Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
GV Wire Reporter's Firsthand Look Inside U.S. Supreme Court Brings Sense of Awe
gvw_david_taub
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 6 months ago on
October 17, 2023

Share

Watching the nine justices of the United States Supreme Court emerge from the back and take their seats on the bench can leave one in awe.

It is a sight that not everyone gets to see — by design. The highest court in the land, which heard its first case in 1791, has never allowed cameras in the court.

Even photos are rare. No one — from the parties, to observers, to the media — are allowed to carry in any type of device. That means no cameras, no recording devices of any type, and certainly no smart phones.

GV Wire had the opportunity to observe a case last week. Although Murray v. UBS Securities, LLC may not be the most important case the court hears, watching the proceedings live gave a unique and rare perspective.

Wonderful Visuals, Poor Audio

The courtroom seats approximately 300 people, including the parties involved, media and the public. Anyone can observe the cases during argument days. The line around the court started hours before the first case at 10 a.m.

The first four rows are reserved for the parties involved and other attorneys. The remaining seating is available for the public. Sometimes, the public are rotated in and out to increase the number of people who can watch.

The media also has designated rows on the side, with a convenient desktop area to take notes. Media are only allowed to bring in a pen and paper; and there is a dress code (suit coat and tie for men; business attire for women).

On the walls high up on each of the four sides are bas relief art pieces depicting various scenes. They seem to convey themes of “justice,” including a man holding a snake, another man holding a Hebrew scroll, and a knight with a sword.

The ceiling has ornate flower designs on red and blue backgrounds. The front and back of the court has four floor-to-ceiling marble columns, with eight on the sides.

The court also has floor-to-ceiling red drapes on each side, with gold fringe.

The justices sit in the front of the room, with Chief Justice John Roberts in the center. From the center out, justices are seated by seniority. To Roberts right is Justice Clarence Thomas; Samuel Alito to his left. At the ends are Amy Coney Barrett and Ketanji Brown Jackson.

There is also seating at the side of the bench for the Clerk of the Court and the Marshal of the Court.

Desks for the attorneys arguing the case are in the front of the room. Analogue wall clocks hang at the front and back of the rooms.

The only audio comes from two speakers set up in front of the bench. It can be difficult to hear at times. All the parties have a microphone. A cleaner version of the audio is later released through the Court website.

‘May it Please the Court’

The court session started promptly at 10 a.m. (everyone was requested to be seated a half-hour in advance). The clerk opened the day with the familiar phrase “oyez, oyez, oyez” — the traditional open calling court into session.

Before starting the Murray matter, Roberts swore in a series of attorneys, allowing them to be admitted to argue in front of the Supreme Court. After five minutes, Roberts called Murray v. UBS Securities, LLC.

Easha Ananda, a Stanford law professor and co-director of the Supreme Court Litigation Clinic, delivered the arguments on behalf of Murray.

“May it please the court,” she started, with only a two-minute opening argument. The remainder of approximate 45 minutes — shared with Anthony Yang, Solicitor General of the U.S. Dept. of Justice — was going back in forth with the justices.

This was Anand’s first time arguing in front of the Supreme Court. Attorney Bob Herbst, who won at the trial level, reached out to Anand’s Stanford colleagues to get involved.

“I stepped in during the reply brief to the petition for certiorari and then helped with the merits briefing. Bob and my client, Trevor Murray, entrusted me with the appeal, for which I’ll be forever grateful,” Anand told GV Wire.

Sometimes, Roberts would call on the justices to ask and answer questions. Other times, the justices would just jump in and offer questions of law, several “what if” scenarios, and even moments of frivolity.

A comment from Brett Kavanaugh seemed mundane, but still elicited laughter from the court. The court transcript noted four instances of “laughter.”

Eugene Scalia, a Washington-based attorney, representing UBS Securities, started his argument. If the name is familiar, it should be. Scalia is the son of late Justice Antonin Scalia.

This was also his first case argued at the Supreme Court.

“I’m grateful to have been given the privilege of arguing this important employment case, and of appearing before the Court that meant so much to my father,” Scalia said.

[Note: both Anand’s and Scalia’s comments came after this story first published.]

Murray v. UBS Among 80 Cases a Year

The United States Supreme Court says up to 8,000 cases are presented for an ultimate hearing, but few are granted. The Court hears about 80 cases a term. Some make front page news with major ramifications, such as abortion or gun rights.

Others, such as Murray v. UBS Securities, LLC are more mundane. Argued on Oct. 10, the court must decide how the Sarbanes-Oxley Act defines who is responsible for proving an employee was fired for being a whistleblower.

The technical question the court faces, from the SCOTUS website, is “Under the burden-shifting framework that governs Sarbanes-Oxley cases, must a whistleblower prove his employer acted with a ‘retaliatory intent’ as part of his case in chief, or is the lack of ‘retaliatory intent’ part of the affirmative defense on which the employer bears the burden of proof?”

According to court documents, Murray was a New York analyst for UBS, analyzing mortgage-backed securities.

“In the fall of 2011, applicant reported to his supervisor that he was being pressured by the leader of UBS’s trading desk to alter his analyses and to preclear those analyses with the trading desk. Shortly thereafter, despite having received a strongly positive review, he was fired,” court documents said.

Murray sued in federal court, and won his case. He was awarded nearly $1 million. UBS appealed, with the appeals court siding with the defendant on one aspect — Murray should have been required to prove UBS acted with retaliatory intent. Murray appealed to the Supreme Court, which granted the petition for certiorari — the request to be heard.

The attorneys and justices argued the finer points and technical definitions during the 90-minute hearing (audio here; transcript here).

“Trevor was brave enough to do the right thing and has been paying for it for over a decade. It was such an honor to stand up and represent him in Court, but it was also very scary — the stakes were so high, and the cause so righteous, that I wanted to make sure to do his story justice,” Anand, his attorney, said.

This case may not seemingly have broad effects on the national landscape. But, it is an important enough issue for the highest court in the land to decide.

In a preview of the case, Anne Marie Lofaso with the American Bar Association wrote, “this case presents yet another opportunity for the Court to engage in statutory interpretation.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Boeing’s Financial Woes Continue, While Families of Crash Victims Urge US to Prosecute

DON'T MISS

Police Tangle With Students in Texas and California as Wave of Campus Protest Against Gaza War Grows

DON'T MISS

Meet the Valley Republican Predicting a November Win Over Esmeralda Soria

DON'T MISS

Wired Wednesday: Construction Workers on 2018 Fresno Unified Project Still Not Paid

DON'T MISS

Slumping California Risks Losing World’s ‘5th Largest Economy’ Title

DON'T MISS

Ukraine Uses Long-Range Missiles Secretly Provided by US to Hit Russian-Held Areas, Officials Say

DON'T MISS

Upward Bound: Edison High’s Garcia Headed to Johns Hopkins

DON'T MISS

Boxing Star Ryan Garcia Wants to Meet Netanyahu, Pledges Aid for Gaza Children

DON'T MISS

Fong Won’t Debate Boudreaux, but We Get Hot Topic Answers Anyway

DON'T MISS

Legislation Pandering to Tribal Casinos Is a Bad Bet for Fresno Cardroom Employees

UP NEXT

Fong Won’t Debate Boudreaux, but We Get Hot Topic Answers Anyway

UP NEXT

Biden Signs a $95 Billion War Aid Measure With Assistance for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan

UP NEXT

Fresno County Appoints New Librarian. What’s Her Favorite Book Genre?

UP NEXT

Costa Seeks Legislation to Prevent Reedley Lab Repeat

UP NEXT

Legacy of Speed: The 1,600 Horsepower 1957 ‘Skeva’ Chevy Bel Air Built in Fresno

UP NEXT

KMJ’s Gabriel & Musson Win Radio Honors, Fresno Council Plaudits

UP NEXT

Fresno’s Baklava House Entices Foodies With Its Delicious Flavors

UP NEXT

Did Fresno Unified’s Biggest Contractor Not Pay Its Workers? Company Still Gets Millions After Civil Penalty

UP NEXT

Columbia Cancels In-Person Classes as Demonstrations Sprout on US Campuses to Protest Israel War

UP NEXT

Does Dyer Support (or Endorse) Bredefeld for Supervisor?

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Wired Wednesday: Construction Workers on 2018 Fresno Unified Project Still Not Paid

4 hours ago

Slumping California Risks Losing World’s ‘5th Largest Economy’ Title

4 hours ago

Ukraine Uses Long-Range Missiles Secretly Provided by US to Hit Russian-Held Areas, Officials Say

6 hours ago

Upward Bound: Edison High’s Garcia Headed to Johns Hopkins

Local Education /

7 hours ago

Boxing Star Ryan Garcia Wants to Meet Netanyahu, Pledges Aid for Gaza Children

7 hours ago

Fong Won’t Debate Boudreaux, but We Get Hot Topic Answers Anyway

8 hours ago

Legislation Pandering to Tribal Casinos Is a Bad Bet for Fresno Cardroom Employees

8 hours ago

About 1 in 4 US Adults Over 50 Say They Expect to Never Retire, an AARP Study Finds

9 hours ago

Biden Signs a $95 Billion War Aid Measure With Assistance for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan

9 hours ago

Ancestry Website to Catalogue Names of Japanese Americans Incarcerated During World War II

10 hours ago

Boeing’s Financial Woes Continue, While Families of Crash Victims Urge US to Prosecute

Boeing said Wednesday that it lost $355 million on falling revenue in the first quarter, another sign of the crisis gripping the aircraft ma...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Boeing’s Financial Woes Continue, While Families of Crash Victims Urge US to Prosecute

3 hours ago

Police Tangle With Students in Texas and California as Wave of Campus Protest Against Gaza War Grows

CA District 27 Assembly candidate Joanna Garcia Rose
3 hours ago

Meet the Valley Republican Predicting a November Win Over Esmeralda Soria

4 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: Construction Workers on 2018 Fresno Unified Project Still Not Paid

4 hours ago

Slumping California Risks Losing World’s ‘5th Largest Economy’ Title

6 hours ago

Ukraine Uses Long-Range Missiles Secretly Provided by US to Hit Russian-Held Areas, Officials Say

Local Education /
7 hours ago

Upward Bound: Edison High’s Garcia Headed to Johns Hopkins

7 hours ago

Boxing Star Ryan Garcia Wants to Meet Netanyahu, Pledges Aid for Gaza Children

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend