Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Crime 'Reform' Takes Away Key Tool to Hold Juvenile Killers Accountable
GV-Wire-1
By gvwire
Published 3 years ago on
July 12, 2022

Share

 

In 2000 California passed Proposition 21 – a ballot proposition aimed at addressing gang violence and allowing prosecutors to hold juveniles accountable as adults for violent crimes.  18 years later, voters reaffirmed their desire to continue to hold juveniles accountable by passing Prop 57, only now the decision is left to a judge.

However, in 2018 the state Senate reversed the will of the voters in passing Senate Bill 1391 to prohibit charging anyone under 16 as an adult, but allowing judicial discretion if a prosecutor seeks to charge 16 and 17 year olds as adults.

Charging juveniles as adults sounds draconian. There is a compelling case to be made that once a juvenile is convicted as an adult, reaches 18, and is transferred to adult prison, their future prospects are bleak.

Steve Smith

Opinion

But prior to SB 1391’s passage, district attorneys rarely ever charged juveniles as adults. Known as “adult court dispositions,” their numbers peaked in 2010 at just over 700 statewide and declined to under 200 in 2017 before lawmakers acted. Even at its peak, many adult court referrals went to the now closed California Youth Authority as “youthful offenders” and never saw the inside of an adult prison.  A few were charged and sentenced as adults for good reason.

Consider the case of Adrian “AJ” Gonzalez.  On July 27, 2015, 8 year old Madyson “Maddy” Middleton was reported missing from her Santa Cruz home. Barely 24 hours later, her body was discovered inside a garbage bag that had been dumped in a recycling bin near where she lived – and died. Not long after, Santa Cruz police arrested Gonzalez, a 15 year and 8 month-old neighbor, for her murder.

The evidence was overwhelming including video footage showing Gonzalez dumping her body where she had been found. Forensic evidence linked him to the crime and showed that she had been sexually assaulted and stabbed.

Despite a court ruling that Gonzalez be charged as an adult, the state Supreme Court ruled in 2021 that SB 1391 was retroactive to juveniles currently facing adult prosecution. Taking advantage of his legal good fortune, Gonzalez confessed and pleaded guilty. He will be freed in 2024.

By 2019, adult dispositions dipped to below the number of juveniles charged with murder and in 2020 California saw juvenile homicides increase. That means juvenile murderers as old as 17 and 11 months can be released before the expiration of juvenile court jurisdiction at age 25.

There are two reasons to charge juveniles as adults. One is that their crime is so egregious that the perpetrator is not suitable for rehabilitation within the juvenile system. Surprisingly, the other is that exempting a class of people from criminal prosecution makes them far easier to exploit by older, more sophisticated criminals. In Oliver Twist, Dickens identified that person as Fagan.  Today they are the leaders of California’s criminal street gangs.

Thanks in part to SB 1391, those gangs again have at their disposal youths who they lure into criminal activity with the promise of safety, friendship, and relative wealth that is essentially risk free. In short, juveniles are now less safe.

If an officer stops a car full of gang members, who will claim ownership of any contraband, drugs, or guns in the car? The juvenile, of course. The juvenile is always in the car.

Prop 21 made juveniles legally equal in terms of criminal culpability, thus granting prosecutors a valuable tool to obtain their cooperation in testifying against older, more sophisticated gang members. Successful gang prosecutions went up while juvenile prosecutions – and all crime – went down.

Today that legal tool has been taken away from California’s prosecutors and gangs know it. After reaching a ten-year low, homicides by juveniles are now up.

Voters should consider that even well-meaning criminal justice reforms can have the opposite effect when poorly conceived, researched, and implemented. SB 1391 is just such a reform.

About the Author

Steve Smith, a former police officer and former criminal justice professor, is a senior fellow in urban studies at the Pacific Research Institute.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Is It Bad to Chew Gum All Day?

DON'T MISS

Dollar Doubts Dominate Gathering of Global Economic Leaders

DON'T MISS

US Judge Temporarily Stops West Texas Immigrant Deportations Under Alien Enemies Act

DON'T MISS

Shedeur Sanders’ Long Wait Ends When Browns Take Him in the 5th Round of the NFL Draft

DON'T MISS

Only About Half of Republicans Say Trump Has Focused on the Right Priorities

DON'T MISS

ICE Deports the Mother of an Infant and a 2-Year-Old Who Is a US Citizen

DON'T MISS

Israeli Airstrike Kills 10 People, Half of Them Children

DON'T MISS

Shedeur Sanders Is Still Waiting for a Call as the NFL Draft Enters the Final Day

DON'T MISS

Israel’s AI Experiments in the War in Gaza Raise Ethical Concerns

DON'T MISS

Paul Skenes Strikes Out 9, Wins Duel With Yamamoto in Pirates’ Victory Over Dodgers

UP NEXT

We Need Proof of Life for the Makeup Artist Trump Sent to El Salvador

UP NEXT

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

UP NEXT

Lights, Camera, Board Vote: Fresno Unified’s Carefully Choreographed Production

UP NEXT

Given Its Failures, Can California Manage a Transition to a Carbon-Free Future?

UP NEXT

Over a Century Later, California May Need Another Revolt Against Its Utility Companies

UP NEXT

California’s Economy Was Already Sluggish Before Trump’s Global Tariffs

UP NEXT

Will Fresno Unified Sacrifice Another Generation of Students? The Choice Is Ours

UP NEXT

What if There’s No Way to Stop Trump’s Approach to Power?

UP NEXT

Zakaria Draws Parallels Between Trump’s Tariffs, Failed 1930s Economic Policies

UP NEXT

Americans Haven’t Found a Satisfying Alternative to Religion

Shedeur Sanders’ Long Wait Ends When Browns Take Him in the 5th Round of the NFL Draft

1 hour ago

Only About Half of Republicans Say Trump Has Focused on the Right Priorities

4 hours ago

ICE Deports the Mother of an Infant and a 2-Year-Old Who Is a US Citizen

5 hours ago

Israeli Airstrike Kills 10 People, Half of Them Children

5 hours ago

Shedeur Sanders Is Still Waiting for a Call as the NFL Draft Enters the Final Day

5 hours ago

Israel’s AI Experiments in the War in Gaza Raise Ethical Concerns

5 hours ago

Paul Skenes Strikes Out 9, Wins Duel With Yamamoto in Pirates’ Victory Over Dodgers

5 hours ago

Eovaldi Outlasts Verlander as Rangers Beat Giants

5 hours ago

Rams Take Oregon Tight End Terrance Ferguson in Second Round After Trading Out of First

6 hours ago

The Latest: Francis Is Remembered as a ‘Pope Among the People’ as He Is Laid to Rest

6 hours ago

Is It Bad to Chew Gum All Day?

Q: Mint gum is the only thing that gets me through the workday. Is all that chewing bad for my health? A: If you’re a regular gum chewer, yo...

2 minutes ago

2 minutes ago

Is It Bad to Chew Gum All Day?

7 minutes ago

Dollar Doubts Dominate Gathering of Global Economic Leaders

1 hour ago

US Judge Temporarily Stops West Texas Immigrant Deportations Under Alien Enemies Act

1 hour ago

Shedeur Sanders’ Long Wait Ends When Browns Take Him in the 5th Round of the NFL Draft

4 hours ago

Only About Half of Republicans Say Trump Has Focused on the Right Priorities

5 hours ago

ICE Deports the Mother of an Infant and a 2-Year-Old Who Is a US Citizen

5 hours ago

Israeli Airstrike Kills 10 People, Half of Them Children

5 hours ago

Shedeur Sanders Is Still Waiting for a Call as the NFL Draft Enters the Final Day

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend