Share
RENO, Nev. โ A three-member U.S. appeals court panel appeared sympathetic Tuesday to arguments by lawyers for two Nevada churches that say state COVID-19 restrictions treating churches differently than casinos and other secular businesses violate their First Amendment rights.
The 9th Circuit panel in San Francisco heard arguments via video from lawyers for Calvary Chapel Dayton Valley east of Reno and Cavalry Chapel Lone Mountain in Las Vegas who want the appellate court to reverse earlier district court rulings upholding hard attendance caps Gov. Steve Sisolak has set on the size of indoor worship services.
They say churches should be held to the same standards that allow casinos, bars, restaurants and others to operate based on a percentage of their capacity โ currently 25% โ not a hard cap.
โWhat Calvary Chapel Lone Mountain is seeking is equal footing,โ said Sigal Chattah, its lead attorney.
All three justices cited recent U.S. Supreme Court rulings that handed victories to churches waging similar battles over religious freedom in New York and California. Each expressed skepticism about various arguments lawyers for Nevada made to justify disparate treatment of churches and secular businesses.
โI think itโs more than skepticism, I think the Supreme Court has made it very clear when you treat bike repair shops and liquor stores and the like far more favorably than houses of worship, you are not meeting the applicable First Amendment test,โ Justice Mark Bennett said.
Nevada Argued Its Rules Less Strict Than California, New York
Justice Milan Smith added later:
โIt seems to me what they are saying is that you cannot treat houses of worship differently, less advantageously than you do retail businesses and casinos and the like because it is a violation of the First Amendment.โ
In a 5-4 decision in July, the Supreme Court refused the Dayton Valleyโs churchโs request for a temporary order blocking enforcement of Nevadaโs 50-person cap on religious gatherings in effect at that time while its appeal was pending before the 9th Circuit. The church has since asked the high court to reconsider that ruling.
On Nov. 26, the Supreme Court barred New York from enforcing certain limits on attendance at churches and synagogues in areas designated as hard hit by the virus.
On Dec. 3, the high court ordered a lower federal court to reexamine California restrictions on indoor religious services in light of the New York ruling. The stateโs new stay-home order permits outdoor religious services and protests because theyโre constitutionally protected.
The justices threw out a federal district court ruling that rejected a challenge to the limits from Pasadena-based Harvest Rock Church and Harvest International Ministry, which has more than 160 churches across the state.
Nevada Deputy Solicitor General Craig Newby told the 9th Circuit panel Tuesday that Nevada differs from New York and California because restrictions on religious gatherings there were far more strict โ as few as 10 people in zones with high virus spread in New York and an outright ban on any indoor worship services across most of California.
Nevada Churches Sued in May
The circuit panel in San Francisco indicated that at a minimum it likely would follow the lead of the high courtโs California ruling and return the cases to U.S. District Court in Nevada for further review.
Newby said that would be a more appropriate remedy than overturning previous rulings in the lower courts refusing to grant emergency injunctions the churches sought to block the stateโs COVID-19 directives.
Like the case in New York, the specific restrictions at issue in the legal proceedings no longer are in place. In Nevada, the churches sued in May over Sisolakโs directive that capped all indoor religious gatherings at a maximum of 50 people regardless of the churchโs capacity.
On Sept. 30, he established a limit of 250 or 50% of capacity, whichever is less. And on Oct. 24, returned to a cap of 50 people or 25% of capacity, whichever is less.
Lawyers for the Nevada churches say the specific limits are beside the point. Lone Mountain has a fire code capacity of 700. Dayton Valleyโs is 200.
โWhatever directive comes now or in the future, the principal should be equal treatment,โ said David Cortland, a lawyer for the Alliance Defending Freedom representing the Dayton Valley church.
Newby said casinos are an especially different category because they are strictly regulated by the Nevada Gaming Commission, are subject to training requirements and on-site COVID-19 testing and have increased enforcement abilities. He said the nature of church services makes them especially vulnerable to the spread of the virus.
Smith scoffed at that argument.
โI read that in your brief and I couldnโt stop laughing. The reality is, when you have all these people in casinos, theyโre not paying attention to any rules, I donโt care how well it is regulated. So I donโt see how you justify treating religious worse than casinos,โ he said.
RELATED TOPICS:
Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact
19 hours ago
Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US
19 hours ago
Fresno Man Found Dead, Coronerโs Office Seeks Help Finding Family
19 hours ago
Fresno Firefighters Save Dog From Canal and Now Sheโs Ready for Adoption
17 hours ago
Big Brands Spend Just Enough on X to Avoid Muskโs โNaughty Listโ
17 hours ago
Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams
18 hours ago
Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion
19 hours ago
Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact
19 hours ago
Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US
19 hours ago
Fresno Man Found Dead, Coronerโs Office Seeks Help Finding Family
19 hours ago
Fresno Firefighters Save Dog From Canal and Now Sheโs Ready for Adoption
17 hours ago
Big Brands Spend Just Enough on X to Avoid Muskโs โNaughty Listโ
17 hours ago
Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams
18 hours ago
Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion
19 hours ago
Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact
19 hours ago
Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US
19 hours ago
Fresno Man Found Dead, Coronerโs Office Seeks Help Finding Family
19 hours ago
Senate Rebukes Trumpโs Tariffs as Some Republicans Vote to Halt Taxes on Canadian Imports
12 hours ago
Categories

Senate Rebukes Trumpโs Tariffs as Some Republicans Vote to Halt Taxes on Canadian Imports

Supreme Court Sides With the FDA in Its Dispute Over Sweet-Flavored Vaping Products

Trump Announces Sweeping New Tariffs to Promote US Manufacturing, Risking Inflation and Trade Wars

Fresno Firefighters Save Dog From Canal and Now Sheโs Ready for Adoption

Big Brands Spend Just Enough on X to Avoid Muskโs โNaughty Listโ

Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams

Fresno County Sheriffโs Pilot Takes His Last Flight as He Retires After 31 Years of Service

Voice of America Wins in Court, for Now, as Judge Blocks Trump Administration From Firing Staff
