California’s Unemployment Fund is Underwater and It's a Huge Embarrassment

By admin

Published 1 year ago on

October 4, 2023

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Gov. Gavin Newsom describes himself as a “progressive” and has said his vision for California includes a highly unionized workforce.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

However, his relationship with the state’s public and private employee unions has been a rocky one. Sometimes he and union leaders sing from the same hymnal, but they occasionally are at odds, particularly when labor is feuding with corporate interests that Newsom is also cultivating.

That syndrome was displayed last weekend when he vetoed two of union leaders’ high priority measures, including one that would have given unemployment benefits to striking workers, but then chose a former union leader, Laphonza Butler, to fill a U.S. Senate seat that became vacant when Dianne Feinstein died.

The juxtaposition drew a sharp retort from Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, who resigned from the Legislature last year to become head of the California Labor Federation.

“Don’t get distracted,” Gonzalez Fletcher posted on X, formerly known as Twitter. “Gov. Newsom has vetoed three important labor bills, including labor’s collective highest priority bill – SB 799. We must continue to organize & fight & demand respect for all workers, especially those who are striking to fix an economy that has failed us.”

Newsom said that Senate Bill 799, the unemployment insurance bill, would have worsened the Unemployment Insurance Fund’s multibillion-dollar deficit, which developed when the state borrowed about $20 billion from the federal government to keep unemployment insurance benefits flowing during the first months of the COVID-19 pandemic.

“Now is not the time to increase costs or incur this sizable debt.” Newsom said in his veto message.

Competing Pressures on Labor Bills

Gonzalez Fletcher and other union leaders had pushed Newsom to approve SB 799 and the two other union-backed bills he has vetoed, one banning operation of trucks without human operators and another granting full employment protections to household workers. But he was also under pressure from business groups to reject them.

“We applaud Gov. Newsom for vetoing this misguided legislation,” Jim Wunderman, CEO of the Bay Area Council, said in a statement, adding, “We can’t keep saddling business with more and more costs and expect the state’s economy to flourish.”

Newsom’s veto of SB 799 does not end the battle. Gonzalez Fletcher pledged to put the bill on Newsom’s desk again, saying, “We will keep fighting until striking workers get the benefits they’ve earned.”

The clash also hardens a decades-long stalemate over the chaotic finances of the unemployment insurance system.

The state borrowed money from the federal government during the Great Recession because its Unemployment Insurance Fund, or UIF, had virtually no reserves. When the state didn’t repay the loan, the feds hiked payroll taxes on employers and it was finally retired in 2018.

Two years later, when Newsom ordered businesses to shut down during the pandemic, unemployment soared and once again the state borrowed about $20 billion to pay benefits, most of which is still owed.

California’s unemployment insurance program is running an operational deficit even during this period of relatively high employment and is the least solvent of any state unemployment fund. The UIF has been unable to build reserves because of a chronic political stalemate between unions and employers over benefits and the payroll taxes to pay for them.

It began when former Gov. Gray Davis and the Legislature drained what had been a healthy UIF reserve to sharply increase benefits, leaving it incapable of handling an economic downturn.

If another recession hit the state, it would almost certainly be forced to borrow even more money to maintain benefits, even though it still has heavy debt from the previous recession.

This political mismanagement of a system that protects millions of Californians from economic ruin is – or should be – a huge embarrassment.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration.

DON'T MISS

Senate Confirms Zeldin to Lead Environmental Protection Agency as Trump Vows to Cut Climate Rules

DON'T MISS

Clovis Is Rewarding Diners for Eating and Drinking Local

DON'T MISS

How Much Rain Will Fresno Get From Storms Slamming NorCal?

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Orders Take Aim at Critical Race Theory and Antisemitism on College Campuses

DON'T MISS

At Signing of Laken Riley Act, Trump Says He Plans to Send Migrants in US Illegally to Guantanamo

DON'T MISS

Authorities Seize $160K, 100 Pounds of Marijuana in Merced County Traffic Stop

DON'T MISS

Ex-New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez Sentenced to 11 Years in Prison for Bribery Conviction

DON'T MISS

Trump Set to Sign Order Deporting Pro-Palestinian Exchange Students

DON'T MISS

Tyrese Maxey Scores 43 to Lift 76ers Past LeBron, Lakers 118-104

DON'T MISS

Dennis Schroder Scores 23 Points as Warriors Beat Jazz 114-103

UP NEXT

Trump’s Orders Take Aim at Critical Race Theory and Antisemitism on College Campuses

UP NEXT

Ex-New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez Sentenced to 11 Years in Prison for Bribery Conviction

UP NEXT

RFK Jr. Struggles to Answer Questions on Medicare and Medicaid at Hearing

UP NEXT

Trump White House Rescinds Order Freezing Federal Grants After Widespread Confusion

UP NEXT

Trump Is Going Woke on Energy

UP NEXT

Fresno Councilmembers Want to End Sending of Homeless People to City

UP NEXT

Fresno Agencies Scramble for Clarity on Trump’s Ordered End to Federal Aid

UP NEXT

Trump Offers All Federal Workers a Buyout With 7 Months’ Pay

UP NEXT

Federal Judge Temporarily Blocks Trump Administration Freeze on Federal Grants and Loans

UP NEXT

4 hours ago

Senate Confirms Zeldin to Lead Environmental Protection Agency as Trump Vows to Cut Climate Rules

WASHINGTON — The Republican-controlled Senate on Wednesday confirmed Lee Zeldin to lead the Environmental Protection Agency, a key role to h...

Politics /

23 minutes ago

2 hours ago

Ex-New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez Sentenced to 11 Years in Prison for Bribery Conviction

Education /

3 hours ago

Trump Set to Sign Order Deporting Pro-Palestinian Exchange Students

MORE LATEST →

Politics /

22 hours ago

Fresno Councilmembers Want to End Sending of Homeless People to City

Video /

2 days ago

Migrants Left Stranded After Trump Cancels Asylum Claims at Border

Events /

4 days ago

Drone Delivery is Here: Zipline CEO Shares the Future of Product Transport

Crime /

6 days ago

Fresno County Sex Offender Arrested Fleeing on Motorcycle With Drugs

Poverty/Justice /

1 week ago

Clovis Is Rewarding Diners for Eating and Drinking Local

How Much Rain Will Fresno Get From Storms Slamming NorCal?

Judge Clears Former Fresno City College Coach Ed Madec in Threats Case

CSU Campuses Brace for Possible Cuts in Classes and Sports

Another Heartbreaking Mountain West Defeat for Fresno State

Pardoned Jan. 6 Rioter Wanted for Charges of Soliciting Minor

Live Horse Racing Out for 2025 Big Fresno Fair

Israel’s Prime Minister Says Trump Has Invited Him to the White House on Feb. 4

Trump Administration Halts HIV Drug Distribution in Poor Countries

Share

About the Author

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Senate Confirms Zeldin to Lead Environmental Protection Agency as Trump Vows to Cut Climate Rules

DON'T MISS

Clovis Is Rewarding Diners for Eating and Drinking Local

DON'T MISS

How Much Rain Will Fresno Get From Storms Slamming NorCal?

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Orders Take Aim at Critical Race Theory and Antisemitism on College Campuses

DON'T MISS

At Signing of Laken Riley Act, Trump Says He Plans to Send Migrants in US Illegally to Guantanamo

DON'T MISS

Authorities Seize $160K, 100 Pounds of Marijuana in Merced County Traffic Stop

DON'T MISS

Ex-New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez Sentenced to 11 Years in Prison for Bribery Conviction

DON'T MISS

Trump Set to Sign Order Deporting Pro-Palestinian Exchange Students

DON'T MISS

Tyrese Maxey Scores 43 to Lift 76ers Past LeBron, Lakers 118-104

DON'T MISS

Dennis Schroder Scores 23 Points as Warriors Beat Jazz 114-103

UP NEXT

Trump’s Orders Take Aim at Critical Race Theory and Antisemitism on College Campuses

UP NEXT

Ex-New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez Sentenced to 11 Years in Prison for Bribery Conviction

UP NEXT

RFK Jr. Struggles to Answer Questions on Medicare and Medicaid at Hearing

UP NEXT

Trump White House Rescinds Order Freezing Federal Grants After Widespread Confusion

UP NEXT

Trump Is Going Woke on Energy

UP NEXT

Fresno Councilmembers Want to End Sending of Homeless People to City

UP NEXT

Fresno Agencies Scramble for Clarity on Trump’s Ordered End to Federal Aid

UP NEXT

Trump Offers All Federal Workers a Buyout With 7 Months’ Pay

UP NEXT

Federal Judge Temporarily Blocks Trump Administration Freeze on Federal Grants and Loans

UP NEXT

Why CA Fire Response Could Make or Break These Political Careers

Trump’s Orders Take Aim at Critical Race Theory and Antisemitism on College Campuses

2 hours ago

At Signing of Laken Riley Act, Trump Says He Plans to Send Migrants in US Illegally to Guantanamo

2 hours ago

Authorities Seize $160K, 100 Pounds of Marijuana in Merced County Traffic Stop

2 hours ago

Ex-New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez Sentenced to 11 Years in Prison for Bribery Conviction

2 hours ago

Trump Set to Sign Order Deporting Pro-Palestinian Exchange Students

3 hours ago

Tyrese Maxey Scores 43 to Lift 76ers Past LeBron, Lakers 118-104

4 hours ago

Dennis Schroder Scores 23 Points as Warriors Beat Jazz 114-103

4 hours ago

Hamas Will Free 3 Israelis and 5 Thais in Next Hostage Release Thursday

4 hours ago

Study Says Climate Change Made Conditions That Fed California Wildfires More Likely, More Intense

4 hours ago

Tax Season Has Begun. Here’s When You’ll Get Your Refund

4 hours ago

23 minutes ago

Categories

Senate Confirms Zeldin to Lead Environmental Protection Agency as Trump Vows to Cut Climate Rules

Clovis Is Rewarding Diners for Eating and Drinking Local

How Much Rain Will Fresno Get From Storms Slamming NorCal?

Trump’s Orders Take Aim at Critical Race Theory and Antisemitism on College Campuses

At Signing of Laken Riley Act, Trump Says He Plans to Send Migrants in US Illegally to Guantanamo

Authorities Seize $160K, 100 Pounds of Marijuana in Merced County Traffic Stop