Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Editorial: SB 1 Is the Same Bad Legislation in a New Dress
GV-Wire-1
By gvwire
Published 5 years ago on
July 24, 2019

Share

Bad legislation is bad legislation.
It doesn’t matter how many times you try to dress it up. Or bring it back with a new number.

SB 1 is not only redundant, anti-science, and a barrier to environmental progress, it would put a brake on California’s economy, too.
We’re talking about Senate Bill 1, which is officially titled the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019.
Senate President Pro Tem Toni Atkins (D-San Diego) says the bill is an “insurance policy against the exploitation of our natural resources and our people.”

SB 1 Is Flawed Overreaction to Trump Administration

But, at its heart, SB 1 is a highly flawed overreaction to a Trump administration that many state Democratic leaders and their environmental allies have called “anti-science.”


The Legislature approved SB 1 on the final day of the session and sent the bill to Gov. Gavin Newsom. The bill was vetoed by the governor on Sept. 27.



If it passes the Legislature and is signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom, the bill would empower state agencies to adopt rules and regulations that they determine are more stringent than federal rules and regulations adopted after Jan. 19, 2017.
For the record: Donald Trump was sworn into office Jan. 20, 2017. That’s not a coincidence.
This bill has little to do with ensuring clean water and air, protecting wildlife, and standing up for workers. The real goal is to provide a legislative vehicle for Democratic lawmakers to polish their “Trump resistance” credentials ahead of the 2020 elections.
We are confident in saying that because many of California’s environmental and labor protections already are more stringent than their federal counterparts. Moreover, California has ample tools to fend off unwise decrees from the Trump administration.

This bill has little to do with ensuring clean water and air, protecting wildlife, and standing up for workers. The real goal is to provide a legislative vehicle for Democratic lawmakers to polish their “Trump resistance” credentials ahead of the 2020 elections.

SB 1 Rolls Back Scientific Advances

One big problem with SB 1 is that it would wipe out the gains the scientific community has made since 2017 in understanding what has contributed to the decline of the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta. This new knowledge is opening the door to helping imperiled fished populations such as salmon while freeing water for cities and industries, including agriculture
“Over the last 30 years, several fish species have continued to decline despite significant expenditures and diversion curtailments mandated by Endangered Species Act rulings,” writes Rick Gilmore, general manager of the Byron-Bethany Irrigation District spanning Alameda, Contra Costa, and San Joaquin counties.
“New procedures and agreements (negotiated by the Brown administration), which incorporate new species management science, are currently being incorporated and scrutinized by the federal and state fish agencies. These updated methods should be deployed and evaluated rather than stymied and derailed. The new science and better practices present the best available option for species recovery.”


And, although Atkins says revisions have allayed fears that voluntary environmental agreements praised statewide won’t be handcuffed by SB 1, the bill’s opponents rightfully continue to be skeptical of such claims.

Bill Is a ‘Job Killer’

SB 1 is not only redundant, anti-science, and a barrier to environmental progress, it would put the brakes on California’s economy, too.
“Due to costs and anticipated litigation associated with SB 1, companies doing business in the state would be hard-pressed to hire more workers or expand California operations,” says the California Chamber of Commerce, which calls the bill “a job killer.”

Earlier Version Died, So Should This One

Two years ago, then-state Senate President Pro Tem Kevin de León pushed SB 49, a bill nearly identical to SB 1. Just like Atkins’ bill, it passed the upper house. However, de León’s version nose-dived in the Assembly.
SB 1 deserves the same fate. It’s flawed legislation driven by a knee-jerk reaction to President Trump. And it’s bad for California — especially those inland regions, like the Valley, that Newsom has promised to help.
Newsom should weigh in immediately to fix SB 1’s substantial flaws. If it reaches his desk without those revisions, he should veto it.
— Written by Bill McEwen  
 

DON'T MISS

Pro-Palestinian Protesters at Drexel Ignore Call to Disband as Arrests Nationwide Surpass 3,000

DON'T MISS

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Ticks Higher as S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite Head for More Records

DON'T MISS

Ramos Homers, Hicks Earns 4th Win as Giants Beat Rockies for First Series Sweep This Year

DON'T MISS

Sour Patch Kids Oreos? Peeps Pepsi? What’s Behind the Weird Flavors Popping Up on Store Shelves

DON'T MISS

Red Lobster Seeks Bankruptcy Protection Days After Closing Dozens of Restaurants

DON'T MISS

Michael Cohen Says He Stole from Trump’s Company as Defense Presses Key Hush Money Trial Witness

DON'T MISS

Ohtani Delivers Walk-off Single in 10th. Dodgers Have Won 20 of Last 26 Games.

DON'T MISS

Fresno Sheriff to Host Q&A on CCWs. Registration Is Open.

DON'T MISS

GOP Makes Noncitizen Voting a Key 2024 Campaign Issue

DON'T MISS

Target to Lower Prices on Thousands of Basic Items as Inflation Sends Customers Scrounging for Deals

UP NEXT

How California’s New Fixed Utility Charge Got Its Sneaky Start in the Legislature

UP NEXT

Empowering Education: Join the Fight for California Kids’ Literacy

UP NEXT

Newsom’s No New Taxes Pledge Upsets California Progressives

UP NEXT

SF Unified Flirts with Insolvency. It’s Not the Only District in California.

UP NEXT

Sustainable Farms Need to Come Together, Not Cast Blame Over California Methane Program

UP NEXT

Will California Supreme Court Knock Anti-Tax Measure Off the November Ballot?

UP NEXT

A Sustainable Future for Fresno: Rethinking Our Hydrogen Strategy

UP NEXT

Politicians Keep Shifting Blame as California’s Homelessness Crisis Worsens

UP NEXT

California Schools Can’t Keep Pace with Utility Bills. Lawmakers Must Fix New Solar Rules.

UP NEXT

CA Restaurants Shouldn’t Be Shocked That ‘Junk Fees’ Ban Applies to Them

Sour Patch Kids Oreos? Peeps Pepsi? What’s Behind the Weird Flavors Popping Up on Store Shelves

1 hour ago

Red Lobster Seeks Bankruptcy Protection Days After Closing Dozens of Restaurants

1 hour ago

Michael Cohen Says He Stole from Trump’s Company as Defense Presses Key Hush Money Trial Witness

1 hour ago

Ohtani Delivers Walk-off Single in 10th. Dodgers Have Won 20 of Last 26 Games.

1 hour ago

Fresno Sheriff to Host Q&A on CCWs. Registration Is Open.

2 hours ago

GOP Makes Noncitizen Voting a Key 2024 Campaign Issue

2 hours ago

Target to Lower Prices on Thousands of Basic Items as Inflation Sends Customers Scrounging for Deals

2 hours ago

WikiLeaks Founder Assange Wins Appeal Against US Extradition

2 hours ago

Jim Otto, ‘Mr. Raider’ and Pro Football Hall of Famer, Dies at 86

2 hours ago

Airstrike Kills 27 in Gaza Amid Intensifying Israeli Leadership Divisions

2 hours ago

Pro-Palestinian Protesters at Drexel Ignore Call to Disband as Arrests Nationwide Surpass 3,000

PHILADELPHIA — Pro-Palestinian protesters ignored a request by Drexel University’s president to disband their encampment on Monday as ...

49 mins ago

49 mins ago

Pro-Palestinian Protesters at Drexel Ignore Call to Disband as Arrests Nationwide Surpass 3,000

56 mins ago

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Ticks Higher as S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite Head for More Records

1 hour ago

Ramos Homers, Hicks Earns 4th Win as Giants Beat Rockies for First Series Sweep This Year

1 hour ago

Sour Patch Kids Oreos? Peeps Pepsi? What’s Behind the Weird Flavors Popping Up on Store Shelves

1 hour ago

Red Lobster Seeks Bankruptcy Protection Days After Closing Dozens of Restaurants

1 hour ago

Michael Cohen Says He Stole from Trump’s Company as Defense Presses Key Hush Money Trial Witness

1 hour ago

Ohtani Delivers Walk-off Single in 10th. Dodgers Have Won 20 of Last 26 Games.

2 hours ago

Fresno Sheriff to Host Q&A on CCWs. Registration Is Open.

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend