Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: A Resurrection for Redevelopment?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
August 25, 2019

Share

Voters and elected officials adopt policies on assurances of beneficial impacts, but they often interact with other decrees to produce what are called “unintended consequences.”
Redevelopment has been a classic example for nearly seven decades, and it may be on the verge of another twist.


Dan Walters
CALmatters

Opinion
Redevelopment, authorized in the early 1950s, was aimed at encouraging local governments, cities mostly, to clean up neighborhoods deemed to have “blight.” They would invest in sewers, water systems and other public works that would draw in private investment.
To finance projects, local governments would float bonds and repay them with “tax increment financing.” As property taxes in the improved project areas increased, the revenue gains could be retained by the sponsoring local governments.
The new powers were used scantily at first, but even so drew criticism when properties were seized from their owners, whole neighborhoods were razed, and their occupants, often the poor and/or immigrants, were compelled to find new shelter elsewhere.
Redevelopment exploded after voters passed Proposition 13 in 1978 and placed a limit on all property taxes. Feeling the financial pinch, local officials turned to redevelopment for relief, eventually creating more than 400 local redevelopment zones, often on raw land, and subsidizing commercial development, such as shopping centers, auto dealerships and hotels, that would generate sales taxes and other revenues.

Three Sweeping Policy Decrees Over Several Decades

Cities twisted the legal requirement for finding “blight” with some very creative, even sneaky maneuvers. One declared some marshland to be blighted because it was “subject to periodic flooding.”  And they would use generous grants of redevelopment money – bribes, actually – to lure tax-generating commercial business away from neighboring cities.
A decade after Proposition 13 passed, voters acted again, passing Proposition 98 that guaranteed certain levels of financing for public schools and required the state to provide whatever money schools needed if local property taxes didn’t meet required levels.
By and by, as redevelopment use expanded, diversions of property taxes reached about $5.5 billion a year and because of Proposition 98, the state was backfilling about $2 billion to schools.
Thus, three sweeping policy decrees over several decades interacted to produce the consequence of taxpayers throughout the state indirectly spending billions of dollars each year to subsidize commercial projects for a few cities.
The excesses of redevelopment – such as $5 million to underwrite a “mermaid bar” just two blocks from the state Capitol in Sacramento – and its heavy financial impact on an upside-down state budget led then-Gov. Jerry Brown and legislators to do away with it in 2011.

Skepticism Is More Than Warranted

Ever since, city officials have yearned for redevelopment’s return, saying that its demise also reduced financing for badly needed low- and moderate-income housing.
Several highly modified versions have been enacted, but have largely gone unused because all protected the state budget.

Several highly modified versions have been enacted, but have largely gone unused because all protected the state budget.
This year, a new effort was mounted, that would recreate redevelopment with a new name, the Affordable Housing and Community Development Program. It would give a new state commission oversight power and once again require the state to make up losses of property taxes to schools.
Senate Bill 5, carried by Sen. Jim Beall, a San Jose Democrat, has made it through the Senate and is pending in the Assembly in the final weeks of the 2019 session. It’s been estimated that if enacted, it would eventually divert about $2 billion a year in property taxes and require about $1 billion of it to be spent on housing.
Sponsors – city officials and labor unions mostly – contend that oversight would prevent the abuses of redevelopment from reappearing.
Given its tortured history, however, skepticism is more than warranted.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect Linked to Nine-Round Shooting

DON'T MISS

Hundreds Rally in Fresno for Immigrant Rights

DON'T MISS

Visalia Man Arrested Again in Child Exploitation Case After National Tip

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Announces 2025 Undergraduate Deans’ Medalists

DON'T MISS

Familiar Husband-and-Wife-Duo Bring Thai Food to Northeast Fresno

DON'T MISS

Fresno’s Downtown Kern Street Market Set for Return. Get Your Produce Baskets Ready

DON'T MISS

Retired Madera County Sheriff Edward Bates Dies at 99

DON'T MISS

Military Parade on Trump’s Birthday Could Include More Than 6,500 Troops

DON'T MISS

Israeli Security Cabinet Backs Plans to Expand Gaza Operation, Media Reports Say

DON'T MISS

California Lawmakers Kill Bid to Force HOAs to Follow Open Meeting Laws

UP NEXT

Hundreds Rally in Fresno for Immigrant Rights

UP NEXT

Visalia Man Arrested Again in Child Exploitation Case After National Tip

UP NEXT

Fresno State Announces 2025 Undergraduate Deans’ Medalists

UP NEXT

Familiar Husband-and-Wife-Duo Bring Thai Food to Northeast Fresno

UP NEXT

Fresno’s Downtown Kern Street Market Set for Return. Get Your Produce Baskets Ready

UP NEXT

Retired Madera County Sheriff Edward Bates Dies at 99

UP NEXT

Military Parade on Trump’s Birthday Could Include More Than 6,500 Troops

UP NEXT

Israeli Security Cabinet Backs Plans to Expand Gaza Operation, Media Reports Say

UP NEXT

California Lawmakers Kill Bid to Force HOAs to Follow Open Meeting Laws

UP NEXT

California Democrats Backed Into a Corner Over Teen Sex Solicitation

Fresno State Announces 2025 Undergraduate Deans’ Medalists

38 minutes ago

Familiar Husband-and-Wife-Duo Bring Thai Food to Northeast Fresno

1 hour ago

Fresno’s Downtown Kern Street Market Set for Return. Get Your Produce Baskets Ready

1 hour ago

Retired Madera County Sheriff Edward Bates Dies at 99

2 hours ago

Military Parade on Trump’s Birthday Could Include More Than 6,500 Troops

2 hours ago

Israeli Security Cabinet Backs Plans to Expand Gaza Operation, Media Reports Say

2 hours ago

California Lawmakers Kill Bid to Force HOAs to Follow Open Meeting Laws

2 hours ago

California Democrats Backed Into a Corner Over Teen Sex Solicitation

3 hours ago

Fresno Unified’s New Supe Makes 500% More Than a New Teacher

3 hours ago

Trump Says Harvard University’s Tax-Exempt Status Will Be Revoked

3 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect Linked to Nine-Round Shooting

Fresno police have arrested a man linked to a shooting last month that triggered a ShotSpotter alert and left several people fleeing for saf...

1 minute ago

Steven Gonzales, who is on probation, was arrested for an April shooting after police identified him through a traffic stop and surveillance footage on Thursday, May 1, 2025. (Fresno PD)
1 minute ago

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect Linked to Nine-Round Shooting

9 minutes ago

Hundreds Rally in Fresno for Immigrant Rights

19 minutes ago

Visalia Man Arrested Again in Child Exploitation Case After National Tip

Fresno State has named eight outstanding undergraduate students as its 2025 Deans’ Medalists, recognizing top scholars from each college for academic excellence, leadership, and community impact. (Fresno State)
38 minutes ago

Fresno State Announces 2025 Undergraduate Deans’ Medalists

1 hour ago

Familiar Husband-and-Wife-Duo Bring Thai Food to Northeast Fresno

1 hour ago

Fresno’s Downtown Kern Street Market Set for Return. Get Your Produce Baskets Ready

2 hours ago

Retired Madera County Sheriff Edward Bates Dies at 99

President Donald Trump disembarks Air Force One upon arriving at Tuscaloosa National Airport in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, U.S. May 1, 2025. (REUTERS/Leah Millis)
2 hours ago

Military Parade on Trump’s Birthday Could Include More Than 6,500 Troops

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend