Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Who's an Employee and Who's Not?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
April 8, 2019

Share

Lorena Gonzalez finds herself in an unusual political position this year — and clearly relishes it.


Opinion
Dan Walters
CALmatters Commentary

Lorena Gonzalez has introduced Assembly Bill 5, which would codify the decision, known colloquially as “Dynamex” for the package delivery company whose workers, having been classified as contractors, sued and won the right to be employees.
Gonzalez, a Democratic assemblywoman from San Diego, is best known as a fierce warrior for worker rights and benefits, and carries a heavy load of legislation, usually on behalf of unions and other advocacy groups.
That puts her in constant conflict with business and employer interests. Her legislation routinely appears on the California Chamber of Commerce’s “job killer” list of bills that would, employers say, raise their costs and discourage investment.
She’s still fighting those battles, but a landmark decision last year by the state Supreme Court, tightening up the legal definition of an employee, is now sending business lobbyists to her, figuratively with hats in hand, to ask for exemptions from the court’s definition.
By applying a three-part test of a worker’s duties, the court’s ruling would shift countless thousands of workers from contractor status to payroll-employee status. Unions and other critics have long complained that rampant “misclassification” has deprived workers of basic rights and benefits, including the ability to unionize.
Gonzalez has introduced Assembly Bill 5, which would codify the decision, known colloquially as “Dynamex” for the package delivery company whose workers, having been classified as contractors, sued and won the right to be employees.

Employers Have Been Pressing for Exemptions

The key part of the Supreme Court’s “ABC” test — already used in many other states — is the declaration that a worker can be classified as a contractor only if he or she performs work that is outside of the usual course of the employer’s business.
Thus, the court ruled, since Dynamex’s delivery drivers are the core of what the company does, they must become employees.
Dynamex is widely seen as a blow to the so-called “gig economy” of companies dependent on part-time workers, with ride services such as Lyft and Uber the best-known examples. Their drivers provide their own vehicles, but the companies make the connection with riders and collect a portion of their fees.
Ever since the decision was issued a year ago, employers — and some contract workers — have been pressing for exemptions.
A coalition of major business groups, headed by the Chamber of Commerce, pledged to support the bill if Gonzalez would agree to broader exemptions and “provide a more progressive and holistic approach that fits today’s modern workforce.”
“The coalition seeks exemptions for workers “who prefer to control their own schedule,” including consultants, travel agents, and truck, taxi and gig economy drivers” and exemptions for “short-term projects and business-to-business contracts.”

The Bill’s Final Shape Is Very Uncertain

Gonzalez has given some ground, agreeing to exempt insurance agents, doctors, stockbrokers, investment advisers, and some salespersons. But there’s a long line of employers and workers in other sectors seeking similar treatment.

“I’m willing to have those discussions. I’m committed to striking a balance.” — Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez (D-San Diego)
“I’m willing to have those discussions,” Gonzalez told the committee. “I’m committed to striking a balance.”
They appeared at the bill’s first committee hearing last week, pledging to support the bill if given exemptions. Many of those seeking relief were owner-operators of heavy trucks, who said they prefer the flexibility and independence of working as contractors.
However, she said the bill needs to “send a message that rings loud and clear — enough is enough,” about misclassification she said is hurting workers and costing the state billions of dollars in potential tax revenue from payroll work. “Something is wrong with the way we’ve allowed these companies to operate.”
The bill cleared the Assembly’s Labor Committee easily, but its final shape is very uncertain.
CALmatters.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media venture explaining California policies and politics. or more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

Say Goodbye to Overpriced Groceries: 6 Hacks to Save Hundreds Each Month

DON'T MISS

From Stories to Work Shirts, How Jim Harbaugh Has Turned Around the Chargers

DON'T MISS

Tulare Police Arrest Canadian Suspect in $130,000 Elder Scam

DON'T MISS

Hall of Famer Kurt Warner’s QB Son Commits to Fresno State

DON'T MISS

Meathead Movers Fill Trucks with Donations for LA Fire Victims. Fresno Can Help

DON'T MISS

Hendrick Motorsports Believes Its Next NASCAR Superstar Is From Clovis

DON'T MISS

Spider Monkey Found in Madera DUI Stop Has a Name: Meet Azules

DON'T MISS

Newsom: Insurance Companies Can’t Cancel or Not Renew Policies of LA Fire Victims

DON'T MISS

Notre Dame Gets Late Pick and Field Goal to Edge Penn State

DON'T MISS

NFL Moves Vikings-Rams Playoff Game to Arizona Due to Wildfires

UP NEXT

Promises to Cut CA’s High Living Costs Clash With Progressive Policies

UP NEXT

If CA Wants to Lead on AI, It Can’t Let 3 Companies Hog the Infrastructure

UP NEXT

Even MAGA Needs Immigrants, It Seems

UP NEXT

Absent Reforms, Progressive Governance May Disappear Across the Globe

UP NEXT

Why 2025 Will Be a Pivotal Year for Mayor Karen Bass and LA

UP NEXT

A Troubling Ruling by a Tulare County Judge on Abortion

UP NEXT

The 2024 High School Yearbook of American Politics

UP NEXT

A History Buff? Take This New Year’s Day Quiz

UP NEXT

Jimmy Carter Deserved Our Thanks and Respect, Not Our Sneers

UP NEXT

Why Mountain Meadows Should Be a Priority for New CA Climate Bond

Hall of Famer Kurt Warner’s QB Son Commits to Fresno State

15 hours ago

Meathead Movers Fill Trucks with Donations for LA Fire Victims. Fresno Can Help

15 hours ago

Hendrick Motorsports Believes Its Next NASCAR Superstar Is From Clovis

16 hours ago

Spider Monkey Found in Madera DUI Stop Has a Name: Meet Azules

16 hours ago

Newsom: Insurance Companies Can’t Cancel or Not Renew Policies of LA Fire Victims

17 hours ago

Notre Dame Gets Late Pick and Field Goal to Edge Penn State

17 hours ago

NFL Moves Vikings-Rams Playoff Game to Arizona Due to Wildfires

17 hours ago

Hamas Hostage Survivor Will Speak in Fresno on Saturday

17 hours ago

Why Was FUSD Interim Superintendent’s Seat Moved at Board Meetings?

18 hours ago

LA Fires Underscore How Much CA Has to Lose if Trump Withholds Disaster Aid

19 hours ago

Say Goodbye to Overpriced Groceries: 6 Hacks to Save Hundreds Each Month

Ask any American about their biggest financial worry for 2025, and the cost of groceries will likely top the list. As household budgets tigh...

53 minutes ago

7 minutes ago

Say Goodbye to Overpriced Groceries: 6 Hacks to Save Hundreds Each Month

13 hours ago

From Stories to Work Shirts, How Jim Harbaugh Has Turned Around the Chargers

13 hours ago

Tulare Police Arrest Canadian Suspect in $130,000 Elder Scam

15 hours ago

Hall of Famer Kurt Warner’s QB Son Commits to Fresno State

15 hours ago

Meathead Movers Fill Trucks with Donations for LA Fire Victims. Fresno Can Help

Corey Day Signs Contract With Hendrick Motorsports
16 hours ago

Hendrick Motorsports Believes Its Next NASCAR Superstar Is From Clovis

The Oakland Zoo's rescue of Azules, a young spider monkey, highlights the dangers of wildlife trafficking and illegal primate ownership. (Oakland Zoo)
16 hours ago

Spider Monkey Found in Madera DUI Stop Has a Name: Meet Azules

17 hours ago

Newsom: Insurance Companies Can’t Cancel or Not Renew Policies of LA Fire Victims

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend