Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Eviction Protection Bill Will Trigger Commercial Mortgage Crisis: Opponents
TLBBHMAP3-U010ALB5ANM-348f959abae2-512-300x300-1
By Jim Jakobs, Digital Producer
Published 5 years ago on
May 29, 2020

Share

A state bill would enact a moratorium on commercial evictions for small businesses and nonprofits during the COVID-19 state of emergency.

It just passed the Senate Judiciary Committee and will be heard in appropriations in June.

Commercial real estate interests say Senate Bill 939 trades a short-term business revenue problem for a long-term commercial property foreclosure crisis.

Rex S. Hime, president/CEO of the California Business Properties Association says, “SB 939 seeks to reduce rent amounts paid by leasees, but does nothing to reduce the mortgage payment still owed by the property owner.”

State Sen. Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco) is one of the bill’s authors. He says, “California faces the very real prospect of a mass extinction event for small businesses and nonprofits.”

SB 939

Along with a moratorium on commercial evictions, SB 939 would allow tenants in the hospitality sector to renegotiate a commercial lease if they have lost over 40% of their revenue or if they will operate at 25% reduced capacity due to COVID-19-related social distancing requirements.

“While many landlords are working with their tenants and doing the right thing by renegotiating rents, others are demanding full rent — and even increasing rent — which will lead to closures and bankruptcies.” — State Sen. Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco)

SB 939’s lease renegotiation provisions are not applicable for publicly owned companies or businesses owned by publicly-owned companies. It is also not applicable to large privately-owned companies — only small businesses. If the landlord and tenant cannot come to a new lease agreement, the tenant may end the lease with no penalty.

The law would be in effect until the end of 2021, or two months after the state of emergency ends — whichever is later.

Arguments For

According to Wiener, most businesses are bound by leases negotiated before the COVID-19 pandemic and stay-at-home orders. He says even the most successful businesses are suffering due to severe revenue loss that is likely to continue.

SB 939 will allow hospitality businesses to survive by letting them renegotiate their leases with landlords to find a mutually agreeable set of terms.

“Mass closures would undermine our economic recovery, keep unemployment high, harm our neighborhoods, and damage our social safety net,” Wiener said. “While many landlords are working with their tenants and doing the right thing by renegotiating rents, others are demanding full rent — and even increasing rent — which will lead to closures and bankruptcies.”

Wiener’s office says most businesses are bound by leases negotiated before the COVID-19 pandemic.

[covid-19-tracker]

Arguments Against

“Understand this bill applies to all commercial leases in the state of California – not just restaurants,” Hime said. “It would mandate delayed rent for more than a year, in addition to allowing restaurants, bars, and nightclubs to break a lease, regardless of how much money a property owner has invested in the property for that business.”

Hime says when a tenant moves in, a  property owner will invest upfront money to get the space built-out to the tenant’s specifications. That upfront investment is then paid down over the term of the lease. Hime believes this bill short-circuits that agreement and shifts the full burden onto the property owner.

“SB 939 seeks to reduce rent amounts paid by leasees, but does nothing to reduce the mortgage payment still owed by the property owner.” — Rex S. Hime, president/CEO, California Business Properties Association

Hime also argues, “Nobody wants an empty building. And trying to find new tenants is far more costly than finding creative ways to keep current tenants.”

State Sen. Andreas Borgeas (R-Fresno) opposes SB 939. He says he’s supportive of protections for commercial tenants and has been a staunch advocate for protecting small businesses. He says that SB 939 only addresses “half the problem.”

The California Business Properties Association says several other bills in the Legislature recognize that business renters and property owners must both be helped.

Commercial Mortgage Crisis?

The CBPA argues property owners and tenants are negatively impacted by the COVID-19 statewide shelter in place orders.

“Instead of proposing a positive and balanced approach that recognizes that, it forces one business to float the expenses of another business for more than a year,” the association said in a statement.  “As the state reopens, property owners do not want empty spaces; the state inserting itself into private agreements will prolong the amount of time needed to recover and won’t help tenants as it will weaken the financial health of the properties where they are located.”

Hime said that if the bill becomes law “it will trigger a commercial mortgage crisis.”

Next Steps

CBPA tells GV Wire it has offered amendments for the bill.

“The author has been polite and accessible and has listened to our concerns and the concerns of other legislators expressed in committee, but that input is not reflected in the language of the bill,” the CBPA said in an email.

 

 

DON'T MISS

Merced Police Chief: Local Sexual Assault Exams ‘Worth’ Higher Cost

DON'T MISS

Anjelah Johnson-Reyes to Headline Chukchansi’s Summer Series with ‘Family Reunion Tour’

DON'T MISS

Sue or Hold Back? The University of California Does Both as It Faces Trump’s Wrath

DON'T MISS

Central Unified Takes Additional Steps To Protect Undocumented Students

DON'T MISS

Americans Trade Michelin Stars for Mac and Cheese

DON'T MISS

Dueling Protests Clash at Fresno Tesla Dealership

DON'T MISS

Hamas Says It Accepts New Gaza Ceasefire Proposal but Israel Makes Counter-Offer

DON'T MISS

Andrew Tate’s Ex-Girlfriend Accuses Him of Sexual Assault and Battery in New Lawsuit

DON'T MISS

Protesters Rebelling Against Elon Musk’s Purge of US Government Swarm Tesla Showrooms

DON'T MISS

Plastics Are Seeping Into Farm Fields, Food and Eventually Human Bodies

UP NEXT

Top Vaccine Official Resigns From FDA, Criticizes RFK Jr. for Promoting Misinformation, Lies

UP NEXT

California Food Banks Brace for Funding Cuts, and Not Only From the Trump Administration

UP NEXT

Cal State Automatically Admitting High School Students With Good Grades

UP NEXT

California Democratic Lawmaker Exaggerated His Record as a Police Officer

UP NEXT

Utah Becomes the First State to Ban Fluoride in Public Drinking Water

UP NEXT

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Slips Following Updates on Inflation and US Shoppers

UP NEXT

US Consumers Remained Cautious About Spending Last Month as Inflation Ticked Higher

UP NEXT

Wilmer Flores’ 3-Run Homer in the 9th Inning Propels Giants to Victory Over Reds

UP NEXT

Trump Challenges California on Transgender Parental Notification

UP NEXT

Fresno Mayor Praises a State Bill That Would Speed In-Fill Housing

Central Unified Takes Additional Steps To Protect Undocumented Students

20 hours ago

Americans Trade Michelin Stars for Mac and Cheese

21 hours ago

Dueling Protests Clash at Fresno Tesla Dealership

1 day ago

Hamas Says It Accepts New Gaza Ceasefire Proposal but Israel Makes Counter-Offer

2 days ago

Andrew Tate’s Ex-Girlfriend Accuses Him of Sexual Assault and Battery in New Lawsuit

2 days ago

Protesters Rebelling Against Elon Musk’s Purge of US Government Swarm Tesla Showrooms

2 days ago

Plastics Are Seeping Into Farm Fields, Food and Eventually Human Bodies

2 days ago

Myanmar’s Earthquake Death Toll Jumps to 1,644 as More Bodies Are Recovered From the Rubble

2 days ago

Top Vaccine Official Resigns From FDA, Criticizes RFK Jr. for Promoting Misinformation, Lies

2 days ago

If You Want to Ski Affordably Next Season, Buy Now

2 days ago

Merced Police Chief: Local Sexual Assault Exams ‘Worth’ Higher Cost

Last year, The Merced FOCUS reported that for the first time in over a decade, a crucial service for survivors of sexual assault would be of...

19 hours ago

19 hours ago

Merced Police Chief: Local Sexual Assault Exams ‘Worth’ Higher Cost

19 hours ago

Anjelah Johnson-Reyes to Headline Chukchansi’s Summer Series with ‘Family Reunion Tour’

20 hours ago

Sue or Hold Back? The University of California Does Both as It Faces Trump’s Wrath

20 hours ago

Central Unified Takes Additional Steps To Protect Undocumented Students

21 hours ago

Americans Trade Michelin Stars for Mac and Cheese

1 day ago

Dueling Protests Clash at Fresno Tesla Dealership

2 days ago

Hamas Says It Accepts New Gaza Ceasefire Proposal but Israel Makes Counter-Offer

2 days ago

Andrew Tate’s Ex-Girlfriend Accuses Him of Sexual Assault and Battery in New Lawsuit

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend