Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Capitol Grinds up Major Housing Bill
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 5 years ago on
February 3, 2020

Share

Even under optimal circumstances, California is extraordinarily difficult to govern — more like a fractious nation than a culturally homogenous state.
Our size and our staggering economic, cultural, ethnic, even geographic and meteorological diversity not only create complex issues but make the reconciliation of often bitterly disparate factions difficult, bordering on impossible.


Dan Walters
Opinion
Any legislation faces a series of procedural hurdles, all of which must be cleared for any proposal to be enacted. It gives affected interests, dubbed “stakeholders,” many opportunities to hamper or even block a measure they deem harmful, forcing sponsors to cater to their demands.
As major legislation undergoes multiple revisions on its months-long journey through the process, the end game is often one of three unsatisfactory results: the proposal is unable to garner enough stakeholder support and dies; it passes but it’s diminished to a pointless token, or concessions to interests make it an unworkable monstrosity.
The prime example of No. 3 is the 1996 legislation that purported to deregulate the state’s electrical energy industry, promising benefits to consumers, the economy and utilities.
It was an unmitigated disaster, allowing energy traders to game the convoluted power procurement process it created, driving consumers’ power costs up, creating blackouts, forcing Pacific Gas & Electric into bankruptcy and pushing other utilities to near-insolvency.

SB 50 Was Aimed at Overcoming Local Single-Family Zoning Laws

The legislative sausage factory is grinding up another well-intentioned measure aimed at easing the state’s foremost crisis, a chronic shortage of housing that is heavily impacting California families and threatening to derail the state’s economy.
Senate Bill 50 was aimed at overcoming local single-family zoning laws to authorize higher-density, multiple-family developments that meet certain criteria in hopes of enticing developers to build more housing, particularly for the low- and moderate-income families that feel the biggest pinch.
However, it would potentially cut deeply into local governments’ traditional land use powers and thus potentially change many communities’ preference for bucolic single-family neighborhoods.
Its author, Sen. Scott Wiener, a San Francisco Democrat, faced an uphill battle, mostly with members of his own party and mostly those from Southern California, which is largely a collection of villages, even within its larger cities, segregated by their residents’ economic standing, ethnicity and culture.
“You can have the most streamlined process in the world and enormous funding for affordable housing, but if the zoning says you’re not allowed to build something, that’s the end of the process,” Wiener said during last Wednesday’s floor debate on the bill, which had been bottled up for months. “We’ve prioritized the way a neighborhood looks, that views are more important than who is actually able to live in a neighborhood.”

Crisis Will Continue Unless the Not-In-My-Backyard Attitudes Are Overcome

Wiener made dozens of revisions to lessen the impact on local governments in hopes of placating his critics, to no avail.

“We’re in a world of hurt in California.” Sen. Scott Wiener 
The bill failed, largely due to opposition from Southern California Democrats who said, in essence, they didn’t want Sacramento to have the power to alter the character of their villages. Wiener tried again on Thursday, facing a deadline for advancing bills left over from the 2019 session, but failed again.
It’s difficult to say whether the much-changed bill would have had a material effect on the state’s housing crisis, at least in the short run. The Senate didn’t even publicly post a layman’s explanation of its new, highly technical provisions before the floor votes.
However, it’s evident from the opposition that the crisis will continue unless the tribal not-in-my-backyard attitudes that stall much-needed construction are overcome.
“We’re in a world of hurt in California,” Wiener said before Thursday’s vote.
Yes, we are.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Anti-Israel Boycott Bill Withdrawn from Congressional Vote

DON'T MISS

Ravens Release Justin Tucker After Accusations by Massage Therapists of Inappropriate Behavior

DON'T MISS

Carney Meets Trump in Bid to Reset Strained Canada-US Relations

DON'T MISS

Draymond Green’s Vow to Keep His Cool Helps Warriors Advance to in West Semis

DON'T MISS

Ian Happ Homers as the Cubs Beat the Sloppy Giants

DON'T MISS

Ohtani and Freeman Homer off Alcántara as Dodgers Beat Marlins

DON'T MISS

That One Place Provides a Unique Karaoke Experience and Is ‘Good for the Soul’

DON'T MISS

Israel Hits Yemen’s Main Airport in Airstrike Against Houthis

DON'T MISS

Hanford Toddler Critical After Accidental Gunshot, Police Arrest Relative

DON'T MISS

Drone Strikes Pound Port Sudan, Putting Aid Deliveries at Risk

UP NEXT

The Valley is Driving California’s Economic Growth

UP NEXT

Trump Is About to Steal My Friend’s Christmas … and Yours

UP NEXT

Newsom Jabs at Trump and Musk, but Will AI Make California More Efficient?

UP NEXT

I Can’t Believe Anyone Thinks Trump Actually Cares About Antisemitism

UP NEXT

Will California Meet Newsom’s 2035 EV Deadline? It Won’t Even Hit the 2026 Target 

UP NEXT

Trump Is a Revolutionary. Will He Succeed or Fail?

UP NEXT

We Need Proof of Life for the Makeup Artist Trump Sent to El Salvador

UP NEXT

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

UP NEXT

Lights, Camera, Board Vote: Fresno Unified’s Carefully Choreographed Production

UP NEXT

Given Its Failures, Can California Manage a Transition to a Carbon-Free Future?

Draymond Green’s Vow to Keep His Cool Helps Warriors Advance to in West Semis

1 hour ago

Ian Happ Homers as the Cubs Beat the Sloppy Giants

1 hour ago

Ohtani and Freeman Homer off Alcántara as Dodgers Beat Marlins

1 hour ago

That One Place Provides a Unique Karaoke Experience and Is ‘Good for the Soul’

1 hour ago

Israel Hits Yemen’s Main Airport in Airstrike Against Houthis

2 hours ago

Hanford Toddler Critical After Accidental Gunshot, Police Arrest Relative

2 hours ago

Drone Strikes Pound Port Sudan, Putting Aid Deliveries at Risk

2 hours ago

Europe Launches $566M Program to Lure US Researchers Amid Trump Cuts

2 hours ago

This Is the Moment of Moral Reckoning in Gaza

3 hours ago

Buy American? No Thanks, Europe Says, as Tariff Backlash Grows.

3 hours ago

Anti-Israel Boycott Bill Withdrawn from Congressional Vote

A controversial bill that would have penalized Americans for boycotting Israel was removed from the congressional voting schedule Monday fol...

18 minutes ago

18 minutes ago

Anti-Israel Boycott Bill Withdrawn from Congressional Vote

53 minutes ago

Ravens Release Justin Tucker After Accusations by Massage Therapists of Inappropriate Behavior

U.S. President Donald Trump greets Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 6, 2025. (REUTERS/Kent Nishimura)
1 hour ago

Carney Meets Trump in Bid to Reset Strained Canada-US Relations

1 hour ago

Draymond Green’s Vow to Keep His Cool Helps Warriors Advance to in West Semis

1 hour ago

Ian Happ Homers as the Cubs Beat the Sloppy Giants

1 hour ago

Ohtani and Freeman Homer off Alcántara as Dodgers Beat Marlins

1 hour ago

That One Place Provides a Unique Karaoke Experience and Is ‘Good for the Soul’

Smoke billows after an Israeli airstrike on Houthi infrastructure, in Sana'a, Yemen May 6, 2025. (REUTERS/Khaled Abdullah)
2 hours ago

Israel Hits Yemen’s Main Airport in Airstrike Against Houthis

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend