Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: California’s Experiment in One-Man Governance by Newsom
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 4 years ago on
May 10, 2021

Share

The three-branch system of government is not unique to the United States, but most of the world’s democracies are governed by the parliamentary system.

In Great Britain, Canada, Japan, and other nations with parliamentary governments, the party or coalition that holds a majority of legislative seats automatically wields executive authority, rather than having a separately elected president. The parliamentary system’s prime minister governs by decree as long as the legislative majority continues.

Dan Walters

Opinion

This very brief excursion into political theory underpins what’s been happening in California during the past 14 months —an accidental experiment in quasi-parliamentary government, beginning with Gov. Gavin Newsom’s declaration of an emergency because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Ever since, Newsom has issued countless decrees governing economic and personal conduct, overriding whatever laws he deemed as impediments to battling the deadly infection. The Legislature, controlled by his fellow Democrats, has acquiesced.

Governor or Prime Minister?

Whether Newsom’s one-man command has been effective in taming the pandemic is the topic for another day. Whether his use of emergency powers has been excessive and arbitrary is both a political and a legal issue.

Politically, Newsom’s decrees, such as shutting down large portions of the economy and closing public schools, fueled the drive to recall him, which will culminate in an election next fall. The campaigns by his would-be successors are underway and he’s in full campaign mode with almost daily public appearances.

California’s recall campaign is comparable to what happens in a parliamentary system when the legitimacy of the current government is challenged. It mirrors, for instance, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s current efforts to survive.

Courts Backing Newsom

The legal aspect to Newsom’s assumption of broad emergency powers is being played out in the state’s courts, and so far he is winning.

Last week, the Sacramento-based 3rd District Court of Appeal unanimously declared that Newsom had not exceeded his legal authority, overturning a Superior Court ruling that he had illegally ignored state laws with his decrees.

Republican Assemblymen James Gallagher and Kevin Kiley had mounted the legal challenge and immediately declared an appeal to the state Supreme Court.

The two described the appellate decision as “a startling conclusion” and added, “The issue now squarely presented for the high court is whether the separation of powers still exists in California.” They expressed confidence that the high court “will uphold this bedrock principle of constitutional government.”

Newsom’s office called the ruling “a win for public safety and all Californians.”

The appellate court ruling was not surprising for several reasons.

First, California courts have generally sided with governors facing legal challenges. A few years back, for instance, the state Supreme Court gave then-Gov. Jerry Brown a pass when he employed a legally questionable process to place a criminal justice proposal on the ballot.

Governor Holds Judicial Purse Strings

Secondly, judges at all levels are aware that the governor controls how much money will be allocated to the courts.

Finally, the three justices who issued last week’s decision all were high-ranking members of previous governors’ staffs — two worked for Brown and one for George Deukmejian — so they naturally incline toward upholding executive authority.

Newsom will likely prevail when the issue hits the state Supreme Court. Whether he will prevail when his performance as California’s one-man band is placed before voters is less certain.

However it turns out, California’s experiment in quasi-parliamentary government will be grist for political scientists, political historians, and pundits for many years to come. They should weigh whether emergency powers meant to cope with relatively brief calamities such as earthquakes or riots should be extended into months- or even years-long expansions of executive power.

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

Elon Musk Is Creating His Own Texas Town. Hundreds Already Live There.

DON'T MISS

Amazon and Starbucks Workers Are Striking. What Does It Mean for Labor Under Trump?

DON'T MISS

CalFire Shares 2024’s Top Images. See Highlights of Intense Wildfire Season.

DON'T MISS

While Sherrod Motors to Boise, Entz’s Bulldogs Add a Coach, Transfers, Recruits

DON'T MISS

California and Texas Duke It Out for Worst State to Raise a Family

DON'T MISS

Musk Slams ‘Wokepedia’ for Biased Editing, Urges Donation Boycott

DON'T MISS

Explore the Holiday Magic in California’s Death Valley

DON'T MISS

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

DON'T MISS

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

DON'T MISS

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

UP NEXT

Amazon and Starbucks Workers Are Striking. What Does It Mean for Labor Under Trump?

UP NEXT

CalFire Shares 2024’s Top Images. See Highlights of Intense Wildfire Season.

UP NEXT

California and Texas Duke It Out for Worst State to Raise a Family

UP NEXT

Musk Slams ‘Wokepedia’ for Biased Editing, Urges Donation Boycott

UP NEXT

Explore the Holiday Magic in California’s Death Valley

UP NEXT

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

UP NEXT

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

UP NEXT

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

UP NEXT

What Is Israel’s US Funded Plan for the Middle East?

UP NEXT

Caitlin Clark Honored as AP Female Athlete of the Year

While Sherrod Motors to Boise, Entz’s Bulldogs Add a Coach, Transfers, Recruits

18 hours ago

California and Texas Duke It Out for Worst State to Raise a Family

19 hours ago

Musk Slams ‘Wokepedia’ for Biased Editing, Urges Donation Boycott

20 hours ago

Explore the Holiday Magic in California’s Death Valley

20 hours ago

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

21 hours ago

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

21 hours ago

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

21 hours ago

What Is Israel’s US Funded Plan for the Middle East?

21 hours ago

Caitlin Clark Honored as AP Female Athlete of the Year

22 hours ago

Rams Don’t Dominate, but They’re Mastered Winning Ugly

22 hours ago

Elon Musk Is Creating His Own Texas Town. Hundreds Already Live There.

Over the past few years, Elon Musk has expanded his footprint in Texas, moving his companies from California and building offices, warehouse...

35 minutes ago

The SpaceX starship rocket near the Starbase launchpad in Boca Chica, Texas, Feb. 21, 2024. Employees of SpaceX have filed a formal petition to create the city of Starbase. (Meridith Kohut/The New York Times)
35 minutes ago

Elon Musk Is Creating His Own Texas Town. Hundreds Already Live There.

36 minutes ago

Amazon and Starbucks Workers Are Striking. What Does It Mean for Labor Under Trump?

18 hours ago

CalFire Shares 2024’s Top Images. See Highlights of Intense Wildfire Season.

18 hours ago

While Sherrod Motors to Boise, Entz’s Bulldogs Add a Coach, Transfers, Recruits

19 hours ago

California and Texas Duke It Out for Worst State to Raise a Family

Photo of Elon Musk
20 hours ago

Musk Slams ‘Wokepedia’ for Biased Editing, Urges Donation Boycott

20 hours ago

Explore the Holiday Magic in California’s Death Valley

A vehicle crashed into a home on North Cain Street in Visalia Tuesday morning, causing minor property damage but no injuries, with the unlicensed driver cited at the scene. (Visalia PD)
21 hours ago

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend