct assault on the charter school movement surfaced in the Legislature when the Senate Education Committee approved legislation, backed by the California School Boards Association and school unions, that would make it more difficult for new charter schools to gain approval.

Current law, enacted three decades ago, basically favors the creation of charter schools unless an affected school district can prove that it would be economically devastating or is already in receivership due to financial problems.

Bill Raises the Bar for Charter Approvals

Senate Bill 1380 would expand the ability of school districts to claim financial hardship as a reason for rejecting charter applications within their districts. It would also effectively repeal a current law allowing charters rejected by a district to seek approval by a county board of education.

The measure is being carried by Sen. Bill Dodd, a Napa Democrat, and stems in part from a local charter school conflict. But it would have statewide impacts, making it markedly more difficult for new charter schools to gain approval.

“When it comes to educating our children, locally elected school boards must decide how our precious resources are spent,” Dodd said in statement. “They must have the tools to recover from financial setbacks due to declining enrollment and focus their funds where they will have the greatest benefit.”

Charter schools opposed the bill during the Education Committee hearing, complaining that it would add even more restrictions on formation of new charters than those imposed in a 2019 bill also supported by unions.

Whatever the effect SB 1830 might have on the finances of local school districts, their fundamental problems of declining enrollment and attendance will continue.

The Public Policy Institute of California, in a recent report, says enrollment declines “are expected to continue, with the state projecting a decline of over a half million students by 2031–32 (while) federal projections suggest nearly a million.”

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Cohen Grilled Over Past Lies as Defense Targets Key Witness in Trump Hush Money Trial

DON'T MISS

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Edges Back From Records After Dow Briefly Tops 40,000

DON'T MISS

Two Bills Seek to Boost Valley’s Role in Solar Power. Which One Got Killed Today?

DON'T MISS

What Is Mayor’s Plan to Handle $47 Million Fresno Budget Deficit?

DON'T MISS

Bulldogs Fall to Air Force in Opener of Crucial Baseball Series at Air Force

DON'T MISS

Former Congressmember Cox Close to Plea Deal in Money Laundering Case

DON'T MISS

Palestinian Voices Echo Painful Gaza War History as Nakba is Remembered

DON'T MISS

California Teacher Who Says She Was Fired for Christian Beliefs Gets $360K

DON'T MISS

California Professor to Stand Trial for Death of Pro-Israel Protester

DON'T MISS

Texas Governor Pardons Ex-Army Sergeant Convicted of Killing BLM Protester

UP NEXT

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Edges Back From Records After Dow Briefly Tops 40,000

UP NEXT

Two Bills Seek to Boost Valley’s Role in Solar Power. Which One Got Killed Today?

UP NEXT

What Is Mayor’s Plan to Handle $47 Million Fresno Budget Deficit?

UP NEXT

Bulldogs Fall to Air Force in Opener of Crucial Baseball Series at Air Force

UP NEXT

Palestinian Voices Echo Painful Gaza War History as Nakba is Remembered

UP NEXT

California Teacher Who Says She Was Fired for Christian Beliefs Gets $360K

UP NEXT

California Professor to Stand Trial for Death of Pro-Israel Protester

UP NEXT

Texas Governor Pardons Ex-Army Sergeant Convicted of Killing BLM Protester

UP NEXT

Merced Councilmember Bertha Perez Faces Scrutiny for Alleged Threats, Inappropriate Conduct

UP NEXT

12 Bulldogs Earn All-Mountain West Honors in Track and Field

What Is Mayor’s Plan to Handle $47 Million Fresno Budget Deficit?

3 hours ago

Bulldogs Fall to Air Force in Opener of Crucial Baseball Series at Air Force

4 hours ago

Former Congressmember Cox Close to Plea Deal in Money Laundering Case

4 hours ago

Palestinian Voices Echo Painful Gaza War History as Nakba is Remembered

5 hours ago

California Teacher Who Says She Was Fired for Christian Beliefs Gets $360K

5 hours ago

California Professor to Stand Trial for Death of Pro-Israel Protester

5 hours ago

Texas Governor Pardons Ex-Army Sergeant Convicted of Killing BLM Protester

6 hours ago

Merced Councilmember Bertha Perez Faces Scrutiny for Alleged Threats, Inappropriate Conduct

7 hours ago

12 Bulldogs Earn All-Mountain West Honors in Track and Field

7 hours ago

LeBron James Shows up to Watch Son Bronny Play at NBA Draft Combine

7 hours ago

Cohen Grilled Over Past Lies as Defense Targets Key Witness in Trump Hush Money Trial

NEW YORK — Donald Trump’s lawyers accused the star prosecution witness in his hush money trial of lying to jurors, portraying Trump fi...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Cohen Grilled Over Past Lies as Defense Targets Key Witness in Trump Hush Money Trial

3 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Edges Back From Records After Dow Briefly Tops 40,000

3 hours ago

Two Bills Seek to Boost Valley’s Role in Solar Power. Which One Got Killed Today?

3 hours ago

What Is Mayor’s Plan to Handle $47 Million Fresno Budget Deficit?

4 hours ago

Bulldogs Fall to Air Force in Opener of Crucial Baseball Series at Air Force

4 hours ago

Former Congressmember Cox Close to Plea Deal in Money Laundering Case

5 hours ago

Palestinian Voices Echo Painful Gaza War History as Nakba is Remembered

5 hours ago

California Teacher Who Says She Was Fired for Christian Beliefs Gets $360K

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend