Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Can California Crack Its Housing Nut?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
May 19, 2019

Share

The state Department of Finance reported this month that California, which has a stubborn and growing shortage of housing, added just 77,000 houses, apartments and condos in 2018.

Opinion

Dan Walters
CALmatters Commentary

“California is home to 10 of the least affordable major markets and six of the 15 most expensive large metropolitan rental markets in the country. Rising costs continue to strain homeowners and renters statewide and negatively impact the state’s quality of life and long-term economic prosperity.” — revised budget

Actually, private and public housing developers drew permits for well over 100,000 units, and about that many were constructed. But a whopping 23,700 existing homes were burned or demolished, more than half of them in just one community, Paradise, which was virtually destroyed by wildfire.

With fire losses, the net addition was lower than the 85,297 recorded in 2017, which was lower than the 89,457 in 2016—a situation that Gov. Gavin Newsom labeled as “deplorable” when he introduced a revised state budget this month.

“The underproduction of supply continues to define the housing crisis the state is currently facing,” the revised budget declares. “California is home to 10 of the least affordable major markets and six of the 15 most expensive large metropolitan rental markets in the country. Rising costs continue to strain homeowners and renters statewide and negatively impact the state’s quality of life and long-term economic prosperity.”

It’s one of many socioeconomic issues that Newsom vows to confront and resolve during his still-new governorship. He is touting “a comprehensive $1.75 billion proposal to spur housing production, including planning and production grants to local governments, expansion of the state’s housing tax credit program and loan program for mixed-income housing, and opportunities for innovative housing projects on excess state property.”

Consequence of Soaring Home Prices and Rents

Newsom said he also “has refocused $500 million to removing barriers to building affordable housing and adding funding to assist California renters.”

This year’s legislative session, meanwhile, bristles with dozens of proposals their sponsors say will aggressively attack California’s housing shortage and its consequence of soaring home prices and rents.

The best-known measure, and one that has appeared to have the greatest potential impact, is Senate Bill 50, which aims to overcome local not-in-my-backyard opposition to new housing by establishing a right to build multi-unit projects in “transit-rich” or “job-rich” communities with housing shortages, regardless of local zoning laws.

SB 50 recognizes the most important fact about closing California’s housing gap: that direct governmental spending, such as what Newsom proposes, has only a marginal effect and that the most urgent need is to make private housing investment more attractive by reducing the costs and red tape now associated with projects.

SB 50 Was Put on Hold Until Next Year

However, the bill’s author, Sen. Scott Wiener, a San Francisco Democrat, has been compelled to revise the once-straightforward bill to accommodate pressure from local officials, who cherish their land use powers, and his fellow legislators. The changes seem to be watering down its potential for a big impact.

“It will take years for new supply to have a measurable effect on housing affordability, which is why any efforts to change land use regulations need to be accompanied by renter protections and policies that expand access to affordable units.” — The Terner Center for Housing Innovation at UC-Berkeley

The Terner Center for Housing Innovation at UC-Berkeley, in a new analysis, says the bill’s stated goal is undercut by carve-outs for specific counties and delay of the measure’s provisions in locally defined “sensitive communities.”

“Certainly, upzoning is not a panacea for solving the housing crisis,” the analysis concludes, adding, “It will take years for new supply to have a measurable effect on housing affordability, which is why any efforts to change land use regulations need to be accompanied by renter protections and policies that expand access to affordable units. But maintaining existing land use regulations that allow localities to avoid permitting new multi-family housing—and especially affordable housing—is not the solution either.”

Last week, SB 50 was put on hold until next year. Its struggles underscore the truism that housing is a tough political nut to crack.

CALmatters is a public-interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

Opinion: Does Jesus Want Christians to Be Environmentalists?

DON'T MISS

Illegal Immigrant Faces Murder Charges in Death of Woman Lit on Fire in NYC Subway

DON'T MISS

$1M Investment in Fresno Lender to Help Small Businesses Get Funding

DON'T MISS

Who Is Making a Difference in Fresno? Explore This List of 2024’s Shining Stars

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Tossed by Northern Illinois in Famous Idaho Potato Bowl

DON'T MISS

2 Rescued After Santa Cruz Wharf Partially Collapses Due to Heavy Surf From Major Pacific Storm

DON'T MISS

Spain Faces Threats of Terrorism and Unrest, US Warns in Travel Advisory

DON'T MISS

Bill Clinton Is Hospitalized With a Fever but in Good Spirits, Spokesperson Says

DON'T MISS

Media Relations Expert Leaves City Hall for Valley Children’s Hospital

DON'T MISS

Amar Augillard Departs the Fresno State Basketball Team

UP NEXT

New Decisions Boost California’s Zero-Emission Vehicle Mandate, but Major Hurdles Remain

UP NEXT

The Surprising Sexual Politics of Nicole Kidman’s Kinky ‘Babygirl’

UP NEXT

Tax Loopholes Cost California and Its Cities $107 Billion but Get Little Scrutiny

UP NEXT

24 for 24: GV Wire’s Top Images of 2024

UP NEXT

Did You Know Fresno County Doesn’t Have a Tax Assessor?

UP NEXT

Congress Can Give Us Clean Affordable Energy in 2025

UP NEXT

He Has Prison in His Past. Now He Hopes Law School Is in His Future

UP NEXT

Can New State Regs Resolve California’s Property Insurance Crisis?

UP NEXT

The First New Foreign Policy Challenge for Trump Just Became Clear

UP NEXT

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

Who Is Making a Difference in Fresno? Explore This List of 2024’s Shining Stars

13 hours ago

Fresno State Tossed by Northern Illinois in Famous Idaho Potato Bowl

13 hours ago

2 Rescued After Santa Cruz Wharf Partially Collapses Due to Heavy Surf From Major Pacific Storm

13 hours ago

Spain Faces Threats of Terrorism and Unrest, US Warns in Travel Advisory

14 hours ago

Bill Clinton Is Hospitalized With a Fever but in Good Spirits, Spokesperson Says

14 hours ago

Media Relations Expert Leaves City Hall for Valley Children’s Hospital

15 hours ago

Amar Augillard Departs the Fresno State Basketball Team

15 hours ago

Former Bulldog QB Mikey Keene Commits to Michigan

15 hours ago

Thunderstorms on Christmas Eve? They’re in the Fresno Forecast

16 hours ago

SE Fresno Voters Have Their Pick of Familiar Candidates to Succeed Chavez

16 hours ago

Opinion: Does Jesus Want Christians to Be Environmentalists?

As Christmas approaches, I know that my Christian friends will ask me why I chose to work for the environmental nonprofit Earthday.org inste...

17 minutes ago

17 minutes ago

Opinion: Does Jesus Want Christians to Be Environmentalists?

11 hours ago

Illegal Immigrant Faces Murder Charges in Death of Woman Lit on Fire in NYC Subway

12 hours ago

$1M Investment in Fresno Lender to Help Small Businesses Get Funding

13 hours ago

Who Is Making a Difference in Fresno? Explore This List of 2024’s Shining Stars

13 hours ago

Fresno State Tossed by Northern Illinois in Famous Idaho Potato Bowl

A closed wharf is seen in Santa Cruz, Calif., Monday, Dec. 23, 2024, after the pier partially collapsed and fell into the ocean. (AP/Martha Mendoza)
13 hours ago

2 Rescued After Santa Cruz Wharf Partially Collapses Due to Heavy Surf From Major Pacific Storm

14 hours ago

Spain Faces Threats of Terrorism and Unrest, US Warns in Travel Advisory

14 hours ago

Bill Clinton Is Hospitalized With a Fever but in Good Spirits, Spokesperson Says

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend