Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Court Urged to End Rule That Erased Hernandez's Conviction
By admin
Published 6 years ago on
November 9, 2018

Share

BOSTON — A legal principle that erased former New England Patriots player Aaron Hernandez’s murder conviction after he killed himself in prison is outdated, unfair and should not stand, a Massachusetts prosecutor told the state’s highest court Thursday.

“He goes through a full trial, a jury who speaks for the public convicts him and because he dies, in this case commits suicide, the whole thing is wiped out like it never happened? It’s not fair or just and should be changed.” — Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn III

It doesn’t make sense the former New England Patriots tight end is now innocent in the eyes of the law just because he died before his appeal could be heard, Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn III said. Quinn is urging the court to reinstate Hernandez’s conviction and do away with the legal principle for future cases.

“He goes through a full trial, a jury who speaks for the public convicts him and because he dies, in this case commits suicide, the whole thing is wiped out like it never happened? It’s not fair or just and should be changed,” Quinn told reporters after the hearing.

Hernandez was found guilty in 2015 of killing semi-professional football player Odin Lloyd. Two years later, the 27-year-old was found dead in his prison cell days after being acquitted of most charges in a separate double-murder case.

A judge threw out Hernandez’s conviction last year, citing the legal principle that holds that a defendant convicted at trial who dies before an appeal is heard should no longer be considered guilty in the eyes of the law, thereby returning the case to its pretrial status.

Hernandez’s Attorney Says There’s Nothing Wrong With the Doctrine

Legal experts say the doctrine, rooted in centuries of English law, requires a conviction not be considered final until an appeal can determine whether mistakes were made that deprived the defendant of a fair trial.

John Thompson, Hernandez’s appellate attorney, told the Supreme Judicial Court that there’s nothing wrong with the doctrine and that the alternatives floated by Quinn are problematic.

“The jury’s decision is not the end-all be-all,” Thompson said. “It is an opinion arrived at by 12 people followed by a process that is subject to defect.”

The Supreme Judicial Court typically takes several months to issue a decision.

How other states handle cases such as Hernandez’s varies widely. Some states, like Massachusetts, toss the convictions, while others dismiss the defendant’s appeal and the conviction stands. Other states allow appellate courts to consider a dead defendant’s case, prosecutors say.

Quinn wants court to allow a defendant’s estate to pursue an appeal, if they wish, otherwise the verdict would stand.

Others Seemed Puzzled Over What to Do

Several justices appeared interested in an approach crafted by the Alabama Supreme Court, which directed the state simply to note in the court record the conviction was neither affirmed nor reversed because the defendant died while the appeal was pending.

“I’m struggling with this because we don’t have any good options.” — Ralph Gants, chief justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

But others seemed puzzled over what to do.

“I’m struggling with this because we don’t have any good options,” said Ralph Gants, chief justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.

Quinn pointed to other high-profile Massachusetts criminals who had their convictions erased after their death, including John Salvi, who was convicted of killing two abortion clinic workers and wounding five other people during a shooting rampage in Brookline in 1994.

Roman Catholic priest John Geoghan, a key figure in the clergy sex abuse scandal that rocked the Boston archdiocese and spread across the globe, also had his child molestation conviction vacated after he was beaten to death in 2003 in his cell at the same Massachusetts maximum-security prison where Hernandez died.

DON'T MISS

When to Catch the Last Supermoon of the Year

DON'T MISS

Trump Chooses New York Rep. Elise Stefanik as Ambassador to United Nations

DON'T MISS

Stock Market Today: Most of Wall Street Rolls Higher as Bitcoin Bounces Above $84,000

DON'T MISS

California Farmers Enjoy Pistachio Boom, With Much of It Headed to China

DON'T MISS

Mattel Says It ‘Deeply’ Regrets Misprint on ‘Wicked’ Dolls Packaging That Links to Porn Site

DON'T MISS

Trump Names Stephen Miller to Be Deputy Chief of Policy in New Administration

DON'T MISS

Justin Herbert Has TDs Passing and Rushing as Chargers Beat Titans for 3rd Straight Win

DON'T MISS

Devastated Democrats Play the Blame Game, and Stare at a Dark Future

DON'T MISS

Moody Shrugs Off 3 Missed FGs to Kick 49ers Past Buccaneers in McCaffrey’s Season Debut

DON'T MISS

Air Force Rushing Dominates Bulldogs, Putting Fresno State’s Season in Jeopardy

UP NEXT

Moody Shrugs Off 3 Missed FGs to Kick 49ers Past Buccaneers in McCaffrey’s Season Debut

UP NEXT

Air Force Rushing Dominates Bulldogs, Putting Fresno State’s Season in Jeopardy

UP NEXT

The Vance Walberg Era of Bulldog Basketball Begins With a Win Over Sac State

UP NEXT

Macklin Celebrini, NHL’s Youngest Player, Scores on Marc-Andre Fleury, League’s Oldest

UP NEXT

Ramsey, Beckham Return to SoFi Stadium When the Struggling Dolphins Visit the Streaking Rams

UP NEXT

Longtime Dodgers Ace Clayton Kershaw Is on the Mend After 2 Surgeries

UP NEXT

Christian McCaffrey Expected to Make Season Debut for 49ers This Week

UP NEXT

New Look Basketball Bulldogs Open at Home. How Will They Fare Under Walberg?

UP NEXT

Americans Seek Fresh Start Abroad as Election Sparks Expat Interest

UP NEXT

With Mountain West Title Out of Reach, What Is Fresno State Playing For?

California Farmers Enjoy Pistachio Boom, With Much of It Headed to China

42 mins ago

Mattel Says It ‘Deeply’ Regrets Misprint on ‘Wicked’ Dolls Packaging That Links to Porn Site

48 mins ago

Trump Names Stephen Miller to Be Deputy Chief of Policy in New Administration

53 mins ago

Justin Herbert Has TDs Passing and Rushing as Chargers Beat Titans for 3rd Straight Win

1 hour ago

Devastated Democrats Play the Blame Game, and Stare at a Dark Future

1 hour ago

Moody Shrugs Off 3 Missed FGs to Kick 49ers Past Buccaneers in McCaffrey’s Season Debut

1 hour ago

Air Force Rushing Dominates Bulldogs, Putting Fresno State’s Season in Jeopardy

1 day ago

How Democrats Helped Trump

1 day ago

Do Trump and Newsom Agree On Anything? Yes, Homeless Encampments

1 day ago

Biden Considers Controversial Pardon for Son Hunter Despite Public Denials

1 day ago

When to Catch the Last Supermoon of the Year

CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — Better catch this week’s supermoon. It will be a while until the next one. This will be the year’s fourth...

10 mins ago

10 mins ago

When to Catch the Last Supermoon of the Year

15 mins ago

Trump Chooses New York Rep. Elise Stefanik as Ambassador to United Nations

19 mins ago

Stock Market Today: Most of Wall Street Rolls Higher as Bitcoin Bounces Above $84,000

42 mins ago

California Farmers Enjoy Pistachio Boom, With Much of It Headed to China

48 mins ago

Mattel Says It ‘Deeply’ Regrets Misprint on ‘Wicked’ Dolls Packaging That Links to Porn Site

53 mins ago

Trump Names Stephen Miller to Be Deputy Chief of Policy in New Administration

1 hour ago

Justin Herbert Has TDs Passing and Rushing as Chargers Beat Titans for 3rd Straight Win

1 hour ago

Devastated Democrats Play the Blame Game, and Stare at a Dark Future

Search

Send this to a friend