Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Loss of Local News Hinders Ability to Watchdog Government
Bill McEwen updated website photo 2024
By Bill McEwen, News Director
Published 6 years ago on
March 11, 2019

Share

One of the last investigations Jim Boren oversaw before he retired as executive editor of The Fresno Bee was a four-month examination of substandard housing in the city at the heart of California’s Central Valley.

The multimedia project revealed the living conditions imposed on many of the city’s low-income renters, many of them immigrants: apartments filled with mold, mice and cockroaches, to name some of the more glaring problems. Local housing advocates compared it to the tainted water crisis in Flint, Michigan.

“We made people’s lives better. We changed laws.” — Jim Boren, retired executive editor of The Fresno Bee 

The investigation got immediate results.

“We made people’s lives better. We changed laws,” said Boren, who retired in 2017 and is now director of the Institute for Media and Public Trust at Fresno State University.

Among other things, the city responded by requiring property owners to make repairs when it found violations, rather than just levy fines.

“Those are the kinds of things that journalists do,” Boren said.

Local Journalism Is Being Lost in the US

Sunshine Week

It’s the kind of journalism — holding local government officials accountable for problems that affect the lives of real people — that is in danger of being lost in many communities around the country.

Newspapers are closing or being consolidated at an astounding rate, often leaving behind what researchers label as news deserts — towns and even entire counties that have no consistent local media coverage.

According to an Associated Press analysis of data compiled by the University of North Carolina, more than 1,400 towns and cities in the U.S. have lost a newspaper over the past 15 years. Many of those are in rural and lower-income areas, often with an aging population.

The loss of a reliable local news source has many consequences for the community. One of them is the inability to watchdog the actions of government agencies and elected officials.

‘Strong Newspapers Are Good for Democracy’

Newspapers typically have played the lead role in their communities in holding local officials accountable. That includes filing requests to get public records that shine a light on government action — or inaction — or even filing lawsuits to promote transparency.

“Strong newspapers have been good for democracy, and both educators and informers of a citizenry and its governing officials. They have been problem-solvers,” said Penelope Muse Abernathy, a University of North Carolina professor who studies news industry trends and oversaw the “news desert” report released last fall.

“That is what you are missing when you don’t have someone covering you and bringing transparency or sunlight onto government decisions and giving people a say in how those government decisions are made.”

The absence of a local newspaper playing a watchdog role also can translate into real costs to a community and its taxpayers.

The demise of a paper leaves readers in the dark and emboldens elected officials to sign off on higher wages, larger payrolls and ballooning budget deficits, their study found.

Researchers from the University of Illinois at Chicago and the University of Notre Dame found that municipal borrowing costs increase after a newspaper ceases publication. They found the increase had nothing to do with the economy. Rather, the demise of a paper leaves readers in the dark and emboldens elected officials to sign off on higher wages, larger payrolls and ballooning budget deficits, their study found.

“Our evidence suggests that a local government is more likely to engage in wasteful spending when there is no local newspaper to report on that government,” said University of Illinois Chicago’s Dermot Murphy, one of the study’s authors. “Investors find it riskier to lend money to wasteful governments, and thus the costs of financing public infrastructure projects, such as schools, hospitals, and roadways, for a local government are higher.”

Photo of Penelope Abernathy, a professor at University of North Carolina
Penelope Muse Abernathy, a University of North Carolina professor, says that “strong newspapers have been good for democracy, and both educators and informers of a citizenry and its governing officials. Abernathy studies news industry trends. (AP/Gerry Broome)

Stanford University’s James Hamilton applies a wider lens to the problem of newspaper closures, examining the benefits that come with investigative journalism — and what is lost when it disappears.

In his book “Democracy’s Detective,” he examined several case studies of newspaper investigations, including police shootings of civilians, and found that each dollar spent by the news organization generated hundreds of dollars in benefits to society.

“When investigative scrutiny declines, stories go untold, which means waste, fraud, and abuse will be less likely to be discovered,” said Hamilton, director of the Stanford Journalism Program. “News outlets will still have stories about a bad doctor, identified through court cases or patient complaints. The story about a bad hospital, which would require more resources and analysis to document, will be less likely to be told.”

DON'T MISS

Fresno Council Throws Out Plan for South Central, Says It Was Too Strict

DON'T MISS

How Democrat Adam Gray Won His Race, the Last to Be Called in the US House

DON'T MISS

New Coach Matt Entz Promises to Make Bulldog Football ‘Something Special’

DON'T MISS

San Francisco Man Escaped a Merced County Prison 8 Years Ago. He’s Back With New Charges.

DON'T MISS

Fresno Hit-and-Run Big-Rig Driver Sought After Crash

DON'T MISS

She Buys a Ticket to Support a Good Cause, Then Wins the 2024 Granville Home of Hope

DON'T MISS

CA Needs More Water Storage to Handle Boom-or-Bust Cycles

DON'T MISS

Dodgers’ Deferred Payments Top $1 Billion to 7 Players, Including Snell and Edman

DON'T MISS

Feds Close ‘Rape Club’ Women’s Prison in California

DON'T MISS

California Will Appeal Rejection of Lawsuit Over Huntington Beach Voter ID Law

UP NEXT

How Democrat Adam Gray Won His Race, the Last to Be Called in the US House

UP NEXT

New Coach Matt Entz Promises to Make Bulldog Football ‘Something Special’

UP NEXT

San Francisco Man Escaped a Merced County Prison 8 Years Ago. He’s Back With New Charges.

UP NEXT

She Buys a Ticket to Support a Good Cause, Then Wins the 2024 Granville Home of Hope

UP NEXT

Feds Close ‘Rape Club’ Women’s Prison in California

UP NEXT

California Will Appeal Rejection of Lawsuit Over Huntington Beach Voter ID Law

UP NEXT

The NWS Cancels Tsunami Warning for the US West Coast After 7.0 Earthquake

UP NEXT

GivingTuesday Estimates $3.6B Was Donated This Year, an Increase From 2023

UP NEXT

Earthquake Strikes off California; Tsunami Warning Issued

UP NEXT

ICE Looks for a New Detention Center in California. State Probably Can’t Stop It.

Bill McEwen,
News Director
Bill McEwen is news director and columnist for GV Wire. He joined GV Wire in August 2017 after 37 years at The Fresno Bee. With The Bee, he served as Opinion Editor, City Hall reporter, Metro columnist, sports columnist and sports editor through the years. His work has been frequently honored by the California Newspapers Publishers Association, including authoring first-place editorials in 2015 and 2016. Bill and his wife, Karen, are proud parents of two adult sons, and they have two grandsons. You can contact Bill at 559-492-4031 or at Send an Email

San Francisco Man Escaped a Merced County Prison 8 Years Ago. He’s Back With New Charges.

8 hours ago

Fresno Hit-and-Run Big-Rig Driver Sought After Crash

9 hours ago

She Buys a Ticket to Support a Good Cause, Then Wins the 2024 Granville Home of Hope

11 hours ago

CA Needs More Water Storage to Handle Boom-or-Bust Cycles

11 hours ago

Dodgers’ Deferred Payments Top $1 Billion to 7 Players, Including Snell and Edman

12 hours ago

Feds Close ‘Rape Club’ Women’s Prison in California

12 hours ago

California Will Appeal Rejection of Lawsuit Over Huntington Beach Voter ID Law

12 hours ago

The NWS Cancels Tsunami Warning for the US West Coast After 7.0 Earthquake

12 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: Is Fresno’s Project Labor Agreement Meeting Local Hiring Goals?

12 hours ago

‘Embarrassing’: The Lakers Have Lost Their Last 2 Games by a Combined 70 Points

13 hours ago

Fresno Council Throws Out Plan for South Central, Says It Was Too Strict

The Fresno City Council on Thursday rejected a $1 million plan five years in the making that would have determined land use in south central...

7 hours ago

7 hours ago

Fresno Council Throws Out Plan for South Central, Says It Was Too Strict

7 hours ago

How Democrat Adam Gray Won His Race, the Last to Be Called in the US House

8 hours ago

New Coach Matt Entz Promises to Make Bulldog Football ‘Something Special’

A San Francisco man has been indicted after escaping from U.S. Penitentiary Atwater in Merced County and evading capture for eight years. (Wikipedia)
8 hours ago

San Francisco Man Escaped a Merced County Prison 8 Years Ago. He’s Back With New Charges.

CHP is investigating a Fresno hit-and-run where a big rig driver fled after colliding with a pickup at North and Temperance. (CHP)
9 hours ago

Fresno Hit-and-Run Big-Rig Driver Sought After Crash

11 hours ago

She Buys a Ticket to Support a Good Cause, Then Wins the 2024 Granville Home of Hope

11 hours ago

CA Needs More Water Storage to Handle Boom-or-Bust Cycles

12 hours ago

Dodgers’ Deferred Payments Top $1 Billion to 7 Players, Including Snell and Edman

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend