Share
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
SAN FRANCISCO — A federal appeals court in a rare move overturned the death sentence of a man who was convicted of robbing and killing two people in Fresno in 1988, saying prosecutors knowingly presented false testimony from a key witness.
The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in its Wednesday ruling upheld Colin Dickey’s robbery conviction and said prosecutors could decide whether to retry him for murder. Dickey remains in prison.
“This is an exceptional case in which the prosecutor deliberately elicited, and then failed to correct, false and misleading testimony from the State’s star witness,” the court said in a ruling overturning Dickey’s 1991 death sentence.
The Fresno County prosecutor elicited the testimony from key witness Gene Buchanan, who told the jury he had not met with prosecutors or accepted any benefits from them. In fact, the court said, they had met a dozen times during the investigation, and the district attorney’s office had dismissed drug charges against him and helped him collect a $5,000 reward for implicating Dickey, one of his roommates.
Dickey was convicted in the murders of two neighbors, Marie Caton, 76, and Louis Freiri, 67, who were beaten and stabbed to death in November 1988 at Caton’s home in Fresno, where Freiri was a boarder, the San Francisco Chronicle reported.
Both Dickey and Buchanan lived with Caton’s grandson, Richard Cullumber, who according to witnesses was a drug user who frequently requested money from Caton. Five days after the attack, the court said, Cullumber fled police in a car, said he had “killed a woman,” was cornered after a high-speed chase and shot himself to death.
According to another roommate, Dickey said he had gone to Caton’s house with Cullumber to help him get the money but had nothing to do with the killings. But Buchanan testified that Dickey told him he was at the scene of the attacks, saw Freiri lying with his head slumped down, and decided that “if you kill one you might as well kill them both.”
Buchanan’s testimony “was the centerpiece of the state’s case” and without his dubious statements, “the state’s case against Dickey was weak” and lacked any direct evidence of intent to kill, Judge Morgan Christen said in the 3-0 ruling.
RELATED TOPICS:
Five Weeknight Dishes: Seven Ingredients or Fewer, Because Summer
1 day ago
Big Fresno Fair Unveils Second Wave of 2025 Concert Acts
1 day ago
Americans Don’t See Supreme Court as Politically Neutral, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds
17 minutes ago
Fresno Man Arrested in Fatal DUI Crash on Trimmer Springs Road
21 hours ago
Israeli Military Kills 41 People in Gaza, Medics Say
21 hours ago
Manhunt for Gunman Who Shot Two Minnesota Lawmakers Enters Second Day
22 hours ago
Israel and Iran Bombard Each Other, Trump Says He Can ‘Easily’ End Conflict
22 hours ago
Trump Vetoed an Israeli Plan to Kill Iran’s Supreme Leader, US Officials Say
22 hours ago
Newsom Wanted To Fast-Track the Delta Tunnel Project. The Legislature Slowed the Flow
24 hours ago
Five Weeknight Dishes: Seven Ingredients or Fewer, Because Summer
1 day ago
Big Fresno Fair Unveils Second Wave of 2025 Concert Acts
1 day ago
Americans Don’t See Supreme Court as Politically Neutral, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds
17 minutes ago
Fresno Man Arrested in Fatal DUI Crash on Trimmer Springs Road
21 hours ago
Israeli Military Kills 41 People in Gaza, Medics Say
21 hours ago
Manhunt for Gunman Who Shot Two Minnesota Lawmakers Enters Second Day
22 hours ago
Israel and Iran Bombard Each Other, Trump Says He Can ‘Easily’ End Conflict
22 hours ago
Trump Vetoed an Israeli Plan to Kill Iran’s Supreme Leader, US Officials Say
22 hours ago
Newsom Wanted To Fast-Track the Delta Tunnel Project. The Legislature Slowed the Flow
24 hours ago
Five Weeknight Dishes: Seven Ingredients or Fewer, Because Summer
1 day ago
Big Fresno Fair Unveils Second Wave of 2025 Concert Acts
1 day ago
Suspect in Shooting of Minnesota Lawmakers to Appear in Court on Murder Charges
2 minutes ago
Categories

Suspect in Shooting of Minnesota Lawmakers to Appear in Court on Murder Charges

Iran Asks Gulf States to Mediate for Ceasefire With Israel, Sources Say

Wall Street Climbs as Oil Prices Ease, Fed Meeting in Focus

Americans Don’t See Supreme Court as Politically Neutral, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

Fresno Man Arrested in Fatal DUI Crash on Trimmer Springs Road

Israeli Military Kills 41 People in Gaza, Medics Say

Manhunt for Gunman Who Shot Two Minnesota Lawmakers Enters Second Day
