Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
After Court Ruling, California's Gig Worker Battle Takes New Turn
By admin
Published 2 years ago on
March 20, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The seemingly perpetual political and legal battle over whether gig workers for Uber, Lyft, Doordash and services are contractors or employees took another turn last week and may go full circle – back to the state Supreme Court and possibly a second trip through the Legislature.

state appellate court upheld all but one section of Proposition 22, a 2020 ballot measure sponsored by Uber and other companies to exempt its drivers from Assembly Bill 5, a 2019 law that declared which categories of workers could be contractors and which must be payroll employees.

The legislation was sought by labor unions to implement a 2018 state Supreme Court ruling that stemmed from a 2004 decision by Dynamex Operations West, a package delivery service, to convert its drivers from employees to contractors.

Dan Walters with a serious expression

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Two drivers sued, contending that the conversion violated state labor law. After preliminary skirmishing in lower courts, the issue wound up in the California Supreme Court. It declared that Dynamex’s drivers were improperly converted to contractors and established a three-factor test to determine whether a worker in any industry must be a payroll employee or could be a contractor.

It was a huge win for California’s labor unions, which view contractor status as a way for employers to avoid union organization of their workers or provide benefits such as health insurance and workers’ compensation. Unions quickly urged the Legislature to codify the ruling and narrowly specify categories of workers that could be contractors.

Lorena Gonzalez, a labor leader and former Democratic assemblymember, carried AB 5, which provided only a few exemptions from employee status, such as hairdressers and real estate agents. She now heads the California Labor Federation.

After Gov. Gavin Newsom signed AB 5, the affected companies launched an initiative to exempt their drivers and pledged tens of millions of dollars to qualify and pass it. Ultimately they spent more than $200 million on Proposition 22, contending that their contractor systems provided drivers with flexibility and they would receive some employee-like protections and benefits.

Labor Union’s Meager Opposition

The labor movement, oddly, did not mount an equally strong campaign against the measure, spending less than $20 million, and voters approved it by a 3-2 margin. Its approval, however, merely shifted the issue back to the courts in a lawsuit that challenged Proposition 22’s constitutionality.

An Alameda County judge invalidated the measure but last week a three-member appellate court panel voted 2-1 to uphold all but one piece, which probably will mean a trip back to the state Supreme Court and possibly the Legislature.

If the Supreme Court agrees with the appellate ruling, the transportation services could continue classifying their drivers as contractors. However, the one section of Proposition 22 tossed out by the appellate judges, which was aimed at making it almost impossible for the Legislature to amend its provisions, would open the door to another legislative clash. It would allow the Legislature to decree that contract drivers could, if they wish, form unions to bargain with the companies.

It’s dead certain that unions will seek such legislation if the Supreme Court ratifies the appellate court ruling.

“We are grateful that the California Court of Appeal has affirmed that companies like Uber, Lyft, Doordash and Instacart can’t keep drivers from joining together in a union through their deceptive ballot measure,” Mike Robinson, a contract driver who is one of the plaintiffs in the suit, said in a statement.

And if the Legislature acts, what then? Would there be another ballot measure to overturn that law as well? Given the issue’s 19-year history, one cannot discount that possibility.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Immediate Threat: Mussel Invades California’s Delta, First Time in North America

DON'T MISS

Two-Time Cy Young Winner Blake Snell Opts Out of Contract with Giants

DON'T MISS

No Matter the Outcome, We Are the True Losers of This Election

DON'T MISS

Russia’s Swift March Forward in Ukraine’s East

DON'T MISS

Rapper Young Thug Is a Free Man. Here Are Things to Know About His Plea.

DON'T MISS

AMOR Wellness Trunk-or-Treat Brings 700 Mendota Residents Together for Halloween Fun

DON'T MISS

What Kind of Trouble Is Miguel Arias Trying to Stir Up This Time?

DON'T MISS

MrBeast Probe Ends With Some Employees Fired but Finds No Proof of Sexual Misconduct Allegations

DON'T MISS

Lyft Pays $2.1 Million to Settle Case Alleging the Ride-Hailing Service Deceived Drivers

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Shot to Death at NW Apartment Complex Is Identified

UP NEXT

No Matter the Outcome, We Are the True Losers of This Election

UP NEXT

Lyft Pays $2.1 Million to Settle Case Alleging the Ride-Hailing Service Deceived Drivers

UP NEXT

Southern California County Official Pleads Guilty to Bribery Charge in COVID Funds Scheme

UP NEXT

California’s Transition Off Carbon Fuels Could Be a Monumental Disaster

UP NEXT

Don’t Let Liberal Purity Elect Trump

UP NEXT

Newsom Provides Welfare to the Wealthy, Skimps on Anti-Homelessness Programs

UP NEXT

Anti-Semitic Incident at Oakland Cafe Raises Concerns About Rising Intolerance

UP NEXT

Independent Gen Zers Will Decide Elections From Now On

UP NEXT

Schwarzenegger Endorses Harris, Warns Against Another Trump Term

UP NEXT

Will Noncitizens Be Able to Vote? This California City Will Decide Their Fate

Russia’s Swift March Forward in Ukraine’s East

9 hours ago

Rapper Young Thug Is a Free Man. Here Are Things to Know About His Plea.

9 hours ago

AMOR Wellness Trunk-or-Treat Brings 700 Mendota Residents Together for Halloween Fun

9 hours ago

What Kind of Trouble Is Miguel Arias Trying to Stir Up This Time?

9 hours ago

MrBeast Probe Ends With Some Employees Fired but Finds No Proof of Sexual Misconduct Allegations

10 hours ago

Lyft Pays $2.1 Million to Settle Case Alleging the Ride-Hailing Service Deceived Drivers

10 hours ago

Fresno Man Shot to Death at NW Apartment Complex Is Identified

10 hours ago

Guns, Marijuana, Gambling: Fresno’s Smoke Shop Enforcement Issues $5M in Citations

11 hours ago

North Korea’s Long-Range Missile Test Signals Its Improved, Potential Capability to Attack US

14 hours ago

Pennsylvania Challenge of Elon Musk’s $1M-a-Day Voter Sweepstakes Moves to Federal Court

14 hours ago

Immediate Threat: Mussel Invades California’s Delta, First Time in North America

From the glittery bling of its name, the golden mussel sounds like it could be California’s state bivalve. Alastair Bland CalMatters...

8 hours ago

8 hours ago

Immediate Threat: Mussel Invades California’s Delta, First Time in North America

9 hours ago

Two-Time Cy Young Winner Blake Snell Opts Out of Contract with Giants

9 hours ago

No Matter the Outcome, We Are the True Losers of This Election

A resident outside an apartment complex that was destroyed by Russian bombardment in Siversk, in Ukraine, Oct. 30, 2024. (Tyler Hicks/The New York Times)
9 hours ago

Russia’s Swift March Forward in Ukraine’s East

9 hours ago

Rapper Young Thug Is a Free Man. Here Are Things to Know About His Plea.

9 hours ago

AMOR Wellness Trunk-or-Treat Brings 700 Mendota Residents Together for Halloween Fun

9 hours ago

What Kind of Trouble Is Miguel Arias Trying to Stir Up This Time?

10 hours ago

MrBeast Probe Ends With Some Employees Fired but Finds No Proof of Sexual Misconduct Allegations

Search

Send this to a friend