Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Changing Election Rules Alters Outcomes
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 4 years ago on
December 23, 2020

Share

Periodically, owners of major league sports teams change game rules and in doing so they inevitably affect the games’ outcomes, purposely or not.

Politics are no different. Changing the rules of campaigning, voting and other political procedures affects election results.

Dan Walters

Opinion

We saw an example of that adage this year. Loosening voter registration requirements, allowing or disallowing ballot harvesting and, in some states, shifting from in-person voting to vote-by-mail affected voter turnout, altered the composition of the electorate and thus ultimately had an effect on what or who won or lost.

Obviously, writers of rules — federal and state legislators, mostly — have a motive in changing them to benefit themselves, their parties and their allied interest groups.

That’s why, for instance, the national Democratic Party poured untold millions of dollars into state legislative campaigns. The campaign’s avowed goal was altering the partisan balance of statehouses, now mostly Republican, to affect how congressional districts are redrawn after the 2020 census, but it largely failed.

Hertzberg Apparently Believes That the Change Would Decrease the Chances of a Successful Referendum

Two constitutional amendments introduced in the California Legislature’s newly convened session attest to the continuing desire of politicians to change political rules and thus outcomes.

Senate Constitutional Amendent 1, submitted by Sen. Bob Hertzberg, a Democrat from Van Nuys, would flip how referenda — measures to overturn laws passed by the Legislature — are submitted to voters.

Currently, an interest group opposed to a new law can challenge it by collecting enough signatures to place a referendum on the ballot. Voters are then asked to either validate the new law by voting “yes” or repeal it by voting “no.”

Hertzberg wants a “yes” vote to repeal the new law and a “no” vote to keep the new law in place.

Is the current procedure a little confusing? Yes, particularly since the referendum process is only occasionally used. But it’s doubtful that SCA 1’s change would be less confusing.

Hertzberg apparently believes that the change would decrease the chances of a successful referendum because if voters are somewhat undecided or confused about the underlying issue, they are more likely to vote “no.”

He introduced SCA 1 a month after his landmark law abolishing cash bail for criminal defendants was overturned by a referendum, Proposition 25, sponsored by the bail bond industry. Voters marked nearly 55% of their ballots “no” on Hertzberg’s bail bill.

When You Change Political Rules, You Likely Change the Outcome of the Political Game

Proposition 25 is widely seen as a template for other referenda by business groups adversely affected by laws passed by a liberal Legislature.

Senate Constitutional Amendment 3, offered by Sen. Ben Allen, a Redondo Beach Democrat, would make a huge change in recall elections.

Currently, when enough signatures are collected to seek the recall of an elected official, such as then-Gov. Gray Davis in 2003, the issue is placed before voters in two simultaneous ballot measures. One is on the recall itself and the second is to elect someone to replace the ousted officeholder if the recall is successful.

With 135 candidates on the second ballot, action movie star Arnold Schwarzenegger succeeded Davis with about 48% of the vote.

SCA 3 would maintain two ballots but would automatically place the targeted officeholder on the second ballot as a candidate with a good chance to immediately reclaim the office. In effect, someone could be ousted from office by a majority of voters but then recapture it with an easier-to-achieve plurality vote.

It’s probably not a coincidence that Allen introduced SCA 3 as a campaign to recall Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom seemed to be gaining momentum.

When you change political rules, you likely change the outcome of the political game, just as in football or baseball.

[activecampaign form=19]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

CalFire Shares 2024’s Top Images. See Highlights of Intense Wildfire Season.

DON'T MISS

While Sherrod Motors to Boise, Entz’s Bulldogs Add a Coach, Transfers, Recruits

DON'T MISS

California and Texas Duke It Out for Worst State to Raise a Family

DON'T MISS

Musk Slams ‘Wokepedia’ for Biased Editing, Urges Donation Boycott

DON'T MISS

Explore the Holiday Magic in California’s Death Valley

DON'T MISS

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

DON'T MISS

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

DON'T MISS

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

DON'T MISS

What Is Israel’s US Funded Plan for the Middle East?

DON'T MISS

Caitlin Clark Honored as AP Female Athlete of the Year

UP NEXT

New Decisions Boost California’s Zero-Emission Vehicle Mandate, but Major Hurdles Remain

UP NEXT

The Surprising Sexual Politics of Nicole Kidman’s Kinky ‘Babygirl’

UP NEXT

Tax Loopholes Cost California and Its Cities $107 Billion but Get Little Scrutiny

UP NEXT

24 for 24: GV Wire’s Top Images of 2024

UP NEXT

Did You Know Fresno County Doesn’t Have a Tax Assessor?

UP NEXT

Congress Can Give Us Clean Affordable Energy in 2025

UP NEXT

He Has Prison in His Past. Now He Hopes Law School Is in His Future

UP NEXT

Can New State Regs Resolve California’s Property Insurance Crisis?

UP NEXT

The First New Foreign Policy Challenge for Trump Just Became Clear

UP NEXT

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

Musk Slams ‘Wokepedia’ for Biased Editing, Urges Donation Boycott

14 hours ago

Explore the Holiday Magic in California’s Death Valley

15 hours ago

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

16 hours ago

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

16 hours ago

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

16 hours ago

What Is Israel’s US Funded Plan for the Middle East?

16 hours ago

Caitlin Clark Honored as AP Female Athlete of the Year

17 hours ago

Rams Don’t Dominate, but They’re Mastered Winning Ugly

17 hours ago

What Goes on at Fresno County School Board Meetings? It’s Hard to Tell

17 hours ago

Elaborate Holiday Light Displays Are Making Spirits Bright in a Big Way

18 hours ago

CalFire Shares 2024’s Top Images. See Highlights of Intense Wildfire Season.

CalFire took to social media Tuesday to showcase its most viewed images of 2024, offering a poignant reminder of the year’s challenging wild...

13 hours ago

13 hours ago

CalFire Shares 2024’s Top Images. See Highlights of Intense Wildfire Season.

13 hours ago

While Sherrod Motors to Boise, Entz’s Bulldogs Add a Coach, Transfers, Recruits

14 hours ago

California and Texas Duke It Out for Worst State to Raise a Family

Photo of Elon Musk
14 hours ago

Musk Slams ‘Wokepedia’ for Biased Editing, Urges Donation Boycott

15 hours ago

Explore the Holiday Magic in California’s Death Valley

A vehicle crashed into a home on North Cain Street in Visalia Tuesday morning, causing minor property damage but no injuries, with the unlicensed driver cited at the scene. (Visalia PD)
16 hours ago

Visalia Unlicensed Driver Smashes Into Home. No Injuries Reported.

16 hours ago

Penn State’s Schumacher-Cawley Is 1st Female Coach to Win NCAA Volleyball Title

16 hours ago

Myles Turner Hits Late 3-Pointer, Scores 23 as Pacers Beat Warriors

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend