Fresno Unified’s teachers’ union says the district has violated its contract by improperly spending millions of dollars — perhaps as much as $150 million over the past three years — to cover retirees’ healthcare costs with money that’s supposed to be spent only on active employees.
Fresno Teachers Association President Manuel Bonilla told GV Wire on Thursday that the union submitted a grievance recently to the district over the alleged contract violation.
He said union officials suspect improper payments for retiree healthcare might have occurred for more than three years, but a statute of limitations sets the grievance time period to the past three years.
Fresno Unified spokesman Amy Idsvoog confirmed the grievance was filed but declined to answer questions about it, including how many retirees may have benefited.
“Like any grievance, we have to look into it,” she said. “That process is underway.”
Related Story: Fresno Unified, Teachers Agree on Historic 3-Year Contract
FTA: Nearly One-Third Went To Retirees
Bonilla said the teachers’ union contract specifies that the district’s contributions to the Health Fund be used for active employees only. But an estimated 31% of the Health Fund has gone to cover retiree medical costs, he said.
FTA President Manuel Bonilla
This has reduced the amount of money available through the Health Fund for active employees, including teachers, Bonilla said.
According to Article 18 of the FTA contract, as of July 1, 2019, the district’s annual contribution for each active employee is $19,348.
Bonilla said that the district should have provided additional funding to cover retiree healthcare expenses.
The district’s health fund is overseen by the Joint Health Management Board, which is composed of representatives from labor and management. The board’s responsibility includes making sure that there are sufficient funds to cover medical costs for district employees.
More than 10,500 people work for Fresno Unified, the state’s third-largest district.
Less Money Available For Active Employees
Diverting money to retirees’ healthcare has shortchanged active employees, the union contends.
If the district’s spending of Health Fund money had covered only active employees, Bonilla said, “we’d be able to increase the amount of coverage for active employees, and we would have a higher reserves level in the Health Care Fund.”
Bonilla said that once the district responds to the union’s grievance, the union can seek to negotiate a settlement with the district. If that doesn’t happen, the union can then take the matter to binding arbitration, he said.
This is just another example of the poor leadership and oversight skills of Superintendent Bob Nelson. The lack of professionalism by District department employees at performing their duties is just another example of Nelson’s “Oh Golly! Try and do better.” approach in leading the administrators of F.U.S.D. The employees know that there will be no accountability or discipline should they do a job poorly. How can you not follow the contents of a Collective Bargaining Agreement? I guess Fresno Unified administrators and their clerks must have the same 1st Grade reading and comprehension skills as many of their high school students. I think we’ve found out where the problem lies.