Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Suspect Identified in Ambush Shooting That Killed 2 Idaho Firefighters

11 hours ago

Will Valadao Spoil Trump’s Plan for July 4th ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ Signing?

12 hours ago

Shaver Lake and Reedley 4th of July Shows Are Wednesday. Who Else Is Celebrating?

16 hours ago

Elon Musk Says Senate Bill Would Destroy Jobs and Harm US

16 hours ago

Israel Strikes Pound Gaza, Killing 60, Ahead of US Talks on Ceasefire

17 hours ago

Trump’s Administration Finds Harvard Violated Students’ Civil Rights, WSJ Reports

17 hours ago

How Did the Supreme Court Rule? Here’s a Look at the Big Cases

3 days ago
North Fresno Sewer District Blames City for Rate Hike Proposal
By admin
Published 2 years ago on
September 6, 2023

Share

A dispute between the city of Fresno and a small north Fresno utilities district could cost ratepayers.

A 15-year-old lawsuit, initiated and won by the city, has the Pinedale County Water District on the hook for nearly $300,000 in attorney’s fees. The district says it does not have the money and will have to raise sewer fees by 5% to satisfy the judgment against them.

“The District regrets being required to increase fees for sewer service, but it has been forced do so by the actions of the City of Fresno,” the notice sent by the district to its customers said. It encourages customers to direct any complaints “about the unnecessary surcharge” to Mayor Jerry Dyer, and councilmen Garry Bredefeld and Mike Karbassi.

PCWD attorney Neal Costanzo says the city, through its outside counsel James Betts, is now trying to enforce payment.

Constanzo said the city should forgive the debt.

“Absolutely. It’s the right thing for them to do,” Costanzo said.

The small utility district provides water and sewer services to nearly 3,500 residents and businesses in north Fresno in a 2-square-mile area generally around Herndon and Maroa avenues. The district is separate from the city of Fresno. The five-member PCWD board of directors is elected by the public.

Sewer rates would increase by $1.43 — from $25.75 to $27.18. District customers have until Oct. 17 to submit opposition to the increase, known as a Proposition 218 protest. Rates have not increased since 2010. Water rates are also in the process of increasing, PCWD general manager Jason Franklin said.

(GV Wire/Paul Marshall)

District Sends Letter to Dyer

PCWD board president David Rodriguez sent Mayor Jerry Dyer a letter on Nov. 3, 2022, asking the city to forgive the debt.

“If ‘One Fresno’ is to be more than a campaign slogan, you as Mayor, or the City Council, need to direct the filing of a full and complete satisfaction of this judgment immediately. Otherwise, your residents will be paying inflated fees for sewer charges for the next ten years,” Rodriguez wrote.”

The initial 2008 lawsuit was never filed at the direction of the city council, Rodriguez wrote.

Rodriguez wrote that the district would pass on the costs to satisfy the judgment to its ratepayers “rather than bankrupt itself.”

Constanzo said Dyer never replied to the letter.

“I don’t even know Jerry Dyer opens his own mail. I’m sure he does not. Which is fine. But, you know, we’re just kind of disappointed that we made these overtures and were ignored,” Costanzo said.

Dyer deferred comments to his city manager, Georgeanne White. She said she could not comment because of pending litigation.

(GV Wire/Paul Marshall)

Why Can’t Pinedale Pay?

Why can’t Pinedale pay the city? Costanzo said the district has other priorities, namely building a well. The well is needed to satisfy city water pressure requirements.

“It’s a matter of using the money they have and what they need to do at this point in time,” Costanzo said. “We are under a lot of pressure to drill that well, which is about a $1.5 million project.”

Insurance, Costanzo said, would not cover the debt owed to the city.

2008 Lawsuit and Attorney Fees

The controversy started in 2008 when the city sued PCWD over a contract regarding the use of the city’s sewage treatment plant. Specifically, the city wanted to conduct an audit, as allowed in the contract. Court records show the audit decision came from then-interim city controller/finance director Karen Bradley, with approval from the city manager, Andy Souza.

The district balked.

Because the person they serve to conduct the audits insisted on connecting to our computers and downloading everything,” Costanzo said.

The case was moved from Fresno County Superior Court to Madera County — a procedural move to allow for neutrality when two government agencies in the same county engage in litigation.

The judge ruled in the city’s favor, and after a failed appeal, finalized an award to the city in 2015 of more than $127,000 in attorney’s fees.

Meetings With City Officials

With a court victory in hand, the city never bothered to conduct the audit, the district said.

“They’ve filed the suit for an audit to compel an audit that they never wanted,” Costanzo, the PCWD attorney said.

Court records show the district met with city officials in 2015, including then-City Councilman Steve Brandau. Brandau had no knowledge of the city’s litigation, which predated his time on the council.

Speaking with GV Wire, Brandau — now a Fresno County supervisor representing the Pinedale area — still does not have much recall about the meetings with PCWD officials. He said the situation is “unfortunate.”

“It’s really not about some needed infrastructure. It’s about paying some attorney’s fees. So that sucks. But I think that they are probably going to have to raise those funds,” Brandau said.

In those 2015 meetings, then-City Manager Bruce Rudd and then-Public Utilities Director Thomas Esqueda allegedly told the district they didn’t plan to conduct the audit, PCWD district officials said.

The district believed city officials also agreed to “renounce” the accrued legal fees, although there is no written record backing that claim. PCWD board president Rodriguez also claimed that city officials told him they would ask the city council to not pursue the debt.

The district offered to settle the dispute for $40,000. The city council met in closed session on June 8, 2017, but did not take action.

The city filed litigation in 2017, demanding payment. PCWD tried to block the move — with the main argument that the PCWD-City contract dating back to 1976 was illegal from the start — with the case being heard in Kings County. The judge ruled in the city’s favor and tacked on $92,000 in attorney’s fees.

With interest, PCWD’s debt to the city could balloon to $300,000.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Clovis Police Seek Public’s Help in Finding Missing 82-Year-Old Woman

DON'T MISS

Fresno Woman Killed in Head-On Collision, CHP Investigating

DON'T MISS

Musk Vows to Punish Lawmakers Who Back Trump’s Spending Bill

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Sentenced to Nearly 6 Years for $4.2 Million Tech Startup Fraud

DON'T MISS

Bryan Kohberger Pleads Guilty in Murders of Four Idaho Students, ABC News Reports

DON'T MISS

Wildfire Near Lake Madera Country Estates Burns 12 Acres, Now 100% Contained

DON'T MISS

Fresno County CHP Arrest Two in Interstate 5 Drug, Gun, and Counterfeit Money Bust

DON'T MISS

California Seizes Over 600,000 Pounds of Illegal Fireworks. Newsom Calls for Safe Celebrations

DON'T MISS

Where Trade Talks Stand With Major US Partners Ahead of Tariffs-Hike Deadline

DON'T MISS

Labor Icon Huerta Breaks Ground on Fresno Park Bearing Her Name

UP NEXT

Fresno Woman Killed in Head-On Collision, CHP Investigating

UP NEXT

Musk Vows to Punish Lawmakers Who Back Trump’s Spending Bill

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Sentenced to Nearly 6 Years for $4.2 Million Tech Startup Fraud

UP NEXT

Wildfire Near Lake Madera Country Estates Burns 12 Acres, Now 100% Contained

UP NEXT

Where Trade Talks Stand With Major US Partners Ahead of Tariffs-Hike Deadline

UP NEXT

Labor Icon Huerta Breaks Ground on Fresno Park Bearing Her Name

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Arrested in Clovis for Sex-Related Crimes Against Minor

UP NEXT

Dyer’s Lobbying Works. Fresno Gets $100M for Downtown From State

UP NEXT

Suspect Identified in Ambush Shooting That Killed 2 Idaho Firefighters

UP NEXT

Fresno Fire Destroys Home Under Construction, Displaces Six

Fresno Man Sentenced to Nearly 6 Years for $4.2 Million Tech Startup Fraud

9 hours ago

Bryan Kohberger Pleads Guilty in Murders of Four Idaho Students, ABC News Reports

9 hours ago

Wildfire Near Lake Madera Country Estates Burns 12 Acres, Now 100% Contained

10 hours ago

Fresno County CHP Arrest Two in Interstate 5 Drug, Gun, and Counterfeit Money Bust

10 hours ago

California Seizes Over 600,000 Pounds of Illegal Fireworks. Newsom Calls for Safe Celebrations

10 hours ago

Where Trade Talks Stand With Major US Partners Ahead of Tariffs-Hike Deadline

10 hours ago

Labor Icon Huerta Breaks Ground on Fresno Park Bearing Her Name

10 hours ago

DOJ Announces Arrest, Indictments in North Korean IT Worker Scheme

10 hours ago

Fresno Man Arrested in Clovis for Sex-Related Crimes Against Minor

11 hours ago

Dyer’s Lobbying Works. Fresno Gets $100M for Downtown From State

11 hours ago

Clovis Police Seek Public’s Help in Finding Missing 82-Year-Old Woman

The Clovis Police Department is asking for the public’s help in locating an at-risk missing adult last seen on Thursday. Pathmani Goonawarde...

8 hours ago

Clovis Police are searching for Pathmani Goonawardena, 82, who went missing nearly three weeks ago and was last seen driving a white Volvo near Copper and Auberry, possibly en route to Coarsegold. (CHP)
8 hours ago

Clovis Police Seek Public’s Help in Finding Missing 82-Year-Old Woman

fresno
8 hours ago

Fresno Woman Killed in Head-On Collision, CHP Investigating

President Donald Trump and Elon Musk attend a press conference in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 30, 2025. (Reuters File)
9 hours ago

Musk Vows to Punish Lawmakers Who Back Trump’s Spending Bill

9 hours ago

Fresno Man Sentenced to Nearly 6 Years for $4.2 Million Tech Startup Fraud

Bryan Koberger, who is accused of killing four University of Idaho students, listens during a hearing to overturn his grand jury indictment in Moscow, Idaho, U.S., October 26, 2023. (Reuters File)
9 hours ago

Bryan Kohberger Pleads Guilty in Murders of Four Idaho Students, ABC News Reports

The Blanca Fire, burning 12 acres northwest of Lake Madera Country Estates in Madera County, remains active with 0% containment and no reported injuries or structural damage as the cause is under investigation as of Monday, June 30, 2025. (CalFire)
10 hours ago

Wildfire Near Lake Madera Country Estates Burns 12 Acres, Now 100% Contained

Fresno County CHP arrested two on Interstate 5 after finding about one kilogram of suspected cocaine, a loaded ghost gun, and counterfeit money during a vehicle search on Sunday, June 29, 2025. (CHP)
10 hours ago

Fresno County CHP Arrest Two in Interstate 5 Drug, Gun, and Counterfeit Money Bust

Gov. Newsom warns Californians to celebrate the Fourth of July safely, emphasizing zero tolerance for illegal fireworks which have surged to over 600,000 pounds seized this year. (Shutterstock)
10 hours ago

California Seizes Over 600,000 Pounds of Illegal Fireworks. Newsom Calls for Safe Celebrations

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend