Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Commentary: State-County Conflict Could Flare up Again Soon
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
November 4, 2018

Share

When California became the 31st state in 1850, the Legislature quickly created 27 counties to provide basic local services, such as roads, sheriffs and courts, to a sparse, mostly rural population.

Opinion

by Dan Walters
CALmatters Commentary

The conflicts could be papered over as long as counties controlled revenues via property tax rates, but when Proposition 13, which limited property taxes, was enacted in 1978, their dual role became acutely difficult.

Over the next 57 years, as California’s population grew, the Legislature carved up the original 27, some of them quite immense, to form 31 more counties.

Mariposa County, which had originally covered a sixth of the state, eventually became all or part of 12 new counties, but the formation of new counties stopped in 1907 when Imperial County was sliced off San Diego County.

A personal footnote: Glenn County, formed from Colusa County in 1891, is named for my cousin, Hugh Glenn, the “Wheat King of California” and the 1879 Democratic candidate for governor before being murdered in 1883.

Counties’ primary role as local service providers continued until the latter half of the 20th century, when they evolved, not always willingly, into managers of an ever-expanding array of health care and social services created by state and federal governments.

This bifurcated role created obvious conflicts. Local services, such as parks and police and fire protection, were priorities of local voters, but mandates from Washington and Sacramento took budgetary precedence.

County and State Officials Have Staged a Slow-Motion Wrestling Match

The conflicts could be papered over as long as counties controlled revenues via property tax rates, but when Proposition 13, which limited property taxes, was enacted in 1978, their dual role became acutely difficult.

County and state officials have staged a slow-motion wrestling match over finances ever since, with occasional periods of open warfare and others of relative comity. One major blowup occurred in the early 1990s when a severe recession hammered the state budget and then-Gov. Pete Wilson and legislators reacted by stealing, in effect, property taxes from local governments and giving them to the schools, thereby reducing the state’s education aid.

Since then, there have been several “realignments,” a wonky term referring to deals under which the state shifted some programmatic duties to counties, with a shift of tax money to pay for them, and/or relieved counties of some financial burdens.

The most notable example of the latter was the state’s assumption, a couple of decades ago, of the court system’s costs. The last big realignment came early in Gov. Jerry Brown’s current governorship when he and the  Legislature, under pressure from the federal courts to reduce prison overcrowding, redirected new felons into county jails and local probation, along with money to pay for the new burdens.

How have these realignments worked out?

Problems in the State-County Relationship

A new report from the Legislature’s budget analyst, Mac Taylor, cites continuing problems in the state-county relationship, focusing on the original 1991 realignment and its successors.

“Due to the various changes to 1991 realignment programs without corresponding changes to the funding structure, 1991 realignment today no longer meets many of the core principles of a successful state‑county fiscal partnership,” the report concludes.

The jousting between state and counties could flare up again after Brown departs from the Capitol in January.

Another indication of a troubled relationship is found in a new report from State Auditor Elaine Howle about $4 billion in “questionable” payments for medical services to the poor over four years because the state failed to resolve “discrepancies between the state and county Medi-Cal eligibility systems.”

Wonky though they may be, county-state relations affect millions of Californians from poor welfare and Medi-Cal recipients, the latter a third of the state’s population, to those facing felony criminal charges, not to mention taxpayers.

Thus, the jousting between state and counties could flare up again after Brown departs from the Capitol in January.

CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

DON'T MISS

Jack Black Ends Tenacious D Tour After Bandmate’s Trump Shooting Comment

DON'T MISS

JD Vance on the Issues, From Abortion to the Middle East

DON'T MISS

Local Film ‘Camp Terror’ Hits the Streaming Services

DON'T MISS

Man Dies After Rescuing His 2 Children in Mississippi River

DON'T MISS

Is Inflation Finally Corralled? Powell Says Federal Reserve Believes It’s Close

DON'T MISS

New Village Green Park Opens in Loma Vista as Clovis Community Hub

DON'T MISS

Gomez Guilty of Murdering Los Hooligans Bass Player

DON'T MISS

Biden Says It Was a Mistake to Say He Wanted to Put Trump in a ‘Bull’s-Eye’

DON'T MISS

Dealing Blow to Biden’s Reelection Bid, Teamsters Union May Withhold Endorsement

DON'T MISS

Tesla CEO Elon Musk Appears to Confirm Delay in Aug. 8 Robotaxi Unveil Event to Make Design Change

UP NEXT

The Deep Source of Trump’s Appeal

UP NEXT

When Progressive Ideals Become a Luxury

UP NEXT

John Roberts Makes His Bid for Infamy

UP NEXT

Quiq Labs Ongoing Camps Transform Summer Learning for Fresno Unified Students

UP NEXT

End of the Roar: Porsche Bids Farewell to the 718 Internal Combustion Engine

UP NEXT

Does Joe Biden Realize How Angry These Michigan Voters Are?

UP NEXT

How California’s Bureaucracy Prevents Working-Class Transplants from Resuming Their Careers

UP NEXT

George Clooney: I Love Joe Biden. But We Need a New Nominee.

UP NEXT

This Supreme Court Strikes Against Democracy, Again and Again

UP NEXT

Your Get-Out-of-Jail-Free Card Is Ready, Sir

Man Dies After Rescuing His 2 Children in Mississippi River

14 hours ago

Is Inflation Finally Corralled? Powell Says Federal Reserve Believes It’s Close

14 hours ago

New Village Green Park Opens in Loma Vista as Clovis Community Hub

14 hours ago

Gomez Guilty of Murdering Los Hooligans Bass Player

14 hours ago

Biden Says It Was a Mistake to Say He Wanted to Put Trump in a ‘Bull’s-Eye’

15 hours ago

Dealing Blow to Biden’s Reelection Bid, Teamsters Union May Withhold Endorsement

16 hours ago

Tesla CEO Elon Musk Appears to Confirm Delay in Aug. 8 Robotaxi Unveil Event to Make Design Change

17 hours ago

Smittcamp Asks Court to Drop His Lawsuit Against Controversial NW Fresno Project

18 hours ago

Measure P Arts Grants Spark Debate and a Meeting Tonight

18 hours ago

Tedford Exits Fresno State Football. Tim Skipper Is the Next Bulldog Up.

19 hours ago

Jack Black Ends Tenacious D Tour After Bandmate’s Trump Shooting Comment

The comedy rock duo Tenacious D — made up of Jack Black and Kyle Gass — has canceled the rest of their tour after Gass’ remarks about ...

2 mins ago

2 mins ago

Jack Black Ends Tenacious D Tour After Bandmate’s Trump Shooting Comment

18 mins ago

JD Vance on the Issues, From Abortion to the Middle East

3 hours ago

Local Film ‘Camp Terror’ Hits the Streaming Services

14 hours ago

Man Dies After Rescuing His 2 Children in Mississippi River

14 hours ago

Is Inflation Finally Corralled? Powell Says Federal Reserve Believes It’s Close

14 hours ago

New Village Green Park Opens in Loma Vista as Clovis Community Hub

14 hours ago

Gomez Guilty of Murdering Los Hooligans Bass Player

15 hours ago

Biden Says It Was a Mistake to Say He Wanted to Put Trump in a ‘Bull’s-Eye’

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend