Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Supreme Court Strikes Down Louisiana Abortion Clinic Law
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
June 29, 2020

Share

WASHINGTON โ€” The Supreme Court on Monday struck down a Louisiana law regulating abortion clinics, reasserting a commitment to abortion rights over fierce opposition from dissenting conservative justices in the first big abortion case of the Trump era.

Chief Justice John Roberts joined with his four more liberal colleagues in ruling that the law requiring doctors who perform abortions have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals violates the abortion right the court first announced in the landmark Roe v. Wade decision in 1973.
Chief Justice John Roberts joined with his four more liberal colleagues in ruling that the law requiring doctors who perform abortions have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals violates the abortion right the court first announced in the landmark Roe v. Wade decision in 1973.
In two previous abortion cases, Roberts had favored restrictions.
The Louisiana law is virtually identical to one in Texas that the court struck down in 2016.
โ€œThe result in this case is controlled by our decision four years ago invalidating a nearly identical Texas law,โ€ Roberts wrote, although he did not join the opinion written by Justice Stephen Breyer for the other liberals.
In dissent, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote, โ€œToday a majority of the Court perpetuates its ill-founded abortion jurisprudence by enjoining a perfectly legitimate state law and doing so without jurisdiction.โ€
President Donald Trumpโ€™s two appointees, Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, were in dissent, along with Justice Samuel Alito. The presence of the new justices is what fueled hopes among abortion opponents, and fears on the other side, that the Supreme Court would be more likely to uphold restrictions.
Nancy Northup, president and CEO of the Center for Reproductive Rights, said Mondayโ€™s decision by no means ends the struggle over abortion rights in legislatures and the courts.
โ€œWeโ€™re relieved that the Louisiana law has been blocked today but weโ€™re concerned about tomorrow. With this win, the clinics in Louisiana can stay open to serve the one million women of reproductive age in the state. But the Courtโ€™s decision could embolden states to pass even more restrictive laws when clarity is needed if abortion rights are to be protected,โ€ Northup said.
Photo of the Supreme Court building
The Supreme Court is seen in Washington, early Monday, June 15, 2020. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)

Robertsโ€™ Vote Was a Bit of a Surprise

Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of the anti-abortion Susan B. Anthony List, said, โ€œTodayโ€™s ruling is a bitter disappointment. It demonstrates once again the failure of the Supreme Court to allow the American people to protect the well-being of women from the tentacles of a brutal and profit-seeking abortion industry.โ€
A trial judge had said the law would not provide health benefits to women and would leave only one clinic open in Louisiana, in New Orleans. That would make it too hard for women to get an abortion, in violation of the Constitution, the judge ruled.
But the appeals court in New Orleans rejected the judgeโ€™s findings and upheld the law in 2018, doubting that any clinics would have to close and saying the doctors had not tried hard enough to establish relationships with local hospitals.
The clinics filed an emergency appeal at the Supreme Court, asking that the law be blocked while the justices evaluated the case.
Early last year, Roberts joined with the four liberal members of the court to grant that request and keep the law on hold.
Robertsโ€™ vote was a bit of a surprise because he voted in the Texas case to uphold the clinic restrictions. It may have reflected his new role since Justice Anthony Kennedyโ€™s retirement as the courtโ€™s swing justice, his concern about the court being perceived as a partisan institution and respect for a prior decision of the court, even one he disagreed with. Roberts didnโ€™t write anything explaining his position at the time, but he had never before cast a vote on the side of abortion rights.
The regulations at issue in Louisiana are distinct from other state laws making their way through court challenges that would ban abortions early in a pregnancy. Those include bans on abortion once a fetal heartbeat is detected, as early as 6 weeks, and the almost total ban passed in Alabama.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Reps. Costa, Gray Propose Bill to Address Critical Doctor Shortage in Rural Areas

UP NEXT

Lakers Hold Off Rockets With 6 3-Pointers Apiece From Dorian Finney-Smith, Gabe Vincent

Inside a $17 Billion Maintenance Backlog Plaguing Californiaโ€™s Universities

53 minutes ago

Progress Picks Up on Well Registration Efforts Among Kings County Landowners

53 minutes ago

Reps. Costa, Gray Propose Bill to Address Critical Doctor Shortage in Rural Areas

Two San Joaquin Valley congressional representatives have introduced a bill that could help address the vast shortage of doctors in the regi...

7 minutes ago

7 minutes ago

Reps. Costa, Gray Propose Bill to Address Critical Doctor Shortage in Rural Areas

The Kansas City Chiefs kickoff to the Philadelphia Eagles at the start of the NFL Super Bowl 59 football game, Sunday, Feb. 9, 2025, in New Orleans. (AP File)
41 minutes ago

Hereโ€™s How the New NFL Rules on Kickoffs and Overtime Will Work

Yakista Ceeblaj Lor is Valley Crime Stoppers' Most Wanted Person of the Day for April 2, 2025. (Valley Crimes Stoppers)
53 minutes ago

Valley Crime Stoppersโ€™ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Yakista Ceeblaj Lor

53 minutes ago

Inside a $17 Billion Maintenance Backlog Plaguing Californiaโ€™s Universities

53 minutes ago

Progress Picks Up on Well Registration Efforts Among Kings County Landowners

58 minutes ago

Webb Pitches 7 Strong Innings as Giants Beat Astros

Golden State Warriors guard Stephen Curry (30) reacts in the second half of an NBA basketball game against the Memphis Grizzlies Tuesday, April 1, 2025, in Memphis, Tenn. (AP/Brandon Dill)
1 hour ago

Curry Drops 52 as Warriors Beat Grizzlies, Move into Fifth in West

Los Angeles Dodgers' Mookie Betts hits a two-run home run against the Atlanta Braves during the sixth inning of a baseball game Tuesday, April 1, 2025, in, Los Angeles. (AP/Kevork Djansezian)
1 hour ago

Dodgers Extend Perfect Start Behind May and Bettsโ€™ Heroics

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend