Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Supreme Court Seems Favorable to Biden Administration Over Efforts to Combat Social Media Posts
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 9 months ago on
March 18, 2024

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed likely Monday to side with the Biden administration in a dispute with Republican-led states over how far the federal government can go to combat controversial social media posts on topics including COVID-19 and election security.

The justices seemed broadly skeptical during nearly two hours of arguments that a lawyer for Louisiana, Missouri and other parties presented accusing officials in the Democratic administration of leaning on the social media platforms to unconstitutionally squelch conservative points of view.

Lower courts have sided with the states, but the Supreme Court blocked those rulings while it considers the issue.

Several justices said they were concerned that common interactions between government officials and the platforms could be affected by a ruling for the states.

Concerns Raised

In one example, Justice Amy Coney Barrett expressed surprise when Louisiana Solicitor General J. Benjamin Aguiñaga questioned whether the FBI could call Facebook and X (formerly Twitter) to encourage them to take down posts that maliciously released someone’s personal information without permission, the practice known as doxxing.

“Do you know how often the FBI makes those calls?” Barrett asked, suggesting they happen frequently.

Implications for Free Speech

The court’s decision in this and other social media cases could set standards for free speech in the digital age. The cases over state laws and the one that was argued Monday are variations on the same theme, complaints that the platforms are censoring conservative viewpoints.

The states argue that White House communications staffers, the surgeon general, the FBI and the U.S. cybersecurity agency are among those who coerced changes in online content on social media platforms.

“It’s a very, very threatening thing when the federal government uses the power and authority of the government to block people from exercising their freedom of speech,” Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill said in a video her office posted online.

Administration’s Response

The administration responds that none of the actions the states complain about come close to problematic coercion. The states “still have not identified any instance in which any government official sought to coerce a platform’s editorial decisions with a threat of adverse government action,” wrote Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar, the administration’s top Supreme Court lawyer. Prelogar wrote that states also can’t “point to any evidence that the government ever imposed any sanction when the platforms declined to moderate content the government had flagged — as routinely occurred.”

The companies themselves are not involved in the case.

Free Speech Advocates’ Views

Free speech advocates say the court should use the case to draw an appropriate line between the government’s acceptable use of the bully pulpit and coercive threats to free speech.

“The government has no authority to threaten platforms into censoring protected speech, but it must have the ability to participate in public discourse so that it can effectively govern and inform the public of its views,” Alex Abdo, litigation director of the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, said in a statement.

Previous Rulings

A panel of three judges on the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had ruled earlier that the Biden administration had probably brought unconstitutional pressure on the media platforms. The appellate panel said officials cannot attempt to “coerce or significantly encourage” changes in online content. The panel had previously narrowed a more sweeping order from a federal judge, who wanted to include even more government officials and prohibit mere encouragement of content changes.

A divided Supreme Court put the 5th Circuit ruling on hold in October, when it agreed to take up the case.

Justices Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas would have rejected the emergency appeal from the Biden administration.

Alito wrote in dissent in October: “At this time in the history of our country, what the Court has done, I fear, will be seen by some as giving the Government a green light to use heavy-handed tactics to skew the presentation of views on the medium that increasingly dominates the dissemination of news. That is most unfortunate.”

A decision in Murthy v. Missouri, 23-411, is expected by early summer.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Woman Accusing Jay-Z and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs of Sexual Assault Acknowledges Inconsistencies

DON'T MISS

Ukrainian Drones Strike Russia as Kyiv Reels From Consecutive Massive Air Attacks

DON'T MISS

South Korea’s Parliament Votes to Impeach President Yoon Suk Yeol Over His Martial Law Order

DON'T MISS

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

DON'T MISS

YouTube TV Is Hiking Its Monthly Price, Again. Here’s What to Know

DON'T MISS

City, County of Fresno Reach Tax Agreement. Can Building Move Forward?

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Release Video of Gun Battle That Killed Gang Member, Injured Sergeant

DON'T MISS

Fresno Trustees Inch Closer to Hiring a New Superintendent

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Will Take Up a Challenge Related to Tough CA Vehicle Emissions Standards

DON'T MISS

Why CA Needs to Double-Down on Its Apprenticeship Programs

UP NEXT

Fresno Council Changes Rules on Presidency, Vice Presidency

UP NEXT

Nancy Pelosi Hospitalized After She ‘Sustained an Injury’ on Official Trip to Luxembourg

UP NEXT

Kennedy’s Lawyer Has Asked the FDA to Revoke Approval of the Polio Vaccine

UP NEXT

Drones, Dogs, Drug Labs: Canada’s Plan to Avoid Trump’s Tariffs Takes Shape

UP NEXT

US Senator Says Mysterious Drones Spotted in New Jersey Should Be ‘Shot Down, if Necessary’

UP NEXT

IRS Recovers $4.7 Billion in Back Taxes and Braces for Cuts With Trump and GOP in Power

UP NEXT

Wired Wednesday: Holding up a Fresno Council Meeting to Host a Fundraiser

UP NEXT

Only About 2 in 10 Americans Approve of Biden’s Pardon of Son Hunter: AP-NORC Poll

UP NEXT

Head of the Federal Aviation Administration to Resign, Allowing Trump to Pick His Successor

UP NEXT

Trump Has a New Favorite Foreign Leader. He’s Known as ‘the Madman.’

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

5 hours ago

YouTube TV Is Hiking Its Monthly Price, Again. Here’s What to Know

8 hours ago

City, County of Fresno Reach Tax Agreement. Can Building Move Forward?

19 hours ago

Fresno Police Release Video of Gun Battle That Killed Gang Member, Injured Sergeant

20 hours ago

Fresno Trustees Inch Closer to Hiring a New Superintendent

22 hours ago

Supreme Court Will Take Up a Challenge Related to Tough CA Vehicle Emissions Standards

23 hours ago

Why CA Needs to Double-Down on Its Apprenticeship Programs

23 hours ago

Fresno Council Changes Rules on Presidency, Vice Presidency

23 hours ago

De’Vondre Campbell Won’t Be With 49ers After Refusing to Play: Shanahan

24 hours ago

Country Star Morgan Wallen Sentenced in Chair-Throwing Case

24 hours ago

Woman Accusing Jay-Z and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs of Sexual Assault Acknowledges Inconsistencies

A woman who accused rappers Jay-Z and Sean “Diddy” Combs of sexually assaulting her when she was 13 at an awards show after-part...

2 hours ago

2 hours ago

Woman Accusing Jay-Z and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs of Sexual Assault Acknowledges Inconsistencies

3 hours ago

Ukrainian Drones Strike Russia as Kyiv Reels From Consecutive Massive Air Attacks

4 hours ago

South Korea’s Parliament Votes to Impeach President Yoon Suk Yeol Over His Martial Law Order

This undated photo provided by UnitedHealth Group shows UnitedHealthcare chief executive officer Brian Thompson. (AP/UnitedHealth Group via AP)
5 hours ago

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

8 hours ago

YouTube TV Is Hiking Its Monthly Price, Again. Here’s What to Know

19 hours ago

City, County of Fresno Reach Tax Agreement. Can Building Move Forward?

20 hours ago

Fresno Police Release Video of Gun Battle That Killed Gang Member, Injured Sergeant

22 hours ago

Fresno Trustees Inch Closer to Hiring a New Superintendent

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend