Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Newsom Was Quick to Intervene on Banned Textbooks, but Not School Closures
By admin
Published 11 months ago on
August 7, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

When a right-leaning school board in Southern California balked at providing state-approved social studies textbooks that referenced murdered gay rights leader Harvey Milk, Gov. Gavin Newsom quickly intervened.

Dan Walters with a serious expression

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Newsom declared the board to be “radicalized zealots” and said, “If the school board won’t do its job by its next board meeting to ensure kids start the school year with basic materials, the state will deliver the book into the hands of children and their parents – and we’ll send the district the bill and fine them for violating state law.”

Newsom’s threats worked as the Temecula school board backed down. However, his lightning-fast crackdown on Temecula sharply contrasts with what happened three years ago on a much more important clash – whether to reopen schools shuttered due to COVID-19.

Newsom had assumed vast emergency powers to manage the pandemic, and closing schools that serve nearly 6 million students was one of the state’s earliest and most dramatic actions.

It soon became apparent, however, that the schools were not a likely venue for spreading the disease . Within months, federal health officials, parents and children’s advocates were urging that classrooms be reopened to avoid educational deterioration.

Other states reopened schools, as did many California private schools, including the one serving Newsom’s children. But California’s teacher unions balked, forcing local school officials to leave schools closed and children to cope with makeshift internet classes.

Newsom backed reopening. “I am of the firm belief that we can safely get back our children, youngest children, get them back safely into schools in small cohorts,” Newsom told reporters in early 2021. “We can get this done. We must get it done.”

Newsom Unwilling to Confront Unions

Even though Newsom offered school districts billions of dollars to reopen, schools remained largely shuttered because of continued union opposition. Newsom, who had been so quick to take unilateral actions on other pandemic-related issues and who later cracked down on Temecula, refused to forcefully intervene, apparently unwilling to confront the politically powerful unions.

Eventually schools did reopen, but by then the damage was done. Follow-up studies revealed that closures had seriously damaged educational achievement in a state whose children were already trailing those in other states.

When state academic testing resumed in 2022 after being suspended during the pandemic, it showed “significant declines in proficiency rates,” a study by the Public Policy Institute of California declared.

Prior to the pandemic, 51% of students met standards in English language arts (ELA) and it had dropped to 47%. In mathematics, proficiency declined from 40% to 33%.

“Only 35% of low-income students met state standards in ELA and 21% were proficient in math,” PPIC reported, “compared to 65% of higher-income students in ELA and 51% in math.”

While schools were closed in 2020, a civil rights lawsuit was filed against the state, alleging that closures had an inordinate effect on low-income children of color – something that PPIC and other independent researchers later confirmed.

The state is trying to get the suit tossed, contending that closures did not have the harmful effects it alleges. The suit’s advocates, however, have countered with statements from a variety of educational authorities buttressing its case.

The state Department of Education has a response to that as well. EdSource, a website devoted to California educational issues, reported recently that the department has warned educational researchers who access its data that they cannot help plaintiffs because a clause in research agreements forbids participation in any suit against the state.

In other words, the state is muzzling those who could provide expert testimony that the state’s failure to reopen schools was an educational disaster. That’s authoritarian arrogance to the 10th power.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Watch: Saudi Crown Prince Demands Netanyahu Face Criminal Charges for Gaza

DON'T MISS

Mehdi Hasan Debates Zionism in Heated Live Event

DON'T MISS

Happ, Swanson Homers as Chicago Cubs Battle SF Giants

DON'T MISS

Luxury Portable Bathrooms? Fresno Co. Lets You to Do Your Business in Opulence

DON'T MISS

Tropical Storm Alberto Forms in Southwest Gulf, 1st Named Storm of the Hurricane Season

DON'T MISS

Images Reveal Extensive Destruction in Lebanese Villages

DON'T MISS

Rifts Seem to Appear Between Israel’s Political and Military Leadership Over Conduct of the Gaza War

DON'T MISS

Anarchy Hinders Gaza Aid Efforts, Despite Daily Combat Pause

DON'T MISS

Trump Tries to Set Expectations, and Floats Excuses, for His Debate With Biden

DON'T MISS

Parlier Political Wars Update: Did the Council Fire the City Attorney, or Not?

UP NEXT

Trump Tries to Set Expectations, and Floats Excuses, for His Debate With Biden

UP NEXT

California Lawmakers Fast-Track Restaurant Exemption to Hidden Fees Law

UP NEXT

High-Stakes Deal-Making Continues Behind the Scenes on CA Budget and Ballot

UP NEXT

U.S. Debt on Pace to Top $56 Trillion Over Next 10 Years

UP NEXT

On Juneteenth, Freedom Came With Strings Attached

UP NEXT

California Should Fight the Ticketmaster Monopoly, Not Embolden It

UP NEXT

Fresno Garbage Rate Hike Vote on Thursday. Where Does Council Stand?

UP NEXT

California Business & Labor Hammer Out a Deal on Workplace Violation Lawsuits

UP NEXT

American Leaders Should Stop Debasing Themselves on Israel

UP NEXT

Opinion: You Don’t Need a Ph.D. to Understand Climate Change, Just an Insurance Policy

Luxury Portable Bathrooms? Fresno Co. Lets You to Do Your Business in Opulence

4 hours ago

Tropical Storm Alberto Forms in Southwest Gulf, 1st Named Storm of the Hurricane Season

5 hours ago

Images Reveal Extensive Destruction in Lebanese Villages

5 hours ago

Rifts Seem to Appear Between Israel’s Political and Military Leadership Over Conduct of the Gaza War

5 hours ago

Anarchy Hinders Gaza Aid Efforts, Despite Daily Combat Pause

5 hours ago

Trump Tries to Set Expectations, and Floats Excuses, for His Debate With Biden

5 hours ago

Parlier Political Wars Update: Did the Council Fire the City Attorney, or Not?

5 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: Fresno to Decide on 114% Trash Rate Hikes

7 hours ago

UN Commissioner Calls Israeli Army ‘One of the Most Criminal in the World’

8 hours ago

Iran’s Nuclear Expansion Raises Global Concerns, Condemnation

8 hours ago

Watch: Saudi Crown Prince Demands Netanyahu Face Criminal Charges for Gaza

In a recent video released by Arab News, Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has called for Israeli Prime Minister Benjami...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Watch: Saudi Crown Prince Demands Netanyahu Face Criminal Charges for Gaza

3 hours ago

Mehdi Hasan Debates Zionism in Heated Live Event

3 hours ago

Happ, Swanson Homers as Chicago Cubs Battle SF Giants

4 hours ago

Luxury Portable Bathrooms? Fresno Co. Lets You to Do Your Business in Opulence

5 hours ago

Tropical Storm Alberto Forms in Southwest Gulf, 1st Named Storm of the Hurricane Season

5 hours ago

Images Reveal Extensive Destruction in Lebanese Villages

5 hours ago

Rifts Seem to Appear Between Israel’s Political and Military Leadership Over Conduct of the Gaza War

5 hours ago

Anarchy Hinders Gaza Aid Efforts, Despite Daily Combat Pause

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend