Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
US Court Weighs if Climate Change Violates Children's Rights
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
June 5, 2019

Share

PORTLAND, Ore. — In a courtroom packed with environmental activists, federal judges wrestled Tuesday with whether climate change violates the constitutional rights of young people who have sued the U.S. government over the use of fossil fuels.
A Justice Department attorney warned three judges from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that allowing the case to go to trial would be unprecedented and open the doors to more lawsuits.

“This case would have earth-shattering consequences.”Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Clark
“This case would have earth-shattering consequences,” Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Clark said.
He called the lawsuit “a direct attack on the separation of powers” and said the 21 young people who filed it want the courts to direct U.S. energy policy, instead of government officials.
The young people are pressing the government to stop promoting the use of fossil fuels, saying sources like coal and oil cause climate change and violate their Fifth Amendment rights to life, liberty and property.
The judges seemed to feel the enormity of the case, which the plaintiffs’ lawyer compared in scope to the U.S. Supreme Court’s Brown v. Board of Education ruling that mandated desegregation of schools in the 1950s.
If the case moves forward, the judiciary would be “dealing with different branches of government and telling them what to do,” said Judge Andrew Hurwitz, instead of issuing court orders telling officials to stop doing something deemed unconstitutional.

Obama, Trump Administrations Have Tried to Get Case Dismissed

The dire threat to people, particularly the young, demands such action, said Julia Olson, chief legal counsel for Our Children’s Trust, which is representing the plaintiffs.

“It’s just really disappointing to see the lengths that they go to — to not only not let us get the remedy that we’re seeking, but not even let us have the chance to prove our facts or present our case at trial.” — Nathan Baring, a 19-year-old from Fairbanks
“When our great-grandchildren look back on the 21st century, they will see that government-sanctioned climate destruction was the constitutional issue of this century,” Olson told the judges.
The lawsuit asks the courts to declare federal energy policy that contributes to climate change unconstitutional, order the government to quickly phase out carbon dioxide emissions to a certain level by 2100 and mandate a national climate recovery plan.
The Obama and Trump administrations have tried to get the case dismissed since it was filed in Oregon in 2015.
“It’s just really disappointing to see the lengths that they go to — to not only not let us get the remedy that we’re seeking, but not even let us have the chance to prove our facts or present our case at trial,” said Nathan Baring, a 19-year-old from Fairbanks, Alaska, who joined the lawsuit when he was 15.
Baring said a social media campaign in the early days featured the hashtag #KidsvsGov, which was changed to #YouthvsGov as they got older.
“I think eventually it’s just going to have to be #AdultsvsGov,” Baring said, laughing.
 

Case Has Become Focal Point for Many Youth Activists

As the case drags on, sea ice that protects coastal Alaska communities from fierce storms is forming later in the year, leaving those villages vulnerable, he said.
The young people argue that government officials have known for more than 50 years that carbon pollution from fossil fuels causes climate change and that policies promoting oil and gas deprive them of their constitutional rights.
Lawyers for President Donald Trump’s administration say the young people didn’t find any “historical basis for a fundamental right to a stable climate system or any other constitutional right related to the environment.”
The lawsuit says the young are more vulnerable to serious effects from climate change in the future. The American Academy of Pediatrics, 14 other health organizations and nearly 80 scientists and doctors agreed in a brief filed with the appeals court.
They pointed out that the World Health Organization estimates 88% of the global health burden of climate change falls on children younger than 5.
The case has become a focal point for many youth activists, and the courtroom in Portland was packed.
If the 9th Circuit judges decide the lawsuit can move forward, it would go before the U.S. District Court in Eugene, where the case was filed. The appeals court judges will rule later.

DON'T MISS

Israel Ends Agreement With UN Agency Providing Aid in Gaza

DON'T MISS

Demarcus Robinson’s One-Handed Catch in OT Gives Rams Win Over Seahawks

DON'T MISS

Trump, Musk and an American Masculinity Crisis

DON'T MISS

What One Tossup District Says About the Trump-Harris Battle for the Suburbs

DON'T MISS

Herbert Shines, Chargers Defense Dominates in Win Over Browns

DON'T MISS

US Confirms Reports That Iran Arrested an Iranian-American Citizen

DON'T MISS

A Vivid Trump-Harris Contrast in Campaign’s Grueling Final Days

DON'T MISS

Harris and Trump Battle to the Wire in Swing States, Times/Siena Polls Find

DON'T MISS

Israel Says It Carried out Ground Raid Into Syria, Seizing a Syrian Citizen

DON'T MISS

At 91, Willie Nelson Has a New Album Out and a Cannabis Cookbook Coming

UP NEXT

Visalia Rollerblader Suffered Major Injuries After Being Struck by Vehicle

UP NEXT

Fresno County Man Indicted for Possessing Stolen Guns

UP NEXT

On Elon Musk’s X, Dems Are an Endangered Species While GOP Goes Viral

UP NEXT

New Vehicles, Face Paint and a 1,200-Foot Fall: The US Army Prepares for War With China

UP NEXT

CNN Bars Pro-Trump Guest After His ‘Beeper’ Remark to Mehdi Hasan

UP NEXT

LGBTQ Supporters Drown Out Westboro Baptists’ Anti-Gay Message in Fresno

UP NEXT

The ‘Black Insurrectionist’ Was Actually White. The Deception Did Not Stop There

UP NEXT

Washington Post Says It Will Stop Endorsing Presidential Candidates

UP NEXT

What Happened When a Barber Told Trump About His $15,000 Electric Bill

UP NEXT

Los Angeles Times Editorials Editor Resigns After Newspaper Withholds Presidential Endorsement

What One Tossup District Says About the Trump-Harris Battle for the Suburbs

40 mins ago

Herbert Shines, Chargers Defense Dominates in Win Over Browns

45 mins ago

US Confirms Reports That Iran Arrested an Iranian-American Citizen

47 mins ago

A Vivid Trump-Harris Contrast in Campaign’s Grueling Final Days

52 mins ago

Harris and Trump Battle to the Wire in Swing States, Times/Siena Polls Find

56 mins ago

Israel Says It Carried out Ground Raid Into Syria, Seizing a Syrian Citizen

24 hours ago

At 91, Willie Nelson Has a New Album Out and a Cannabis Cookbook Coming

1 day ago

Fresno State Bulldogs Stumble in Fourth Quarter, Suffer Narrow Loss to Hawai’i

2 days ago

From Blue Cheese to Bacon: Peanut Butter Pairings That Will Shock You

2 days ago

Challengers Seek Seats on Tulare County Irrigation District Boards

2 days ago

Israel Ends Agreement With UN Agency Providing Aid in Gaza

Israel said Monday that it has terminated the agreement facilitating the work of the U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees, the main aid prov...

29 seconds ago

29 seconds ago

Israel Ends Agreement With UN Agency Providing Aid in Gaza

Rams
26 mins ago

Demarcus Robinson’s One-Handed Catch in OT Gives Rams Win Over Seahawks

31 mins ago

Trump, Musk and an American Masculinity Crisis

40 mins ago

What One Tossup District Says About the Trump-Harris Battle for the Suburbs

45 mins ago

Herbert Shines, Chargers Defense Dominates in Win Over Browns

Demonstrators walk over painted images of an American flag and an Israeli flag while marking the 45th anniversary of Iran’s takeover of the U.S. embassy in Tehran, Iran, on Sunday, Nov. 3, 2024. The State Department confirmed that it was looking into reports that an Iranian-American citizen had been arrested in Iran. (Arash Khamooshi/The New York Times)
47 mins ago

US Confirms Reports That Iran Arrested an Iranian-American Citizen

Harris
52 mins ago

A Vivid Trump-Harris Contrast in Campaign’s Grueling Final Days

56 mins ago

Harris and Trump Battle to the Wire in Swing States, Times/Siena Polls Find

Search

Send this to a friend