Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Appeals Court Keeps Flynn Case Alive, Won't Order Dismissal
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 4 years ago on
August 31, 2020

Share

WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court in Washington declined Monday to order the dismissal of the Michael Flynn prosecution, permitting a judge to scrutinize the Justice Department’s request to dismiss its case against President Donald Trump’s former national security adviser.

The decision keeps the matter at least temporarily alive and rebuffs efforts by both Flynn’s lawyers and the Justice Department to force the prosecution to be dropped without any further inquiry from the judge, who has for months declined to dismiss it. The ruling represents the latest development in a criminal case that has taken unusual twists and turns over the last year and prompted a separation of powers clash between a veteran federal judge and the Trump administration.

The conflict arose in May when the Justice Department moved to dismiss the prosecution despite Flynn’s own guilty plea to lying to the FBI about his contacts with the Russian ambassador during the presidential transition period. But U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan, signaling his skepticism at the government’s unusual motion, refused to immediately grant the request and instead appointed a retired federal judge to argue against the Justice Department’s position.

His lawyers then sought to bypass Sullivan and obtain a order from the federal appeals court that would have required the judge to immediately force the judge to dismiss the case.

At issue before the court was whether Sullivan could be forced to grant the Justice Department’s dismissal request without even holding a hearing to scrutinize the basis for the motion.

“We have no trouble answering that question in the negative,” the court wrote in an unsigned opinion for the eight judges in the majority.

In a concurring opinion, U.S. District Judge Thomas Griffith wrote that the court’s opinion did not involve the merits of the Justice Department’s prosecution of Flynn or its decision to abandon the case. Rather, he said the question was a much more simple one.

“Today we reach the unexceptional yet important conclusion that a court of appeals should stay its hand and allow the district court to finish its work rather than hear a challenge to a decision not yet made,” Griffith said. “That is a policy the federal courts have followed since the beginning of the Republic.”

The Flynn Prosecution Was a Signature Criminal Case in Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s Investigation

He said it was very possible that Sullivan could wind up granting the Justice Department’s dismissal request and that it would be “highly unusual if it did not, given the Executive’s constitutional prerogative to direct and control prosecutions and the district court’s limited discretion” in cases that prosecutors want dropped.

Two judges, Neomi Rao and Karen LeCraft Henderson, each wrote dissenting opinions arguing that Sullivan had overstepped his bounds by keeping alive a case that the Justice Department sought to have dismissed.

The Flynn prosecution was a signature criminal case in special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into ties between the 2016 Trump campaign and Russia. Flynn was the only person charged in the Mueller investigation who had served in the White House and he agreed months into the investigation to cooperate with the authorities in hopes of receiving a lighter sentence.

He was questioned by the FBI at the White House, just days after Trump’s inauguration, about his conversations with the then-Russian ambassador to the U.S. pertaining to sanctions that had just been imposed by the Obama administration for election interference. The conversation alarmed law enforcement and intelligence officials who were already investigating whether the Trump campaign had coordinated with Russia to sway the presidential election in Trump’s favor. They were puzzled by the White House’s public insistence that Flynn and the diplomat had not discussed sanctions.

But the Justice Department argued in May that the FBI had insufficient basis to interrogate Flynn about that conversation, which Attorney General William Barr has described as fully appropriate for an incoming national security adviser to have had.

DON'T MISS

NFL Trade Deadline: Lions Get Za’Darius Smith, Cowboys Add Jonathan Mingo

DON'T MISS

Palestinians in Gaza Fear Neither Candidate in US Election Will Help Them

DON'T MISS

Pennsylvania Election Officials Weighing in on Challenges to 4,300 Mail Ballot Applications

DON'T MISS

Ukrainian Troops Have Engaged With North Korean Units for the 1st Time in Russia, an Official Says

DON'T MISS

Clovis Unified Candidate Vue Says Voicemail Claiming Fraud Is Defamatory

DON'T MISS

Middle East Latest: Dozens Killed in Gaza as Israel Says It Targeted a Weapons Facility

DON'T MISS

Dak Prescott Likely out 4+ Games as Cowboys Place QB on IR With Hamstring Injury

DON'T MISS

Tropical Storm Rafael Chugs Past Jamaica as Cuba Prepares for Another Hurricane Hit

DON'T MISS

The Latest: Trump and Harris Cede Stage to Voters Who’ll Also Decide Control of House and Senate

DON'T MISS

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Rallies on Election Day as Economy Remains Solid

UP NEXT

North Korea’s Long-Range Missile Test Signals Its Improved, Potential Capability to Attack US

UP NEXT

Visalia Rollerblader Suffered Major Injuries After Being Struck by Vehicle

UP NEXT

Fresno County Man Indicted for Possessing Stolen Guns

UP NEXT

On Elon Musk’s X, Dems Are an Endangered Species While GOP Goes Viral

UP NEXT

New Vehicles, Face Paint and a 1,200-Foot Fall: The US Army Prepares for War With China

UP NEXT

CNN Bars Pro-Trump Guest After His ‘Beeper’ Remark to Mehdi Hasan

UP NEXT

LGBTQ Supporters Drown Out Westboro Baptists’ Anti-Gay Message in Fresno

UP NEXT

The ‘Black Insurrectionist’ Was Actually White. The Deception Did Not Stop There

UP NEXT

Washington Post Says It Will Stop Endorsing Presidential Candidates

UP NEXT

What Happened When a Barber Told Trump About His $15,000 Electric Bill

Ukrainian Troops Have Engaged With North Korean Units for the 1st Time in Russia, an Official Says

50 mins ago

Clovis Unified Candidate Vue Says Voicemail Claiming Fraud Is Defamatory

57 mins ago

Middle East Latest: Dozens Killed in Gaza as Israel Says It Targeted a Weapons Facility

58 mins ago

Dak Prescott Likely out 4+ Games as Cowboys Place QB on IR With Hamstring Injury

1 hour ago

Tropical Storm Rafael Chugs Past Jamaica as Cuba Prepares for Another Hurricane Hit

1 hour ago

The Latest: Trump and Harris Cede Stage to Voters Who’ll Also Decide Control of House and Senate

1 hour ago

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Rallies on Election Day as Economy Remains Solid

1 hour ago

When Polls Close in Battleground States on Election Day

1 hour ago

Jason Kelce Apologizes for Fan Confrontation, Vows to ‘Treat People With Respect’

2 hours ago

Curry’s Return Ignites Warriors in Victory Over Wizards

2 hours ago

NFL Trade Deadline: Lions Get Za’Darius Smith, Cowboys Add Jonathan Mingo

DETROIT – The Detroit Lions got their edge rusher. The injury-plagued Dallas Cowboys added a receiver. Other teams are still trying to...

39 mins ago

39 mins ago

NFL Trade Deadline: Lions Get Za’Darius Smith, Cowboys Add Jonathan Mingo

40 mins ago

Palestinians in Gaza Fear Neither Candidate in US Election Will Help Them

47 mins ago

Pennsylvania Election Officials Weighing in on Challenges to 4,300 Mail Ballot Applications

50 mins ago

Ukrainian Troops Have Engaged With North Korean Units for the 1st Time in Russia, an Official Says

57 mins ago

Clovis Unified Candidate Vue Says Voicemail Claiming Fraud Is Defamatory

58 mins ago

Middle East Latest: Dozens Killed in Gaza as Israel Says It Targeted a Weapons Facility

1 hour ago

Dak Prescott Likely out 4+ Games as Cowboys Place QB on IR With Hamstring Injury

1 hour ago

Tropical Storm Rafael Chugs Past Jamaica as Cuba Prepares for Another Hurricane Hit

Search

Send this to a friend