Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

4 hours ago

Trump Says He’s Committed to Sending National Guard Troops to Chicago

6 hours ago

Trump Dismisses Rumors He Is in Ill Health, Calls Them ‘Fake’

6 hours ago

Rubio Says US Military Conducted Lethal Strike Against Drug Vessel From Venezuela

6 hours ago

Trump Says He Is ‘Very Disappointed’ With Putin Over Ukraine

6 hours ago

Wall Street Hits Over One-Week Low on Tariff Uncertainty, Data in Focus

11 hours ago

US Judge Blocks Trump Administration’s Use of Troops in Los Angeles

11 hours ago

Garnet Fire in Fresno County Grows to 26,982 Acres, 12% Contained

11 hours ago
Walters: Will Reducing Criminal Penalties Reduce Crime?
Portrait of CalMatters Columnist Dan Walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 5 years ago on
January 24, 2021

Share

California is conducting an immense sociological experiment, testing whether reducing prison time for criminal acts will, in the long run, mean less crime.

Over the last decade, politicians and voters have lowered penalties for dozens of serious and minor crimes, reduced state prison populations by about 40% and adopted multiple programs to treat underlying conditions, such as drug use and lack of education, to deter offenders from committing new crimes.

Dan Walters

Opinion

It’s been a dramatic turnaround from previous decades, when the public demanded ever-tougher sentences and the state couldn’t build prisons fast enough to handle a tidal wave of new inmates, resulting in overcrowding so severe that federal judges intervened.

The change coincided with California’s equally dramatic political reorientation.

From the late 1970s to the early 1990s, a fear of crime, particularly violent crime, dominated the state’s political atmosphere, symbolized by the “three strikes and you’re out” law aimed at putting repeat felons behind bars for life.

Republicans adroitly capitalized to win elections by accusing Democratic rivals of being soft on crime. In 1986, voters overwhelmingly voted out three liberal state Supreme Court justices because of their capital punishment rulings.

Within a Decade, Democrats Had Achieved Dominance at All Levels

Republican overreach, particularly a ballot measure targeting undocumented immigrants, and complex economic and sociological factors, such as the collapse of Southern California’s aerospace industry, began changing the state’s political climate in the late 1990s.

Within a decade, Democrats had achieved dominance at all levels and soon embraced what they called “criminal justice reform.”

Jerry Brown, who experienced the political impact of crime as governor in the late 1970s and 1980s and signed some of the lock-‘em-up bills, returned to the governorship in 2011. He was bent on reversing course, but cautiously didn’t make that intent public until he had won a fourth and final term in 2014.

Brown sponsored a 2016 ballot measure, Proposition 57, that swept away much of what he and other governors had wrought decades earlier, with political cover from federal judges who had ordered reductions in prison populations due to overcrowding.

Brown’s successor, Gavin Newsom, is continuing the experiment. Even though the death penalty is still law, Newsom has declared an execution moratorium. He also accelerated reductions in prison populations because of severe COVID-19 outbreaks and promised to close prisons.

Newsom’s proposed 2021-22 budget projects that the prison population, once as high as 170,000, will drop to 97,950 this year and continue declining thereafter.

Violent Crime Has Been Spiking Upwards During the Nearly Year-Long COVID-19 Pandemic

Meanwhile, voters in San Francisco and Los Angeles have elected new district attorneys on platforms to minimize incarceration and maximize diversions into non-penal rehabilitation.

They are seeing some pushback. George Gascón, who had been San Francisco’s district attorney before shifting to Los Angeles, is even being sued by his own deputies, contending he is violating the law by ordering them to seek minimal sentences for crimes.

The bottom line question, of course, is whether the attitudinal change will, as advocates contend, reduce the system’s disproportionate impact on Black and Latino communities while also reducing the overall threat of crime.

Interestingly, and perhaps significantly, violent crime has been spiking upwards during the nearly year-long COVID-19 pandemic. This month, Los Angeles Police Chief Michel Moore cited a sharp surge in homicides in his city to more than 300 in 2020 and 24 in the first two weeks of 2021.

In mid-January, the Los Angeles Times’ running tally of homicides counted 656 in Los Angeles County during the previous 12 months.

“It’s our shared responsibility to stop this senseless violence,” Moore said in his tweet.

If, however, it continues, will crime once again become a burning political issue?

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

[activecampaign form=19]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Caught With 1,500 Fentanyl Pills Sentenced to Five Years

DON'T MISS

California Jury Clears Pop Star Cardi B of Assault Allegations in Civil Lawsuit

DON'T MISS

How the US Congressional Redistricting War is Playing Out State by State

DON'T MISS

Republican US House Committee Releases Thousands of Epstein Files

DON'T MISS

AI Will Require 60% of Workers to Retrain. Are Fresno Colleges Ready?

DON'T MISS

How One Blackstone Avenue Shelter Took Business Owners’ Concerns to Heart

DON'T MISS

They Were Convicted of Gang Crimes. New CA Supreme Court Rulings Trim Their Sentences

DON'T MISS

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

DON'T MISS

US Congress Returns, With One Month to Avert Government Shutdown

DON'T MISS

Trump Says His Administration Will Ask Supreme Court for Expedited Ruling on Tariffs

UP NEXT

California Jury Clears Pop Star Cardi B of Assault Allegations in Civil Lawsuit

UP NEXT

How the US Congressional Redistricting War is Playing Out State by State

UP NEXT

Republican US House Committee Releases Thousands of Epstein Files

UP NEXT

AI Will Require 60% of Workers to Retrain. Are Fresno Colleges Ready?

UP NEXT

How One Blackstone Avenue Shelter Took Business Owners’ Concerns to Heart

UP NEXT

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

UP NEXT

US Congress Returns, With One Month to Avert Government Shutdown

UP NEXT

Trump Says His Administration Will Ask Supreme Court for Expedited Ruling on Tariffs

UP NEXT

Trump Says He’s Committed to Sending National Guard Troops to Chicago

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Arrest Teen After Traffic Stop Leads to Foot Chase, Firearm Recovery

Republican US House Committee Releases Thousands of Epstein Files

3 hours ago

AI Will Require 60% of Workers to Retrain. Are Fresno Colleges Ready?

4 hours ago

How One Blackstone Avenue Shelter Took Business Owners’ Concerns to Heart

4 hours ago

They Were Convicted of Gang Crimes. New CA Supreme Court Rulings Trim Their Sentences

4 hours ago

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

4 hours ago

US Congress Returns, With One Month to Avert Government Shutdown

5 hours ago

Trump Says His Administration Will Ask Supreme Court for Expedited Ruling on Tariffs

6 hours ago

Trump Says He’s Committed to Sending National Guard Troops to Chicago

6 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Teen After Traffic Stop Leads to Foot Chase, Firearm Recovery

6 hours ago

Trump Dismisses Rumors He Is in Ill Health, Calls Them ‘Fake’

6 hours ago

Fresno Man Caught With 1,500 Fentanyl Pills Sentenced to Five Years

A Fresno man was sentenced Tuesday to five years in federal prison for possessing fentanyl with intent to distribute, prosecutors said. Ady ...

2 hours ago

The crest of the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) is seen at their headquarters in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 10, 2021. REUTERS/Andrew Kelly/File photo
2 hours ago

Fresno Man Caught With 1,500 Fentanyl Pills Sentenced to Five Years

Cardi B looks on during the presentation of designer Rousteing's Spring/Summer 2025 Women's ready-to-wear collection show for fashion house Balmain during Paris Fashion Week in Paris, France, September 25, 2024. (Reuters File)
2 hours ago

California Jury Clears Pop Star Cardi B of Assault Allegations in Civil Lawsuit

Democratic lawmakers in Texas
3 hours ago

How the US Congressional Redistricting War is Playing Out State by State

U.S. financier Jeffrey Epstein appears in a photograph taken for the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services' sex offender registry March 28, 2017 and obtained by Reuters July 10, 2019. New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services/Handout via REUTERS/File Photo
3 hours ago

Republican US House Committee Releases Thousands of Epstein Files

4 hours ago

AI Will Require 60% of Workers to Retrain. Are Fresno Colleges Ready?

4 hours ago

How One Blackstone Avenue Shelter Took Business Owners’ Concerns to Heart

The California Supreme Court (CalMatters/File)
4 hours ago

They Were Convicted of Gang Crimes. New CA Supreme Court Rulings Trim Their Sentences

Mike Briggs
4 hours ago

Former Fresno Councilmember and Assemblymember Mike Briggs Dies After Cancer Battle

Search

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Send this to a friend