Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Resurrection of Measure P? Ruling Gives Parks Tax New Hope
gvw_david_taub
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 4 years ago on
July 1, 2020

Share

A court ruling regarding a San Francisco tax measure may breathe new life in Fresno’s 2018 sales tax measure for parks.

As Dominic Fracassa of the San Francisco Chronicle reported, the California First District Court of Appeal affirmed a lower-court decision that a tax measure for a specific purpose needs only a majority vote to pass instead of the two-thirds threshold — when placed on the ballot through the petition process.

While the ruling applies specifically to November 2018’s Measure C in San Francisco, the same concept could apply to Fresno’s Measure P.

Fresno voters approved the three-eighths cent sales tax increase with nearly 53% of the vote, but when it failed to garner two-thirds, the city declared that it had failed.

Measure P was estimated to raise $38 million a year (prior to COVID-19) for city parks, trails, and related programs. The tax would last for 30 years.

Because the city ruled Measure P did not pass, the sales tax did not increase, and no funds have been collected.

Advocates for Measure P sued, lost in civil court, and appealed. That case is being heard by the Fifth District Court of Appeal, based in Fresno.

Similarities in San Francisco, Fresno cases

Like Measure P, San Francisco’s Measure C would increase taxes for a specific purpose, mainly for homeless services. Both measures were placed on the ballot by petition, as opposed to a government agency (i.e. a city council) voting to place it in front of voters.

And, that’s where the crux of the argument lies. Through changes to the state Constitution by Propositions 13 and 218, any tax for a specific purpose needed two-thirds approval for passage.

A 2017 state Supreme Court ruling, California Cannabis Coalition vs. City of Upland, ruled that such rules only applied to tax questions placed on the ballot by the government, not the people.

However, Upland dealt with only one specific aspect, namely the timing of an election. It did not rule on the threshold needed — majority vs. two-thirds — to pass.

San Francisco Court: Only Majority Vote Needed

In the San Francisco case, the appeal court found that Proposition 13, the landmark 1978 initiative that mainly restricted increasing property taxes, did not intend to restrict voting thresholds.

“We find in the official ballot pamphlet nothing to support an inference that the voters adopting Proposition 13 intended to limit their own ability to raise local taxes by initiative, and to adopt such initiatives by majority vote,” Justice Alison Tucher wrote for the 3-0 appellate panel.

“We will not apply the two-thirds vote requirement to local citizens’ initiatives,” the 29-page ruling stated.

The court also found that Proposition 218, passed in 1996, also applied only to tax measures placed by “local government.”

Still Likely to Head to Supreme Court

Last September, Fresno County Superior Court Judge Kimberly Gaab ruled that Measure P did not pass, but indicated that the issue would eventually be resolved by the state Supreme Court or Legislature.

Fresno BHC appealed that decision to the Fifth District Appellate Court, where the parties are now exchanging briefs. The court ruled against consolidating the cases but agreed to consider them together.

Attorneys for Fresno BHC said they were not authorized to respond, referring the matter to their client. Fresno BHC did not respond to GV Wire’s request for comment before publication of this story.

The city, through spokesman Mark Standriff, said it doesn’t discuss ongoing legal issues.

Measure P Opponents Concerned

Michael Der Manouel Jr., a Fresno political analyst and Measure P opponent, is concerned about how the recent court ruling may advance the tax measure.

I think if the appeal court rulings is upheld and applied retroactively to Fresno’s Measure P and invalidates the election result, it will be a grave injustice against the voters of Fresno,” Der Manouel said.

He said the No on P campaign was designed to prevent two-thirds passage.

“If that target is moved after the election is done and certified, clearly it is unfair,” Der Manouel said.

(Disclosure: GV Wire Publisher Darius Assemi opposed Measure P and contributed to the opponents’ efforts.)

Read the San Francisco Appeal Court Ruling



SF DCA Ruling A158645 (Text)

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Unlocking the Secrets to Fresno State’s Superb Baseball Season

DON'T MISS

‘This Is How to Improve Reading Proficiency. We Just Have Execute It’: FUSD Board President

DON'T MISS

Does Dyer Support (or Endorse) Bredefeld for Supervisor?

DON'T MISS

Get a 3D First Look at Merced’s High-Speed Rail Station Design

DON'T MISS

California Court to Decide on Transgender Ballot Measure Wording

DON'T MISS

Rare House Vote Sees Ukraine, Israel Aid Advance as Democrats Join Republicans

DON'T MISS

Full Jury and 6 Alternates Seated in Trump’s Hush Money Trial

DON'T MISS

Wired Wednesday: How High Will the Price of Gold & Silver Go?

DON'T MISS

How 4/20 Grew From Humble Roots to Marijuana’s High Holiday

DON'T MISS

Taylor Swift Drops 15 New Songs on Double Album, ‘The Tortured Poets Department: The Anthology’

UP NEXT

Does Dyer Support (or Endorse) Bredefeld for Supervisor?

UP NEXT

Get a 3D First Look at Merced’s High-Speed Rail Station Design

UP NEXT

California Court to Decide on Transgender Ballot Measure Wording

UP NEXT

Rare House Vote Sees Ukraine, Israel Aid Advance as Democrats Join Republicans

UP NEXT

Full Jury and 6 Alternates Seated in Trump’s Hush Money Trial

UP NEXT

Wired Wednesday: How High Will the Price of Gold & Silver Go?

UP NEXT

How 4/20 Grew From Humble Roots to Marijuana’s High Holiday

UP NEXT

Taylor Swift Drops 15 New Songs on Double Album, ‘The Tortured Poets Department: The Anthology’

UP NEXT

Lamborghini’s Race Evolution: From Tractors to the Track

UP NEXT

Biden Administration Restricts Oil and Gas Leasing in 13 Million Acres of Alaska’s Petroleum Reserve

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Get a 3D First Look at Merced’s High-Speed Rail Station Design

2 hours ago

California Court to Decide on Transgender Ballot Measure Wording

2 hours ago

Rare House Vote Sees Ukraine, Israel Aid Advance as Democrats Join Republicans

4 hours ago

Full Jury and 6 Alternates Seated in Trump’s Hush Money Trial

4 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: How High Will the Price of Gold & Silver Go?

Video /

5 hours ago

How 4/20 Grew From Humble Roots to Marijuana’s High Holiday

6 hours ago

Taylor Swift Drops 15 New Songs on Double Album, ‘The Tortured Poets Department: The Anthology’

6 hours ago

Lamborghini’s Race Evolution: From Tractors to the Track

6 hours ago

Biden Administration Restricts Oil and Gas Leasing in 13 Million Acres of Alaska’s Petroleum Reserve

6 hours ago

Logan Webb’s Seven Dominant Innings Help Giants Blank Diamondbacks

6 hours ago

Unlocking the Secrets to Fresno State’s Superb Baseball Season

So, how has the Fresno State baseball team positioned itself atop the Mountain West Conference? San Jose State at Fresno State Friday: 6:05...

25 mins ago

25 mins ago

Unlocking the Secrets to Fresno State’s Superb Baseball Season

37 mins ago

‘This Is How to Improve Reading Proficiency. We Just Have Execute It’: FUSD Board President

1 hour ago

Does Dyer Support (or Endorse) Bredefeld for Supervisor?

2 hours ago

Get a 3D First Look at Merced’s High-Speed Rail Station Design

2 hours ago

California Court to Decide on Transgender Ballot Measure Wording

4 hours ago

Rare House Vote Sees Ukraine, Israel Aid Advance as Democrats Join Republicans

4 hours ago

Full Jury and 6 Alternates Seated in Trump’s Hush Money Trial

Video /
5 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: How High Will the Price of Gold & Silver Go?

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend