Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California’s Boom or Bust Tax System Strikes Again
By admin
Published 2 years ago on
January 11, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Gov. Gavin Newsom’s penchant for braggadocio was in full flower eight months ago when he declared that California had a $97.5 billion budget surplus and boasted that “no other state in American history has ever experienced a surplus as large as this.”

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

He and the Legislature then wrote a 2022-23 budget with major increases in education, medical care and social services, plus a multi-billion-dollar cash rebate to taxpayers and other one-time expenditures.

On Tuesday, a more subdued Newsom acknowledged that the projected surplus had morphed into a $22.5 billion shortfall. He proposed a $297 billion 2023-24 budget that throttles back some of the additional spending and indirectly borrows billions of dollars to close the gap.

Moreover, Newsom warned that if the Federal Reserve System’s interest rate increases trigger a recession, the deficit could become much worse.

California’s Roller Coaster Tax System

The situation is another reminder that California’s public finances are at the mercy of an extremely volatile revenue system, one dominated by personal income taxes, especially those paid by high-income Californians on their stocks and other capital investments.

As he began his presentation to reporters, Newsom displayed a chart demonstrating the ups and downs of capital gains as a percentage of personal income – reaching a peak of 9.7% in 2021 and now expected to decline to 5% by 2025.

Newsom said it “sums up California’s tax structure, sums up boom and bust.”

The decline in investment earnings, Newsom said, is the primary reason for a $29 billion reduction in projected income. His estimate of revenue declines and the resulting $22.5 deficit is a bit more optimistic than a November forecast from the Legislature’s budget analyst, Gabe Petek.

‘Not Touching the Reserves,’ Says Newsom

The situation rekindles a decades-old debate in political, academic, and media circles about the state budget’s volatile dependence on the investment earnings of a relative handful of affluent taxpayers.

Former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and legislative leaders created a blue-ribbon commission to recommend tax system changes that would lessen volatility. The badly divided commission proposed to reduce the reliance on the income tax by flattening it to just two brackets, eliminating sales and corporate income taxes, and creating a new “net business receipts tax.”

When the “Parsky Commission,” so dubbed for its chairman, businessman Gerald Parsky, finally released its report in 2009, it was quickly consigned to oblivion. When Jerry Brown returned to the governorship in 2011, he proposed to deal with volatility by creating a “rainy day” reserve financed by windfall revenues.

That fund and other reserves now total $35.6 billion, which would easily cover the current deficit, but Newsom – agreeing with Patek – is not tapping them, citing the danger of recession.

“We’re not touching these reserves,” he said. “We’re in a very volatile moment.”

As hefty as the reserves appear, it’s questionable whether they would be enough to counter even a moderate recession.

Little Appetite for Tax Reform

Petek, who pegged the current shortfall at $24 billion without a recession, warned in his November forecast that “Based on historical experience, should a recession occur soon, revenues could be $30 billion to $50 billion below our revenue outlook in the budget window.”

In other words, a recession could have as much as a $74 billion negative impact on the budget, more than twice the state’s reserves. In relative terms, the state has faced deficits of that magnitude in past recessions.

“What’s consistent is the inconsistency of our tax structure,” Newsom acknowledged.

Ideally, California would alter that structure to make it less dependant on a narrow base of taxable income – but as the fate of the Parsky Commission’s report indicates, there’s little political appetite for such reform.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

I Can’t Believe Anyone Thinks Trump Actually Cares About Antisemitism

DON'T MISS

US Treasury Dealers Recommend Ending Federal Debt Ceiling

DON'T MISS

Nearly 450,000 US Customers Without Power After Severe Storm

DON'T MISS

Teoscar Hernandez, Andy Pages Lead 18-Hit Attack as Dodgers Beat Marlins

DON'T MISS

Palestinian Student Released on Bail as He Challenges Deportation From US

DON'T MISS

Kamala Harris Plans a Speech Sharply Criticizing Donald Trump’s Policies

DON'T MISS

‘Agreeing to Disagree’ Is Hurting Your Relationships – Here’s What to Do Instead

DON'T MISS

Ukraine Says It’s Poised to Sign a Key Mineral Resources Deal Sought by the US

DON'T MISS

California High-Speed Rail Leader Pushes State to Support Private Investment

DON'T MISS

Israeli Military Intervenes in Syrian Sectarian Violence

UP NEXT

US Treasury Dealers Recommend Ending Federal Debt Ceiling

UP NEXT

Nearly 450,000 US Customers Without Power After Severe Storm

UP NEXT

Teoscar Hernandez, Andy Pages Lead 18-Hit Attack as Dodgers Beat Marlins

UP NEXT

Palestinian Student Released on Bail as He Challenges Deportation From US

UP NEXT

Kamala Harris Plans a Speech Sharply Criticizing Donald Trump’s Policies

UP NEXT

‘Agreeing to Disagree’ Is Hurting Your Relationships – Here’s What to Do Instead

UP NEXT

Ukraine Says It’s Poised to Sign a Key Mineral Resources Deal Sought by the US

UP NEXT

California High-Speed Rail Leader Pushes State to Support Private Investment

UP NEXT

Israeli Military Intervenes in Syrian Sectarian Violence

UP NEXT

Wildfires Rage Near Jerusalem, Major Road Closed, Communities Evacuated

Teoscar Hernandez, Andy Pages Lead 18-Hit Attack as Dodgers Beat Marlins

20 minutes ago

Palestinian Student Released on Bail as He Challenges Deportation From US

23 minutes ago

Kamala Harris Plans a Speech Sharply Criticizing Donald Trump’s Policies

24 minutes ago

‘Agreeing to Disagree’ Is Hurting Your Relationships – Here’s What to Do Instead

28 minutes ago

Ukraine Says It’s Poised to Sign a Key Mineral Resources Deal Sought by the US

34 minutes ago

California High-Speed Rail Leader Pushes State to Support Private Investment

39 minutes ago

Israeli Military Intervenes in Syrian Sectarian Violence

48 minutes ago

Wildfires Rage Near Jerusalem, Major Road Closed, Communities Evacuated

56 minutes ago

California Sent Investigators to ICE Facilities. They Found More Detainees, and Health Care Gaps

1 hour ago

Americans Are Chasing the Castlecore Dream in Europe, and You Should Too

1 hour ago

I Can’t Believe Anyone Thinks Trump Actually Cares About Antisemitism

Michelle Goldberg April 28, 2025 Opinion About a decade ago, conservatives would often denounce Muslim immigration on the grounds that it t...

2 minutes ago

Pro-Trump kippahs at an event organized by the Republican Jewish Coalition at the Wisconsin Club in Milwaukee, July 18, 2024. (Jamie Lee Taete/The New York Times)
2 minutes ago

I Can’t Believe Anyone Thinks Trump Actually Cares About Antisemitism

U.S. dollar banknotes are seen in this photo illustration taken February 12, 2018. (REUTERS/Jose Luis Gonzalez/Illustration/File Photo)
10 minutes ago

US Treasury Dealers Recommend Ending Federal Debt Ceiling

17 minutes ago

Nearly 450,000 US Customers Without Power After Severe Storm

20 minutes ago

Teoscar Hernandez, Andy Pages Lead 18-Hit Attack as Dodgers Beat Marlins

Demonstrators hold placards that read "Free Mohsen" in reference to Mohsen Mahdawi, a Palestinian green card holder and student at Columbia University that was detained, as they gather at Foley Square calling for the release of Palestinian activist and Columbia University graduate student Mahmoud Khalil, in Manhattan, New York City, U.S., April 15, 2025. (REUTERS/Jeenah Moon/File Photo)
23 minutes ago

Palestinian Student Released on Bail as He Challenges Deportation From US

24 minutes ago

Kamala Harris Plans a Speech Sharply Criticizing Donald Trump’s Policies

28 minutes ago

‘Agreeing to Disagree’ Is Hurting Your Relationships – Here’s What to Do Instead

34 minutes ago

Ukraine Says It’s Poised to Sign a Key Mineral Resources Deal Sought by the US

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend