Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Wildfire Victims Fear They'll Be the Last Ones Paid by PG&E
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
February 26, 2020

Share

SAN FRANCISCO — A $13.5 billion settlement between victims of California’s catastrophic wildfires and the utility blamed for causing them was supposed to bring some peace and hope to people still reeling from the devastation.

“How is it in any way fair that the actual victims of this fire, or any of the fires, are put at the very, very bottom of the priority list.” Michelle Barker, 54, in a recent letter to U.S Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali
Instead, the deal has sparked confusion, resentment, suspicion and despair as the victims, government agencies, and lawyers grapple for their piece of the pie.
More than 81,000 have filed claims to the settlement fund, setting the stage for a potential scrum as Pacific Gas & Electric scrambles to emerge from one of the most complex bankruptcy cases in U.S. history by June 30.
“How is it in any way fair that the actual victims of this fire, or any of the fires, are put at the very, very bottom of the priority list,” wrote Michelle Barker, 54, in a recent letter to U.S Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali, who is overseeing the settlement. Barker lost her home to the 2018 fire that wiped out Paradise, California.
The tensions may boil over during a hearing Wednesday focusing on whether federal and state agencies are entitled to tap the fund to recoup any of the $4 billion they doled out after the wildfires. Health chain Adventist Health is also seeking at least $1 billion for losses from its heavily damaged hospital in Paradise, and lawyers could try to take up to a third.
Photo of the aftermath of the Camp Fire in Paradise, Ca.
FILE – This Nov. 15, 2018, aerial file photo shows the remains of residences leveled by the Camp wildfire in Paradise, Calif. Pacific Gas & Electric and a group of insurers say they have reached an $11 billion settlement to cover most of the claims from the 2017 and 2018 wildfires in California. The utility said in a statement Friday, Sept. 13, that the tentative agreement covers 85% of the insurance claims, including a fire that decimated the town of Paradise. (AP Photo/Noah Berger, File)

A Government Takeover Would Likely Cause the Company’s Stock to Drop

Victims are also upset that half the settlement, or $6.75 billion, would be paid in stock from PG&E, the company responsible for ruining their lives.
The stock payment may prove a clever strategy, said San Francisco bankruptcy attorney Michael Sweet, because that could make it more difficult for Gov. Gavin Newsom to follow through on threats of a government-backed takeover if PG&E doesn’t make reforms.
A government takeover would likely cause the company’s stock to drop, further diminishing the value of the victims’ settlement.
“They are turning the victims into human shields,” Sweet said. “You only go into bankruptcy because there isn’t enough to go around for everyone.”
Barker, who lost her Paradise home, is among dozens making passionate pleas to Montali asking him to rework a deal he approved in December. More than 1,600 wildfire victims signed an online petition calling the settlement unfair.
PG&E “is building off of our losses in a sense,” said Jason Meek, 48, whose Northern California wine country home was destroyed in 2017. “It’s important in my view that this settlement is done with thought and care.”
The possibility of government agencies tapping the fund has outraged people still looking for new places to live after losing their homes and, in some cases, still grieving loved ones who perished during the worst wildfires in modern U.S. history.

A Growing Sentiment Among Victims That They’re Getting Such a Raw Deal

Montali, who also presided over PG&E’s previous bankruptcy from 2001-2004, has never left any doubt that compensating the wildfire victims is his top priority in the new case, which began in January 2019. Claimants have since filed more than $50 billion in wildfire claims, which the utility has proposed settling for a total of $25.5 billion, which includes reimbursement for insurers and other things.
Attorneys representing the victims concede the settlement isn’t perfect, but they say it’s the best deal possible under the circumstances.

“I don’t have a lot of faith that I’m going to see any significant compensation at the end of it all.” — Sarah Bates, a 67-year-old former nurse who moved to Virginia after losing her Paradise home in 2018 
Still, there is a growing sentiment among victims that they’re getting such a raw deal they should reject it, even if that means waiting longer to be paid.
“I want you to know that many of us understand what is happening and that we will move heaven and earth to stop it,” vowed Lisa Williams, 59, another survivor of the 2018 Camp Fire, in a Feb. 6 letter. Williams, who now lives in Las Vegas, started a wildfire victims group on Facebook opposing the current deal.
Compounding frustration over the plan to pay them in stock, PG&E agreed to an all-cash settlement of $11 billion to reimburse about 110 insurers for losses paid out to policyholders.
“Not only do we have to wait to get paid but we’d have to depend on the company’s recovery,” said Meek, who said he has moved many times since losing his house, and is nowhere close to rebuilding on his property. “If a fire comes again, what will happen to the stock price?”
The last time PG&E emerged from bankruptcy in April 2004, its stock more than doubled while paying out billions of dollars in dividends. PG&E’s stock has sunk as low as $3.55 four months ago, but has since rebounded to $16 to $18 per share, largely on hopes the company will be able to deliver on its projection of record profits as it bounces back from bankruptcy.
Court documents say none of the victims will have to accept PG&E stock if they don’t want it but the process for choosing an alternative hasn’t been spelled out yet.
Sarah Bates, a 67-year-old former nurse who moved to Virginia after losing her Paradise home in 2018, said those affected the most are being “tossed aside.”
“I don’t have a lot of faith that I’m going to see any significant compensation at the end of it all,” Bates said.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

UP NEXT

Gov. Newsom Lambasts Trump for Giving Immigrants’ Health Data to Deportation Officials

Russia Says US Has Cancelled Next Round of Talks on Easing Tensions

57 minutes ago

Protester Killed at Utah ‘No Kings’ Rally Was Fashion Designer From ‘Project Runway’

58 minutes ago

Fresno Stabbing Leads to 7-Hour SWAT Standoff and Arrest

A machete attack in a Fresno apartment complex led to a seven-hour SWAT standoff that ended with a suspect in custody early Monday morning, ...

6 minutes ago

6 minutes ago

Fresno Stabbing Leads to 7-Hour SWAT Standoff and Arrest

Officials inside the Israeli Army’s underground command bunker in Tel Aviv, Israel, on Friday, May 21, 2021. A former leader in Israel’s top commando unit acknowledged that the distance from the battlefield could create indifference to human lives. (Dan Balilty/The New York Times)
31 minutes ago

A Look Inside Israel’s ‘Fortress of Zion’ Command Beneath Tel Aviv

43 minutes ago

Fresno Police Make DUI Arrest, Cite 135 Drivers in Distracted Driving Crackdown

National flags of Russia and the U.S. fly at Vnukovo International Airport in Moscow, Russia April 11, 2017. (Reuters File)
57 minutes ago

Russia Says US Has Cancelled Next Round of Talks on Easing Tensions

58 minutes ago

Protester Killed at Utah ‘No Kings’ Rally Was Fashion Designer From ‘Project Runway’

Possum, a quirky senior pup who beat the odds after surgery and dental work, is now thriving in foster care and ready to find a loving home. (Mell's Mutts)
1 hour ago

Possum the Wanderer Finds Her Groove After Tumor Surgery

Norman James Walker is Valley Crime Stoppers' Most Wanted Person of the Day for June 16, 2025. (Valley Crimes Stoppers)
1 hour ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Norman James Walker

1 hour ago

JJ Spaun Turns a Free Fall into US Open Title at Rainy Oakmont

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend