Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Will Fresno Taxpayers Foot the Bill for Councilman's Criminal Defense?
David Website Replacement
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 2 years ago on
August 15, 2022

Share

The Fresno City Council has considered paying for the defense of council president Nelson Esparza, who faces criminal charges of attempted extortion.

The details remain shrouded, but discussions over whether to use public funds for Esparza’s defense have been included on two recent closed session agendas. Esparza recused himself both times, according to the meeting minutes.

State law gives the city the right to pay criminal defense costs for an elected official, although it is not a requirement.

Sources told GV Wire that items on the council’s June 23 and July 21 meeting agendas focused on paying Esparza’s legal fees. The sources could not speak on the record because the conversations took place in closed sessions.

The Fresno County District Attorney’s office alleges Esparza threatened then-city attorney Douglas Sloan’s job in April, telling him to only perform work for certain members of the city council.

Sloan announced he was leaving his position soon after and is now city attorney in Santa Monica.

Esparza faces one felony count of attempted extortion and a misdemeanor count of violating the City Charter. His arraignment is set for Sept. 20.

If convicted, the maximum penalty is three years in jail. Esparza has denied the allegations and — in his only verbal public statements on the matter — said he plans to remain on the council and continue serving as president.

Esparza, through a campaign spokesperson, declined to comment for this story.

Some Councilmembers Want Public Discussion

Some councilmembers said discussions about paying for Esparza’s criminal defense should be held publicly.

“Would I support a public discussion if that was legally permissible? I certainly would. I support most things being out in public,” Councilman Garry Bredefeld said.

Councilman Mike Karbassi also supports an open discussion.

“I would also support a standing policy that taxpayer money never be spent on the criminal defense of an elected official,” Karbassi texted.

Councilman Tyler Maxwell declined to answer. Other councilmembers — Miguel Arias, Esmeralda Soria, Luis Chavez and Esparza — did not respond to requests for comment.

Discussion During Closed Session

“I would also support a standing policy that taxpayer money never be spent on the criminal defense of an elected official.” — Councilman Mike Karbassi

Multiple sources speaking on background say the first closed session discussion revolved around Esparza’s pending defamation lawsuit against fellow councilmember Garry Bredefeld. State law allows leeway to cover such litigation. The second discussion focused on Esparza’s criminal charges.

Recollections of the June 23 meeting vary. Sources differ on whether an actual vote was taken about covering the costs of Esparza’s defamation lawsuit. If any vote was taken, nothing was reported publicly — a possible violation of the state’s open meeting law.

One source said the city council voted 5-0 in two votes to pay for both sides of the civil suit. Another said it was just a briefing on the situation; and the city attorney and/or city manager made an administrative decision to fund either Bredefeld’s defense, Esparza’s lawsuit or both.

Could a decision to defend a lawsuit be made unilaterally by the city’s administration? GV Wire asked Scott Emblidge, an attorney with San Francisco-based Moscone Emblidge & Rubens LLP and an expert on municipal law.

“That depends on the City’s charter or administrative code in terms of who is authorized to make that type of decision.  In San Francisco, for example, the City Attorney does not seek Board of Supervisors’ approval for defending lawsuits,” Emblidge said in an email.

When asked what the city manager’s role in the discussion was, City Manager Georgeanne White pointed GV Wire to City Charter Sec. 803 (g), which states:

“The Council shall have control of all legal business and proceedings and may employ other attorneys to take charge of any litigation or matter or to assist the City Attorney therein.”

Coincidentally, Sec. 803 covers the role of the city attorney and what the District Attorney’s office alleges Esparza violated.

During the July 21 closed session item — three days after charges were filed — the city council learned that Esparza’s criminal defense could be covered, an extension of the information received on June 23.

A motion was made to prevent the city from covering Esparza’s criminal defense but it failed 4-2, sources say. That action was never reported publicly. Experts contacted by GV Wire were uncertain about whether such action needed to be made public.

Three conditions need to be met for a city to cover a criminal defense of an employee, including an elected leader — the alleged actions are brought on account of an act or omission in the scope of employment with the public entity; and it is determined to be in the best interest of the government entity to provide such a defense; and the employee acted without actual malice and in the apparent interests of the public entity.

Interim City Attorney Rina Gonzales did not respond to a request for comment.

Esparza dropped his defamation lawsuit in June, in part because the city would pay for Bredefeld’s defense.

“The potential liability to the City is something that greatly concerns me because it is our belief that the lawsuit would be successful. I love our city and will not sue the City of Fresno over my colleague’s defamatory remarks. His antics have already cost enough taxpayer dollars,” Esparza said in a news release.

Transparency of Closed Session Decisions

“Assuming it was agendized and properly discussed in closed session, any vote on whether to commit the City to pay an individual’s attorneys’ fees should have been reported in open session.” — Attorney Scott Emblidge

Municipal attorney Emblidge says more transparency is needed in both reporting on any vote in closed session, and how it is listed on the agenda.

“If such a vote was taken, that issue should have been specified on the council’s agenda. It is far from clear that this issue could be discussed in closed session under the litigation exception for closed sessions,” Emblidge said. “But even assuming it was agendized and properly discussed in closed session, any vote on whether to commit the city to pay an individual’s attorneys’ fees should have been reported in open session.”

Discussing potential litigation is an exception to the open meeting act.

David Loy, legal director with the First Amendment Coalition, questions whether Esparza’s pending litigation meets the threshold to hold the discussion in closed session.

“There has to be a bona fide exposure to litigation … It can’t just be a hypothetical fear,” Loy said. “(The city council) can’t collude to pretend that there’s a fear of litigation when there’s not.”

Loy also questioned whether the city can provide legal defense based only on existing policy or law.

“If it doesn’t require a vote of the council, why is it coming for council in the first place?” Loy said. “Because all Esparza would have to do is submit the form and get reimbursed.”

Both Loy and Emblidge — neither of whom are involved in the case — were at times baffled how a vote in closed session, if taken, would not be reported publicly.

DON'T MISS

Biden Won’t Enforce TikTok Ban, Official Says, Leaving Fate of App to Trump

DON'T MISS

Man With Stick Kills 2 Homeless People in Miami in ‘Unprovoked’ Attack, Police Say

DON'T MISS

FBI Closes Diversity Office, Reflects Broader Corporate Trend

DON'T MISS

School Is Safe Place for Kids Regardless of Immigration Status, Fresno Districts Say

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Crash Claims Life of 74-Year-Old Driver

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Sentenced to Life for 2020 Murder Over 49ers Flag

DON'T MISS

US Recovers $31 Million in Federal Payments to Dead People

DON'T MISS

Planning Commission Says Fresno Smoke Shop Plan Hurts ‘Good’ Biz Owners. Arias Says PC Is ‘Out of Touch.’

DON'T MISS

American Accused of Assaulting Pennsylvania Student Extradited From France to US

DON'T MISS

Looking for His Father, a Worried Son Went to Fire Evacuation Zone but Found Death and Devastation

UP NEXT

Fresno County Crash Claims Life of 74-Year-Old Driver

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Sentenced to Life for 2020 Murder Over 49ers Flag

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Seek Help in Locating Missing At-Risk Teen

UP NEXT

Fresno’s Jeff Atmajian, Orchestrator of ‘Joker’ and ‘Wicked,’ Speaks at Saroyan Theatre

UP NEXT

Many Americans Doubt Trump Will Be Able to Lower Prices in His First Year, an AP-NORC Poll Shows

UP NEXT

Clovis Police, California ABC Cite Bartender for Selling Alcohol to Minors

UP NEXT

Netanyahu Says ‘Last-Minute Crisis’ With Hamas Holding Up Gaza Truce Approval

UP NEXT

Key Takeaways from Pete Hegseth’s Fiery Confirmation Hearing

UP NEXT

How Trump Could Try to Stay in Power After His Second Term Ends

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Deshon Montrell Mayo

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

School Is Safe Place for Kids Regardless of Immigration Status, Fresno Districts Say

6 hours ago

Fresno County Crash Claims Life of 74-Year-Old Driver

6 hours ago

Fresno Man Sentenced to Life for 2020 Murder Over 49ers Flag

8 hours ago

US Recovers $31 Million in Federal Payments to Dead People

9 hours ago

Planning Commission Says Fresno Smoke Shop Plan Hurts ‘Good’ Biz Owners. Arias Says PC Is ‘Out of Touch.’

9 hours ago

American Accused of Assaulting Pennsylvania Student Extradited From France to US

9 hours ago

Looking for His Father, a Worried Son Went to Fire Evacuation Zone but Found Death and Devastation

9 hours ago

Netanyahu Postpones Cabinet Vote on Gaza Strip Ceasefire Deal

9 hours ago

Fresno Police Seek Help in Locating Missing At-Risk Teen

9 hours ago

Palestinians in Gaza Eager to Return Home in Ceasefire, but Many Will Find Nothing Left

9 hours ago

Biden Won’t Enforce TikTok Ban, Official Says, Leaving Fate of App to Trump

WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden won’t enforce a ban on the social media app TikTok that is set to take effect a day before he leaves ...

6 hours ago

6 hours ago

Biden Won’t Enforce TikTok Ban, Official Says, Leaving Fate of App to Trump

6 hours ago

Man With Stick Kills 2 Homeless People in Miami in ‘Unprovoked’ Attack, Police Say

6 hours ago

FBI Closes Diversity Office, Reflects Broader Corporate Trend

6 hours ago

School Is Safe Place for Kids Regardless of Immigration Status, Fresno Districts Say

6 hours ago

Fresno County Crash Claims Life of 74-Year-Old Driver

Daniel Epimenio Gonzalez, 39, of Fresno, was sentenced to 75 years to life for the 2020 murder of Frank Rojas, sparked by a dispute over a 49ers flag. (GV Wire File)
8 hours ago

Fresno Man Sentenced to Life for 2020 Murder Over 49ers Flag

9 hours ago

US Recovers $31 Million in Federal Payments to Dead People

9 hours ago

Planning Commission Says Fresno Smoke Shop Plan Hurts ‘Good’ Biz Owners. Arias Says PC Is ‘Out of Touch.’

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend