Double-Barreled ‘Tort Wars’ Conflict Heats Up
By admin
Published 1 year ago on
February 1, 2023
Stock Photo ID: 2232490273 California US state flag with statue of lady justice, constitution and judge hammer on black drapery. Concept of judgement and punishment

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Nothing is more pervasive in California’s Capitol than what have been dubbed “tort wars” – skirmishes over rules governing personal injury lawsuits.

No session of the Legislature is complete without at least one clash over who can sue whom for what act and collect damages that can potentially reach hundreds of millions of dollars.

Tort wars pit business and insurance interests against lawyers who specialize in personal injury lawsuits, often in alliance with unions and consumer and environmental protection groups. The battles are waged in courts and in ballot measures as well as the hallways of the Capitol.

A double-barreled showdown is imminent over a unique law called the Private Attorney Generals Act (PAGA), which authorizes private lawsuits to enforce California’s labor laws. Former Gov. Gray Davis signed the legislation in 2003, just five days after voters decided to recall him.

Dan Walters with a serious expression

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Its enactment was a big tort wars win for personal injury attorneys and labor unions, both of which had backed Davis in his unsuccessful fight against the recall. They contended that private suits were needed to fill a big void in state labor law enforcement.

The pro-PAGA faction scored two more victories last year when the Legislature passed bills to expand its potential scope, one authorizing employees to refuse to work if they consider it unsafe, and the other requiring employers to reveal wage scales for current workers and potential jobseekers.

However, business groups claim that PAGA is a license for outrageous shakedowns of employers for even tiny labor law infractions, and are sponsoring a measure for the 2024 ballot to repeal it. Meanwhile, as the rival factions gear up for a ballot battle, they are also dueling over PAGA’s scope in the state Supreme Court.

Last year, as the Legislature was expanding the reach of PAGA, the U.S. Supreme Court was constricting its scope slightly by invalidating class action suits by workers who had signed pre-employment arbitration agreements.

Another case now pending in the state Supreme Court could expand PAGA’s reach. To make the case even more noteworthy, it involves another burning issue – whether drivers for Uber and other ride-sharing and delivery services are independent contractors or employees.

In 2018, the state Supreme Court issued its landmark ruling that sharply broadened circumstances requiring workers to be considered employees. The Legislature then codified the ruling in the much-debated Assembly Bill 5, carving out very few exceptions. But Uber, Lyft and other companies persuaded voters in 2020 to pass a ballot measureProposition 22, exempting their drivers from the law.

The pending state Supreme Court case involves an Uber driver, Erik Adolph, who signed an arbitration agreement before beginning work as a contractor. He contends that he was really an employee and therefore entitled to file a class action lawsuit under PAGA.

Adolph won at the trial court level and in a state appellate court, but Uber has now appealed to the state Supreme Court and the contending PAGA factions see it as another potentially landmark case.

Californians for Fair Pay and Employer Accountability, a coalition of major business groups led by the California Chamber of Commerce, has filed an amicus brief on the case saying they are making “combating the widespread abuse of PAGA a priority: to stop its misuse by plaintiffs’ lawyers as a tool to shakedown businesses, rather than to ensure Labor Code compliance.”

Attorney General Rob Bonta, on the other hand, submitted a brief supporting the broad application of PAGA.

The court will issue its PAGA ruling this year. Voters will have what may be the last word next year. Tort wars will continue indefinitely, year after year.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

The 49ers Have Been Docked a 2025 Fifth-Round Draft Pick for an Accounting Error

DON'T MISS

Ohtani to Begin Throwing Program Soon. Roberts Hints Dodgers Star Might Play in the Field

DON'T MISS

How California’s Prized Solution for Methane Gas Is Backfiring on Farmers

DON'T MISS

California Isn’t on Track to Meet Its Climate Change Mandates — and a New Analysis Says It’s Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Many Californians Rely on This Farmers Market Program. Newsom Wants to Cut It

DON'T MISS

Aaron Donald Announces His Retirement After a Standout 10-Year Career With the Rams

DON'T MISS

Baseball Superstar Ohtani and His Wife Arrive in South Korea for Dodgers-Padres MLB Opener

DON'T MISS

Terrified Residents of San Francisco’s Tenderloin District Sue for Streets Free of Drugs, Tents

DON'T MISS

16 SWAT Officers Hospitalized After Blast at Training Facility in Southern California

DON'T MISS

Carbon Capture Storage Is Key to California’s Economy & Energy Future

No data was found

The 49ers Have Been Docked a 2025 Fifth-Round Draft Pick for an Accounting Error

3 hours ago

Fresno Bank Sued. It Allegedly Helped Bitwise Commit Fraud.

bitwise /

3 hours ago

How California’s Prized Solution for Methane Gas Is Backfiring on Farmers

environment /

6 hours ago

Supreme Court Seems Favorable to Biden Administration Over Efforts to Combat Social Media Posts

7 hours ago

Putin Extends Rule in Preordained Russian Election After Harshest Crackdown Since Soviet Era

7 hours ago

Ohtani to Begin Throwing Program Soon. Roberts Hints Dodgers Star Might Play in the Field

7 hours ago

Trump: Some Migrants Are ‘Not People’, There’ll Be a ‘Bloodbath’ if I Lose

7 hours ago

Tech Lawyer and Philanthropist Nicole Shanahan Rumored as RFK Jr.’s VP Pick

news /

8 hours ago

March Madness is Here. UConn, Purdue, Houston and North Carolina Get Top Seeding in NCAA Tournament

8 hours ago

Crafts Retailer Joann Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy as Consumers Cut Back on Pandemic-Era Hobbies

8 hours ago

Records Show That Valley Children’s Leader Suntrapak’s Pay Exceeds $5 Million

■Valley Children’s paid CEO Todd Suntrapak $5.2 million in 2021. The hospital also gave him a $5 million forgivable home loan. ■The Va...
Healthcare /

2 hours ago

3 days ago

Realtor Association Settles Lawsuit on Commission Rules. Fresno Broker Fears the End of Market Transparency

3 days ago

Prosecutor Leaves Georgia Election Case Against Trump After Relationship With District Attorney

3 days ago

Rory McIlroy’s 65: 10 Birdies, 2 Tee Shots in the Water, 1 Testy Dispute

3 days ago

Aaron Donald Announces His Retirement After a Standout 10-Year Career With the Rams

3 days ago

New Book Explores the Myths, Truths and Legacy of the Macho Man

3 days ago

Baseball Superstar Ohtani and His Wife Arrive in South Korea for Dodgers-Padres MLB Opener

3 days ago

India’s New Citizenship Law Excludes Muslims. Here’s What to Know

3 days ago

US, G-7 Allies Warn Iran to Back Off Deal to Provide Russia Ballistic Missiles or Face New Sanctions

Photo of San Francisco 49ers' Arik Armstead

3 days ago

Former 49ers DT Arik Armstead Agrees to a 3-Year, $51 Million Deal with the Jaguars, AP Source Says

3 days ago

Supreme Court Rules Public Officials Can Sometimes Be Sued for Blocking Critics on Social Media

Search