Share
A judge has tentatively granted the city of Fresno’s motion to dismiss a six-year-old case involving discolored and contaminated water in northeast Fresno homes.
The case was granted class-action status, meaning the 13 plaintiffs could have expanded to thousands. They claimed water delivered into their homes through corroded pipes ruined their plumbing and lowered property values.
An attorney representing some of the plaintiffs vowed to appeal, once Fresno County Superior Court Judge Rosemary McGuire’s ruling becomes final. Attorneys held oral arguments on Wednesday.
“We absolutely disagree with the court’s tentative ruling,” plaintiffs’ attorney Shehnaz Bhujwala of Boucher LLP told GV Wire.
McGuire, in her tentative ruling released Tuesday, was unconvinced that the plaintiffs made their case.
“Assuming a mandatory duty exists, there is insufficient evidence presented to create a triable issue as to breach or causation. Plaintiffs’ action is based on alleged violations of legislative enactments designed to protect public health. Plaintiffs are unable to present a triable issue of fact that the damage allegedly suffered is one of the consequences the enacting body sought to prevent in imposing the mandatory duty,” McGuire wrote.
The ruling in effect canceled a trial scheduled for April 2023.
Water Problems Dominated the Headlines in 2016
With the Flint, Michigan water crisis top of mind for many, resident complaints about water quality initiated public meetings led by then-Fresno Public Utilities Director Thomas Esqueda.
He told residents that second-rate galvanized pipes were corroding and leaking iron, zinc, and even lead into their homes.
Subsequently, the then chief of Fresno’s water operations was placed on administrative leave over discrepancies in water quality reports.
And, the Fresno City Council quickly banned galvanized pipes for plumbing in new construction and remodels.
Damage Could Have Been in the Millions
The first lawsuit came in 2016 when residents said water from the northeast water treatment facility rusted their pipes. Another set of plaintiffs sued a year later, and the cases were consolidated.
Among other things, the plaintiffs said the city did not report discolored water complaints to state authorities and violated its permit to operate a water treatment facility.
Bhujwala, the attorney for the plaintiffs, estimated that damages could be in the millions.
“The court’s decision is opposite to prior decisions in the case where the court recognized that having to replumb your plumbing … is a necessary cost because the plaintiffs and class members are receiving discolored water that is contaminated with heavy metals leaching from the corroded plumbing,” Bhujwala said.
City officials did not respond to GV Wire’s request for comment.
The case is listed on the closed session agenda for Thursday’s Fresno City Council meeting.
RELATED TOPICS:
If You Want to Ski Affordably Next Season, Buy Now
3 hours ago
Dog Found in Horrid Conditions Now Seeks Loving Home
4 hours ago
Trump Takes Aim at California Six Times in 24 Hours
4 hours ago
Elon Musk Sells X to His Own xAI for $33 Billion in All-Stock Deal
19 hours ago
US Naval Academy Ends Affirmative Action in Admissions
20 hours ago
Appeals Court Clears Way for DOGE to Keep Operating at USAID
20 hours ago
Trump Pledges US Aid for Asia Quake Despite Former Official Saying System in ‘Shambles’
20 hours ago
Is Fresno Political Consultant Alex Tavlian Behind Election Attack Mailer?
20 hours ago
Plastics Are Seeping Into Farm Fields, Food and Eventually Human Bodies
2 hours ago
Categories

Plastics Are Seeping Into Farm Fields, Food and Eventually Human Bodies

Myanmar’s Earthquake Death Toll Jumps to 1,644 as More Bodies Are Recovered From the Rubble

If You Want to Ski Affordably Next Season, Buy Now

Dog Found in Horrid Conditions Now Seeks Loving Home

Trump Takes Aim at California Six Times in 24 Hours

Elon Musk Sells X to His Own xAI for $33 Billion in All-Stock Deal

US Naval Academy Ends Affirmative Action in Admissions
