Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Opinion: What Will Tax Increase Advocates Do Now?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 4 years ago on
November 15, 2020

Share

Proposition 15, which would have boosted property taxes on commercial real estate by billions of dollars a year, finally bit the dust last week.

It wasn’t a surprise. Although its advocates — unions, mostly — may cite the COVID-19 pandemic and recession as causes for failure, the measure never polled strongly even before the twin crises struck.

Dan Walters

Opinion

Their pitch was two-fold — schools and local governments need the money and big commercial property owners benefit from an unfair loophole.

The successful counter argument from business opponents was also a two-fer — if Proposition 15 passed, property owners would shift extra taxes to business tenants and their customers, and it would be the first step toward dismantling Proposition 13, California’s iconic and popular property tax limit.

Proposition 15’s rejection creates a dilemma for public employee unions and other spending advocates who ardently believe that despite already having one of the nation’s highest taxation levels, somewhere over 12% of personal income, California governments need much more money.

Those advocates enjoy strong support in the overwhelmingly Democratic Legislature, which could simply raise sales, personal income or corporate tax rates without going to voters. Tax increases will no doubt be introduced when the Legislature reconvenes in December since putting a bill in the hopper is a cheap way for a legislator to show solidarity with unions and other pro-tax factions.

The Top 1% of Taxpayers Generate More Than a Third of the State’s Unrestricted Revenues

However, having enough Democratic legislators to pass new taxes and putting up enough votes for specific levies are not the same thing, particularly if they lack gubernatorial support.

When Gov. Gavin Newsom endorsed Proposition 15, he pointedly said he would not sanction more bites on his fellow high-income Californians or a “wealth tax,” both of which have been floated in the Capitol.

“In a global, mobile economy, now is not the time for the kind of state tax increases on income we saw proposed at the end of this legislative session and I will not sign such proposals into law,” Newsom said.

Newsom’s reference to a “global, mobile economy” implies awareness that the state budget is already very dependent on taxing incomes of the wealthy. In fact, the top 1% of taxpayers — about 150,000 in a state of 40 million — generate more than a third of the state’s unrestricted revenues. Hitting them up for more could encourage tax avoidance, such as freezing taxable income from capital gains, or even fleeing to other states.

If Newsom and the Legislature won’t act, would advocates risk another a ballot measure in 2022? The California School Boards Association and its allies had wanted to put a $15 billion personal and corporate income tax hike on this year’s ballot, but bowed to pressure from Proposition 15’s advocates, particularly the California Teachers Association, to not compete.

Will Proposition 15’s Defeat Cool the Jets of Tax Increase Advocates?

“After conducting a significant amount of polling and analysis, we have determined that having two measures on the same ballot that — at least in part — provide funding for public schools, risked a scenario where our measure would come up short,” California School Boards Association CEO Vernon Billy said last December as his group backed off.

An extra $15 billion a year would raise California’s per-pupil spending to the national average on the way to the education community’s goal of entering the top ranks of states in school support, which would require another $15 billion per year.

Those are big numbers and don’t take into account demands from health, social welfare and early childhood education advocates for billions more they want to expand services.

Does Proposition 15’s defeat cool the jets of tax increase advocates, or spur them to greater efforts?

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

[activecampaign form=19]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Progress Is Made on a Huge Fire North of Los Angeles While New Fires Erupt in Southern California

DON'T MISS

Fresno DUI Suspect Arrested After Crash Kills Pedestrian, Injures Another

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Sex Offender Arrested Fleeing on Motorcycle With Drugs

DON'T MISS

As the Fresno GOP Turns: Cease and Desist Letter Sent to Rebel Leader

DON'T MISS

When Did Fresno EOC Finances Start Their Downhill Plunge?

DON'T MISS

Trump Signs Executive Order on Developing Artificial Intelligence ‘Free From Ideological Bias’

DON'T MISS

Trump Pardons Anti-Abortion Activists Convicted for Blocking Abortion Clinic Entrances

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Seek Public’s Help in Star Pro Smog Burglary Investigation

DON'T MISS

SZA to Join Kendrick Lamar as a Guest During Super Bowl Halftime Performance

DON'T MISS

California Approves $2.5B for State Response to Los Angeles-Area Fires

UP NEXT

LA Fires Add Tricky New Wrinkle to Trump-Newsom Feud

UP NEXT

Much of the Damage from the LA Fires Could Have Been Averted

UP NEXT

Even This Year Is the Best Time Ever to Be Alive

UP NEXT

Voices for Justice: Diverse Figures Unite in Support of Palestine

UP NEXT

California Housing Crisis Will Get Worse as LA Fires Destroy Homes

UP NEXT

Gov. Newsom, Mayor Bass Targeted in Wildfire Witch Hunt

UP NEXT

As Crazy as It Sounds, Trump’s Approach to Foreign Policy Could Work

UP NEXT

The Biden Presidency: Four Illusions, Four Deceptions

UP NEXT

Can Democrats Be the Party of the Future Again?

UP NEXT

California’s Battle Over Taxing Multinational Corporations Heats Up Again

As the Fresno GOP Turns: Cease and Desist Letter Sent to Rebel Leader

10 hours ago

When Did Fresno EOC Finances Start Their Downhill Plunge?

10 hours ago

Trump Signs Executive Order on Developing Artificial Intelligence ‘Free From Ideological Bias’

10 hours ago

Trump Pardons Anti-Abortion Activists Convicted for Blocking Abortion Clinic Entrances

11 hours ago

Fresno Police Seek Public’s Help in Star Pro Smog Burglary Investigation

12 hours ago

SZA to Join Kendrick Lamar as a Guest During Super Bowl Halftime Performance

13 hours ago

California Approves $2.5B for State Response to Los Angeles-Area Fires

13 hours ago

Senate Confirms Ratcliffe to Lead the CIA, Giving Trump His Second Cabinet Member

13 hours ago

Madera County Two-Vehicle Crash Claims Winton Woman’s Life

14 hours ago

Is Matthew Stafford Retiring? Rams Coach Wants Answer ‘Sooner Than Later’

14 hours ago

Progress Is Made on a Huge Fire North of Los Angeles While New Fires Erupt in Southern California

LOS ANGELES — Evacuation orders were lifted Thursday for tens of thousands as firefighters with air support slowed the spread of a huge wild...

8 hours ago

Apparatus sits on Sepulveda Blvd. as fire burns along Interstate 405, Thursday, Jan. 23, 2025, in Los Angeles. (AP/Mark J. Terrill)
8 hours ago

Progress Is Made on a Huge Fire North of Los Angeles While New Fires Erupt in Southern California

A Fresno driver, Marcelo Gaytan, 56 was arrested for DUI after fatally striking a 98-year-old woman and critically injuring an 82-year-old man in a pedestrian collision. (Fresno PD)
9 hours ago

Fresno DUI Suspect Arrested After Crash Kills Pedestrian, Injures Another

Benny Brusso, 56, was arrested Thursday after fleeing from deputies on a motorcycle and found to be a registered sex offender with drugs and copper wire in his possession. (GV Wire File)
9 hours ago

Fresno County Sex Offender Arrested Fleeing on Motorcycle With Drugs

10 hours ago

As the Fresno GOP Turns: Cease and Desist Letter Sent to Rebel Leader

10 hours ago

When Did Fresno EOC Finances Start Their Downhill Plunge?

President Donald Trump signs an executive order in the Oval Office of the White House, Thursday, Jan. 23, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Ben Curtis)
10 hours ago

Trump Signs Executive Order on Developing Artificial Intelligence ‘Free From Ideological Bias’

11 hours ago

Trump Pardons Anti-Abortion Activists Convicted for Blocking Abortion Clinic Entrances

12 hours ago

Fresno Police Seek Public’s Help in Star Pro Smog Burglary Investigation

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend