Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Sued Again for Requiring Women on Company Boards
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
November 13, 2019

Share

SACRAMENTO — California’s first-in-the-nation law requiring publicly held companies to put women on their boards of directors is facing a second legal challenge.
The law requires publicly traded companies to have at least one woman on their boards by the end of this year. By 2021, boards with five members must have two women, while those with six directors must have three.
The Pacific Legal Foundation provided The Associated Press with the lawsuit it filed in federal court Wednesday, arguing that the law violates the equal protection clause of the U.S. Constitution.
The libertarian group wants to block such laws in California and other states. Similar proposals have been introduced in Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey and Washington state, the group said.
Illinois ultimately enacted a pared-down law this year requiring publicly traded companies to report the demographics of their boards and plans for promoting diversity to the state each year.
Some European countries, including Norway and France, already require corporate boards to include women.

Companies Face $100,000 Fines if They Fail to Report Their Board Compositions to Padilla’s Office

“The law mandates exactly what the equal protection clause forbids — taking into account things like sex or race,” foundation attorney Anastasia Boden said. “The Constitution is meant to ensure that people are free to be individuals. Here, the law assumes that people of the same sex are essentially interchangeable.”

“The law mandates exactly what the equal protection clause forbids — taking into account things like sex or race. The Constitution is meant to ensure that people are free to be individuals. Here, the law assumes that people of the same sex are essentially interchangeable.” — foundation attorney Anastasia Boden
Another conservative group, Judicial Watch, sued in August, arguing that spending taxpayer money to enforce the law would violate the California Constitution.
Secretary of State Alex Padilla is named in both lawsuits. He’s asking a judge to throw out the Judicial Watch lawsuit, saying taxpayers have not been harmed and thus have no standing to sue.
Companies face $100,000 fines if they fail to report their board compositions to Padilla’s office. Those who fail to include the required number of female board members can be fined $100,000 for a first violation and $300,000 for subsequent violations.
Former Gov. Jerry Brown signed the measure into law last year as lawmakers reacted to the national #MeToo movement against sexual misconduct. The Democratic governor said at the time that the legislation had “potential flaws” that could block its implementation but that it was important to send a message.
State Sen. Hannah-Beth Jackson said her bill is already having a positive effect but respects the right of anyone to file a challenge.
Photo of former Gov. Jerry Brown
FILE – In this Tuesday, Dec. 18, 2018 file photo, then California Gov. Jerry Brown talks during an interview in Sacramento, Calif. California’s first-in-the-nation law requiring publicly held companies to put women on their boards of directors faces its second legal challenge. Pacific Legal Foundation sued in federal court on Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2019, arguing that the law violates the U.S. Constitution’s equal protection clause. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli, File)

The California Chamber of Commerce Opposed the Measure

“I strongly believe — and significant research has shown — that this is a policy that improves a business’ performance and their bottom line,” Jackson said in a statement, noting that many companies have already voluntarily complied.
She said the last all-male board of the S&P 500 added a female director, “showing that diversity is within our grasp, and there are women who are highly qualified and eager to step up.”
The California Chamber of Commerce opposed the measure, saying it would be difficult for companies to implement and violates constitutional prohibitions against discrimination.
The Pacific Legal Foundation’s lawsuit likely comes too late to block this year’s deadline, Boden said, but she’s hoping for a ruling before corporations are required to include more women by the end of 2021.
Boden argued that corporations are putting more women on their boards even without the law. She cited the Equilar Gender Diversity Index by the executive data company, which shows that women filled more than 40 percent of director posts so far this year.
“We are actually near boardroom parity,” Boden said. “We don’t need this law, which will actually cast doubt on the reason behind future hires.”
The foundation said nearly two-thirds of its funding comes from individuals, about a quarter from foundations and the rest from associations, businesses and others, and that no donations — corporate or otherwise — go to support any specific case.

DON'T MISS

If You Want to Ski Affordably Next Season, Buy Now

DON'T MISS

Dog Found in Horrid Conditions Now Seeks Loving Home

DON'T MISS

Trump Takes Aim at California Six Times in 24 Hours

DON'T MISS

Elon Musk Sells X to His Own xAI for $33 Billion in All-Stock Deal

DON'T MISS

US Naval Academy Ends Affirmative Action in Admissions

DON'T MISS

Elon Musk Backtracks on a Legally Questionable Plan to Pay Voters

DON'T MISS

Appeals Court Clears Way for DOGE to Keep Operating at USAID

DON'T MISS

Trump Pledges US Aid for Asia Quake Despite Former Official Saying System in ‘Shambles’

DON'T MISS

Is Fresno Political Consultant Alex Tavlian Behind Election Attack Mailer?

DON'T MISS

Gronk-a-Mania Set to Run Wild Over WrestleMania Weekend

UP NEXT

Cal State Automatically Admitting High School Students With Good Grades

UP NEXT

California Democratic Lawmaker Exaggerated His Record as a Police Officer

UP NEXT

Utah Becomes the First State to Ban Fluoride in Public Drinking Water

UP NEXT

Wilmer Flores’ 3-Run Homer in the 9th Inning Propels Giants to Victory Over Reds

UP NEXT

Trump Challenges California on Transgender Parental Notification

UP NEXT

Fresno Mayor Praises a State Bill That Would Speed In-Fill Housing

UP NEXT

Feds Revive Funding for the Tiny Delta Smelt Trump Hates

UP NEXT

Will This Bill Be the End of California’s Housing vs. Environment Wars?

UP NEXT

State Audit: CPUC Needs to Boost Oversight of Energy Efficiency Programs We’re Paying For

UP NEXT

Democrats’ Popularity Plummets, yet Midterm Prospects Remain Strong

Elon Musk Sells X to His Own xAI for $33 Billion in All-Stock Deal

17 hours ago

US Naval Academy Ends Affirmative Action in Admissions

17 hours ago

Elon Musk Backtracks on a Legally Questionable Plan to Pay Voters

17 hours ago

Appeals Court Clears Way for DOGE to Keep Operating at USAID

17 hours ago

Trump Pledges US Aid for Asia Quake Despite Former Official Saying System in ‘Shambles’

17 hours ago

Is Fresno Political Consultant Alex Tavlian Behind Election Attack Mailer?

17 hours ago

Gronk-a-Mania Set to Run Wild Over WrestleMania Weekend

19 hours ago

Federal Judge Blocks Trump From Dismantling Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

19 hours ago

St. Agnes’ Newest Robot Promises Less Invasive Surgeries, Faster Recoveries

19 hours ago

California Food Banks Brace for Funding Cuts, and Not Only From the Trump Administration

20 hours ago

If You Want to Ski Affordably Next Season, Buy Now

While the slopes may still be open across much of North America, it’s time to think about next season. The major passes, including Epi...

1 hour ago

1 hour ago

If You Want to Ski Affordably Next Season, Buy Now

Punkin, a 1-2-year-old dog with a tough past of living in a hoarding situation, is looking for a patient, understanding home with another dog to help him adjust and thrive. (Mell's Mutts)
1 hour ago

Dog Found in Horrid Conditions Now Seeks Loving Home

1 hour ago

Trump Takes Aim at California Six Times in 24 Hours

17 hours ago

Elon Musk Sells X to His Own xAI for $33 Billion in All-Stock Deal

17 hours ago

US Naval Academy Ends Affirmative Action in Admissions

17 hours ago

Elon Musk Backtracks on a Legally Questionable Plan to Pay Voters

17 hours ago

Appeals Court Clears Way for DOGE to Keep Operating at USAID

17 hours ago

Trump Pledges US Aid for Asia Quake Despite Former Official Saying System in ‘Shambles’

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend